This paper reports on the use of APOS theory to investigate conceptual understanding of the indefinite integral amongst undergraduate students at the University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. We present a Preliminary Genetic Decomposition (PGD) for the indefinite integral, which predicts the mental constructions and mechanisms that may facilitate conceptual understanding. In this pilot study, the analysis of students’ written responses to the research instrument suggested that more than half of the participants lacked the prerequisite knowledge of the concepts of function, derivative of functions and the chain rule. The findings confirmed that students experience greater difficulty dealing with transcendental functions than with algebraic functions. The analysis indicated that the cognitive mechanism of reversal, to recognise the inverse nature of differentiation and integration, was inconsistent or absent in many students. Interview data from a subset of participants was employed for triangulation with the document analysis. The empirical data suggested refinement of the PGD and modification of the research instrument, and further fine-grained interviews with study participants to investigate their conceptual understanding more deeply, and for the purposes of data triangulation.
Read full abstract