Abstract The objective was to evaluate the effect of birth body weight (BBW) classification on post-weaning growth, dry matter intake (DMI), feed efficiency, and grazing performance of fall-born crossbred heifers. Heifers were classified based on BBW as either light (LtBBW, < -0.5 SD from mean), average (AvgBBW, ± 0.5 SD from mean), or heavy (HvyBBW, > +0.5 SD from mean). Angus and Hereford-sired heifers (n = 153) from commercial Angus dams were utilized in the analysis. Heifers were early weaned at 82 ± 7 days of age. Post-weaning management strategy consisted of calves being kept in partially covered drylot pens and fed a high-energy grain diet (35% dried distillers grains with solubles, 30% whole shelled corn, 30% ground fescue hay, and 5% supplement) in GrowSafe bunks. During the post-weaning evaluation (initiated on day 1), heifer (168 ± 23 kg and 156 ± 7 days of age) DMI was collected for 56 days and body weights (BW) were collected every 14 days. Following the intake evaluation, heifers rotated daily for 166 days though 33 paddocks of 2.4 ± 0.5 hectares each and were weighed every 28 days. Data were analyzed using the MIXED procedure of SAS 9.4. As designed, birth body weight differed (P < 0.01) between classifications (27, 32, and 37 kg for LtBBW, AveBBW, and HvyBBW, respectively). Heifers classified as LtBBW were born earlier (P = 0.02) than AvgBBW and HvyBBW. Heifer BBW classification affected (P < 0.01) weaning weights; heifers classified as LtBBW and AvgBBW had lighter weaning weights than HvyBBW heifers. Birth weight category affected (P < 0.01) BW on days 1, 28, and 56. On day 1, heifers classified as LtBBW were the lightest, AvgBBW were intermediate, and HvyBBW were the heaviest; however, on days 28 and 56, heifers classified as LtBBW were lighter than AvgBBW and HvyBBW. Heifers classified as LtBBW and AvgBBW had less (P < 0.01) DMI and average daily gain (ADG) than HvyBBW during the post-weaning evaluation period. Gain to feed during post-weaning evaluation period was not affected (P = 0.94) by heifer BBW classification. Birth weight category affected (P < 0.01) BW during the grazing season on days 28, 56, 84, 113, 141, 168, 196, and 223. On days 84, 96, and 223, heifers classified as LtBBW were lighter than AvgBBW and HvyBBW; however, on days 113, 141, and 168, LtBBW were lightest, AvgBBW were intermediate, and HvyBBW were the heaviest. During the grazing period, ADG did not differ (P = 0.72) between BBW classifications. In conclusion heavy birth weight heifers had greater post-weaning DMI and ADG when fed a high grain diet; however, grazing ADG did not differ. Heavy birth weight heifers were heavier throughout the duration of the experiment.