3 P91 pipes enduring 5âź6 Ă 104 h service had been found in an ultra-supercritical power plant. Hardness tests, microstructure observation(OM, SEM/EBSD, TEM/EDS) and creep rupture tests were performed, and the relationship between hardness, microstructure and creep rupture strength were discussed. Results showed that 1 of the 3 pipes still featured lath martensite, and its mechanical properties complied with relevant criteria. Other 2 pipes were characteristic of a mixture of ferrite and highly recovered martensite. Their hardness and creep rupture strength experienced severe degradation. Laves phase was observed in all 3 pipes. The most distinctive feature of the 2 low hardness pipes was their coarse and intragranularly distributed M23C6. This might be caused by abnormal heat treatments which could lead to the mixed microstructure of martensite and ferrite, and this kind of microstructure would degrade fast during service. Thus the low hardness had nothing to do with the precipitation of Laves phase.