Organizational Position Research Articles

Clinical reasoning skill of nurses working in teaching medical centers in dealing with practical scenarios of King’s model concepts

BackgroundThe present study was conducted to determine clinical reasoning of nurses working in teaching medical centers in dealing with practical scenarios of King’s concepts.MethodsThe study population in this cross-sectional descriptive-analytical study comprised 133 nurses. Data were collected using scenarios based on the King’s model. Data were analyzed in SPSS-16.FindingsMean age of the participating nurses was 27.71 ± 8.1 years.The clinical reasoning score was less than average in most participating nurses, and had a significant relationship with education(P < 0.05), service ward(P < 0.001)and organizational position(P < 0.05). In the multivariate analysis of factors relating to clinical reasoning, higher education level (B = 9.5, P = 0.018) and organizational position (B = 4.3, P = 0.017) were predictors of clinical reasoning score.DiscussionExisting nursing models such as King’s, which is closely related to clinical reasoning, can be used more in educational and clinical systems, and as a clinical guide for promoting the clinical reasoning of nurses and students.

Conceptualisation and Determination of the Concept of Creating Shared Value: The Results of a Delphi Study

Objective: The purpose of the article is to present the genesis of the concept of Creating Shared Value (CSV), re-conceptualise it, and point out the main dimensions of value creation. In addition, the article describes the existing interdependencies between the various dimensions and the distinct approaches to defining these dimensions. Research Design &amp; Methods: The article presents the results obtained from an expert survey conducted using the Delphi method. The survey allowed us to obtain experts’ opinions on approaches to defining the creation of shared value and its dimensions. Findings: The results obtained suggest a different approach to understanding and defining the concept of CSV and the dimensions of value creation. In the study experts pointed to the connection of the CSV concept with other management theories and concepts in corporate social responsibility and sustainability. They emphasised the role of creating shared value to different stakeholder groups in the complex internal and external business environment. The difficulty of linking company strategy, business models, and activities with social, environmental, or economic goals was pointed out. Implications / Recommendations: The article presents the results obtained from the first part of a study aimed at constructing a tool to measure the creation of shared value. They are the starting point for both the development of the dimensions of the construct and the factors which can be measured to evaluate the creation of social, economic and environmental value in each dimension. Contribution: The article contributes to the understanding of the concept of CSV as a management theory in the context of enhancing the competitive position of organisations and provides a methodological basis for developing a CSV measurement tool.

Проблемы и возможности медицинского туризма в Челябинской области.

Since January 1, 2019, the Federal project “Development of export of medical services” is being implemented, which is aimed at improving the quality of medical services in the Russian Federation and their promotion on the international market. Despite this, the problems and opportunities of medical tourism remain one of the urgent health problems not only in Russia, but also in the Chelyabinsk region. Through the conducted research, among political, economic, social and technological factors, problems and opportunities affecting the development of the export of medical services in the region were identified. The experts also named the necessary measures for the development and promotion of medical services on the international market Aim: analysis of existing problems in the field of medical tourism and import of medical services offered on the territory of the Russian Federation, and identification of possible prospects for the development of this area of medical activity. Materials and methods. The materials of this study were analytical materials and official statistical data of the FSBI “TSNIIOIZ” of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation. When processing the results, the information and analytical method, the statistical method, the method of questioning and expert evaluation, the method of processing and summarizing information were used. Results. The study involved 50 medical workers holding senior positions in medical organizations of the Chelyabinsk region (heads of structural divisions, chief physicians and deputy chief physicians). The study of the opinion of the study participants on the problems and prospects of the development of medical tourism led to the following results: • Shortage of personnel and material and technical resources is the main constraining factor of development in the provision of medical services to foreign citizens • It is necessary to equip medical organizations with a sufficient amount of medical equipment to increase the level of medical services provided to foreign citizens. The analysis of the external environment revealed political, economic, social and technological factors that hinder and contribute to the development of medical tourism in the country. Thus, the leading political factor contributing to the development of the export of medical services, experts called the support of medical tourism from the state. And the respondents consider the sanctions imposed by the European Union and the United States to be the main negative political factor. Respondents consider the relatively low cost of providing paid medical services as the main economic opportunity for the development of medical tourism. Whereas the main negative economic factor is the increase in the cost of medical devices and medical equipment due to restrictions on the import of imported equipment directly and the emergence of parallel imports. The most important for attracting foreign patients among social factors is the level of qualification of medical personnel, as well as high performance indicators in certain medical areas. Significant social threats, from the point of view of the respondents, is the lack of a unified system of voluntary medical insurance and international accreditation for most medical organizations of the Russian Federation. In order to develop medical tourism and increase the demand for Russian medical organizations among foreign tourists, the participants of the experiment consider it necessary to use the latest treatment technologies and achieve an international level of service, as well as create conditions that will help foreign patients to facilitate obtaining a medical visa. Conclusion. The results of the study made it possible to assess the problems of medical tourism and assess the prospects for development from the point of view of the heads of medical organizations of the Chelyabinsk region, as well as to develop a set of measures for the development of medical tourism in the Chelyabinsk region. The scope of the results. The data obtained will allow us to develop a set of measures aimed at the development of medical tourism in Russia, the adoption of which will help to increase the volume of exports of medical services and the number of treated foreign citizens.

Challenges in Applying IR4.0 Technologies to Improve Organizational Structure and Positions: The Case of Malaysian Public Agencies

Challenges in Applying IR4.0 Technologies to Improve Organizational Structure and Positions: The Case of Malaysian Public Agencies

Examining the complexities of binding international law on international organisations

PurposeThis paper aims to discuss the positioning of international organisations (IOs) in the realm of international law. It proposes a more robust approach, arguing IOs have legal obligations akin to states to the extent which could be fulfilled by them. This paper suggests making IOs parties to international treaties like the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), International Covenant on Economic Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) and Geneva Convention 1949 to codify their international responsibilities. In addition, it proposes amending multilateral treaties to grant IOs membership and create binding legal obligations for them, thereby enhancing the overall legal framework for IOs.Design/methodology/approachThe paper opted for qualitative analytical approach of research by referring to international treaties and scholarly papers.FindingsThe authors have evaluated the bindingness of international law on IOs. The authors argue that jus cogens and customary international law are equally binding on IOs. However, treaties could only be binding on IOs to the extent of their consent. The authors have assessed prior violations of IOs. The authors argue that, to prevent such violations by IOs, creating obligations is the first step. Second, amendments are required in the existing international treaties that reflect the foundations of international humanitarian and international human rights law like the Geneva Convention 1949, ICCPR, and ICESCR, to permit IOs to join these treaties, resulting in binding international legal obligations.Research limitations/implicationsThe most prominent assertion of this paper is that IOs as subjects of international law are bound by the principles of international law, including treaty law with consent, customary international laws, general principles of law and peremptory norms. To fulfil these obligations, a regime needs to be introduced wherein amendment is made in treaties to make IOs parties to them and structuring the law on responsibility for IOs. Considering the multifaceted nature of IO, the role it performs in contemporary times requires them to be bound by rules of international law just like states. There is a need to settle their position in global governance and give them more teeth to understand and fulfil their duties to ensure smooth functioning in the long run.Originality/valueThe paper fulfils an identified gap in the positioning of IOs under the international law.

Problem-Based Learning in Medical Education: A Global Research Landscape of the Last Ten Years (2013-2022).

Problem-based learning (PBL) constructs a curriculum that merges theory and practice by employing clinical scenarios or real-world problems. Originally designed for the pre-clinical phase of undergraduate medicine, PBL has since been integrated into diverse aspects of medical education. Therefore, this study aims to map the global scientific landscape related to PBL in medical education in the last ten years. We combined bibliometrics and network analysis to analyze the metadata of related research articles published between 2013 and 2022 and indexed in the Web of Science Core Collection. Our results show an annual publication rate of 9.42%. The two main journals disseminating research on this subject are BMC Medical Education and Medical Teacher. Education & Educational Research and Health Care Sciences & Services are the two most frequent research areas, and also the two most central nodes of the related network. The USA and China are the most publishing countries, while the Netherlands and Canada are the most collaborative. The Maastricht University holds the position of most publishing and collaborative research organization. The University of California ranks second in publications, while the University of Toronto is the second most central research organization. Our study provides an overview of the last ten years of publications related to PBL and medical education, and we hope it can be of interest to educators, researchers, and students involved with this subject. The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s40670-024-02003-1.

USING LINEAR PROGRAMMING METHODS TO SOLVE PROBLEMS OF OPTIMIZING THE BANK'S ADVERTISING BUDGET

The advertising strategy is one of the most important components of optimizing the bank's business processes. It directly affects the level of profit, demand for services and strengthening the position of a financial organization in the market. This paper discusses the use of linear programming problems to optimize the advertising budget of the bank. To solve the problem of optimizing the bank's advertising budget, a mathematical model was proposed that determines the optimal distribution of the budget between advertising channels, maximizing the number of bank customers, subject to all restrictions. As a result of the experimental analysis, the effectiveness of this technique for optimizing the bank's advertising budget was proved.The main result of this work is the substantiation of the need to optimize the bank's advertising budget, as well as the development of a mathematical model for its implementation. The obtained results make it possible to increase the profitability of a financial institution, increase recognition and trust in the bank by customers.

Explaining the Required Knowledge and Skills for Public Health Undergraduates: a Qualitative Study in Golestan Province

Introduction: Health workers should be trained based on the real needs of the society in terms of quantity and quality, so that af ter graduation, they can be employed in organizational positions related to their field of study and solve the health problems of the society by providing relevant services within their scope of duties. The purpose of this study was to explain the required knowledge and skills for public health undergraduates. Methods: This qualitative study was conducted with the content analysis approach and by holding three focus group discussion sessions with 30 health network managers; managers, heads and experts of the technical groups of the deputy of health and the headquarters of health networks, and health care workers of comprehensive urban and rural health service centers in Golestan province. Data analysis was done using thematic content analysis method and MAXQDA software. Results: After merging the similar codes with each other, finally 55 codes were extracted and classified into 19 subthems and finally categorized into 4 thems. Management information needed by public health graduates included work mission in health, planning and supervision, work ethics and executive processes. Specialized and field information included re-emerging and emerging diseases, population youth, crisis management, mental health, reproductive health, aspects of social health and immunization. The practical skills of individual development included teamwork, communication skills and expression techniques, attracting social participation, using virtual networks and familiarity with information technology. Skills needed to work in the health system included regional situation assessment, operational planning, and first aid. Conclusion: The required knowledge of public health students can be provided by including the results of the study in the educational curricula and in accordance with the new instructions. Also, the combination of practical skills with theoretical topics during academic semesters and paying more attention to internship courses can train public health students according to the needs of the health system.

Analisis Pedagogical Content Knowledge Guru: Faktor Pengaruh PCK Guru PPKn Materi Bhinneka Tunggal Ika

Analisis Pedagogical Content Knowledge Guru: Faktor Pengaruh PCK Guru PPKn Materi Bhinneka Tunggal Ika

Job crafting as retention strategy: An ethnographic account of the challenges faced in crafting new nursing roles in care practice.

Nursing shortages in the global north are soaring. Of particular concern is the high turnover among bachelor-trained nurses. Nurses tend to leave the profession shortly after graduating, often citing a lack of appreciation and voice in clinical and organisational decision-making. Healthcare organisations seek to increase the sustainability of the nursing workforce by enhancing nursing roles and nurses' organisational positions. In the Netherlands, hospitals have introduced pilots in which nurses craft new roles. We followed two pilots ethnographically and examined how nurses and managers shaped new nursing roles and made sense of their (expected) impact on workforce resilience. Informed by the literature on professional ecologies and job crafting, we show how managers and nurses defined new roles by differentiating between training levels and the uptake of care-related organisational responsibilities beyond the traditional nursing role. We also show how, when embedding such new roles, nurses needed to negotiate specific challenges associated with everyday nursing practice, manifested in distinct modes of organising, work rhythms, embodied expertise, socio-material arrangements, interprofessional relationships, and conventions about what is considered important in nursing. We argue that our in-depth case study provides a relational and socio-material understanding of the organisational politics implicated in organising care work in the face of workforce shortages.

For whom the bell (really) tolls: A grounded theory of millennial academic supervisors’ sensemaking of communitarian values as a springboard to enrich their transformational leadership attributes

ABSTRACT The emergence of millennials in strategic positions of academic organizations paved the way for a peculiar execution of leadership practices due to their work ethic and generational stereotypes. Scholars argue that one of the neo-charismatic modalities that they embrace is transformational leadership. By and large, the said leadership paradigm becomes a multifaceted phenomenon if viewed from the specific generational and professional lenses. There is a paucity of studies that discovers its translation on developing countries that imbue a communitarian schema of values. Through a Glaserian grounded theory, the qualitative inquiry purported to provide a model which would uncover the process of sensemaking of communitarian values to enrich the transformational leadership attributes of the millennial academic supervisors. Twenty (20) information-rich cases from various comprehensive universities in the Philippines participated in the inquiry. Interestingly, the study revealed four (4) distinct yet interwoven stages of Build up, Engage in, Lean on, and Live through. The ‘BELL Model of Culturally Sensitive Transformational Leadership Attribute Enrichment among Millennial Academic Supervisors’ can serve as a pragmatic framework that could assist the teacher-leaders hailing from communitarian societies with a scaffolding that resonates with their modern-day sensibilities and celebrates their indigeneity.

Comparison and positioning of NGOs aimed at children from the perspective of social marketing on Twitter

The role of Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) in disseminating and protecting children’s rights is fundamental by increasing society’s knowledge about the reality that children face, thus mobilizing citizen attention. In this paper, we present an original study on social media data, specifically Twitter, to analyze childhood NGOs, evaluating the success of their content (through the likes obtained by publications) from the perspective of social marketing and prospective theory. In addition, it examines the positioning of organizations concerning the types of messages identified. The methodological approach is based on data mining, content analysis, and simple correspondence analysis through which the typology of the messages and positioning map are determined. The results suggest that these organizations generate predictable communication by publishing on specific topics and only increasing the number of tweets in emergencies when they are requiring urgent help. Some tweets show an immediate risk to which children are exposed if they do not receive help, which aligns with one of the premises of the Prospect Theory. Furthermore, a more significant number of posts does not necessarily imply a greater number of likes. Three types of messages have been determined: informative tweets that point out risks (type 1), impartial dialogue tweets (type 2), and action tweets that highlight benefits (type 3), confirmed through the Kruskal-Wallis test to have a relationship with impact. The positioning map shows that type 3 messages, which World Vision Spain opts for, are the most popular, followed by type 1, which Educo leans towards. Finally, there are those of type 2, with which UNICEF Spain is associated. The main implication is that our analysis validates the use of social media such as Twitter to analyze NGOs and proposes these social media platforms to be an important tool in mobilizing the community. In addition, this study offers parameters when constructing the messages for use in social marketing campaigns according to decisions that involve risk or certainty.

Ran-GTP assembles a specialized spindle structure for accurate chromosome segregation in medaka early embryos

Despite drastic cellular changes during cleavage, a mitotic spindle assembles in each blastomere to accurately segregate duplicated chromosomes. Mechanisms of mitotic spindle assembly have been extensively studied using small somatic cells. However, mechanisms of spindle assembly in large vertebrate embryos remain little understood. Here, we establish functional assay systems in medaka (Oryzias latipes) embryos by combining CRISPR knock-in with auxin-inducible degron technology. Live imaging reveals several unexpected features of microtubule organization and centrosome positioning that achieve rapid, accurate cleavage. Importantly, Ran-GTP assembles a dense microtubule network at the metaphase spindle center that is essential for chromosome segregation in early embryos. This unique spindle structure is remodeled into a typical short, somatic-like spindle after blastula stages, when Ran-GTP becomes dispensable for chromosome segregation. We propose that despite the presence of centrosomes, the chromosome-derived Ran-GTP pathway has essential roles in functional spindle assembly in large, rapidly dividing vertebrate early embryos, similar to acentrosomal spindle assembly in oocytes.

Organizational authenticity: How craft‐based ventures manage authentic identities and audience appeal

AbstractResearch SummaryCommercial success in craft‐based industries requires projecting authentic identities but direct claims of authenticity can backfire and raise suspicions of pecuniary motivation, an antithesis to authenticity. Managing authentic identities is thus central to the success of craft‐based ventures. We argue that organizations can shape their audience's perceptions of authenticity and appeal by tacitly and indirectly conveying a resonant identity meaning with visibility and credibility. Our empirical analysis, set in the US craft beer industry, reveals strong support for the idea that craft ventures can raise authenticity and appeal through managing the content/meaning, visibility, and credibility of their identity claims. We discuss the implications of our theory and findings for the role of organizations in the social construction of authenticity and appeal.Managerial SummaryManagers of craft ventures in identity‐driven markets face a strategic challenge in managing growth—how to maintain the authentic identity of their firm as its scale of operations expands. In modern‐day craft industries, consumers covet offerings from firms that they deem authentic but overt claims of authenticity by producers are ineffective. Our study of the craft beer market suggests that managers can leverage strategic assets like organizational resources (ownership structure), capabilities (investment in technology and product variety) and position (third‐party endorsements) to effectively communicate their firm's identity meaning with credibility and visibility. This holds significant practical implications for how managers can successfully navigate the growth process and their firms can continue to be viewed as authentic craft producers even as they increasingly benefit from scale.

DOP03 Gaps between ECCO quality standards of care and the real world: the E-QUALITY survey on processes and outcomes

Abstract Background The European Crohn’s and Colitis Organisation (ECCO) Position Paper on Quality-of-Care (QoC) proposed essential standards on process and outcomes for units that manage patients with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). The E-QUALITY taskforce investigated whether gaps between these standards and real-world practice exist. Methods A 74-question web survey accessible to all institutions affiliated with ECCO was developed. One delegate per institution was requested to respond. A descriptive analysis was done. Results From March to October 2023, 166 centres from 28 different countries replied to the survey (Fig.1). At diagnosis, disease extent is assessed by colonoscopy in 96% and completed by small bowel (SB) evaluation in 43%. At least 2 biopsies from each segment are obtained in 55%. SB investigation for Crohn’s disease (CD) takes place in 60%. 54% of centres provide access to endoscopy with deep sedation for the majority of patients. To assess treatment response, faecal calprotectin is used in 65%, endoscopy in 54%, cross-sectional imaging for CD in 36%. In the case of primary failure of any drug, therapeutic decisions are based on objective measures of inflammation in 98%. A scheduled monitoring protocol for asymptomatic patients is followed in 42%. Patients with prolonged use of corticosteroids are being switched to a steroid-sparing treatment in 84%, but there is no protocol to track or act upon high steroid exposure in 43% of centres. 72% centres monitor metabolic bone health. Only 51% of units screen IBD patients for colorectal cancer, but screening is done with high-definition endoscopy in 92%. Chromoendoscopy with targeted biopsies is performed in only 47% units. Patients with perianal fistula are managed by combined medical and surgical approach in 67%, and reassessment by clinical and endoscopy and/or pelvic MRI is done in 62%. Laparoscopic approach for intra-abdominal surgery is used in 76%, and preoperative nutritional assessment in 62%. Patients receive therapies to prevent post-operative recurrence based on risk factors in 70%, standard endoscopy within 6-12 months after surgery is done only in 52% of centres. Although only 8% of centres lack a defined protocol to manage acute severe ulcerative colitis flares, 13% lack a standard algorithm, and 36% do not involve the surgeon in this setting from day 1. 38% of centres have a paediatric to adult transition clinic. The main reason for not adhering to ECCO standards are difficulty of providing tests in a timely fashion in up to 83% of centres. Conclusion Our survey has revealed significant gaps between ECCO standards and real-world practice. These results will help ECCO improve initiatives to help institutions to provide standard QoC. 1) Fiorino et al. JCC 2020;14:1037-48

Zlecanie wykonywania funkcji administracji państwowej organizacjom społecznym jako forma uspołecznienia działalności państwa socjalistycznego. Wybrane przykłady

Commissioning certain state functions — which consist in transferring the competences held by the state administration to non-state actors (e.g. social organizations) while allowing them to exercise some means of governance while performing said functions — was common practice in socialist states. This led to a shift in the social and political position of organizations of that kind, which in turn strengthened the policital base of a socialist society and ensured the further development of socialist democracy.

Disaster preparedness for tourist village organizers in disaster prone area of Merapi Yogyakarta

Background: A number of tourist villages in Sleman Regency are located in Disaster Prone Area (DPA). To minimize the risks of disasters, preparedness efforts are required. Some of the components of preparedness are: knowledge of disaster risks, polices and guidelines in relation to the preparedness to anticipate the occurrence of natural disaster, emergency plan for natural disasters, disaster alert system, and resources mobilization. Tourist Villages of Pentingsari, Nganggring, and Tunggularum are located in Merapi Disaster Prone Area (DPA). These three tourist villages were selected due to their high vulnerability and risk potential of Merapi eruption due to their locations in DPA III and DPA II. Methods: This is a qualitative study with case study design. The subjects of the study were tourist village organizers who had knowledge and understanding of tourist villages with the criteria of their positions in the tourist village organization. The sample taking technique applied to the subjects was the purposive sampling technique. Results: The level disaster preparedness in terms of knowledge parameter among some tourist village organizers was limited since only few things were understood. In terms of policy and guidelines parameter, these components were not available for the tourist village organizers. With regard to the parameter of emergency plan for the organizers, this component was limited since there were some lack of preparation in a number of components. In relation to the parameter of disaster alert system for the tourist village organizers, this aspect was found to be good. With regard to the parameter of resource mobilization for the tourist village organizers, it was found that this aspect was unavailable since there were not enough decent facilities. Conclusions: the level of disaster preparedness in the disaster prone area of Merapi Yogyakarta was still limited in dealing with the threats of Mount Merapi eruption disaster.

Heterotopias of Citizenship as Spaces of Otherness: The Fluid Boundaries Between We and They

Heterotopia is a neologism proposed by Michel Foucault to describe specific cultural and discursive spaces that mirror real life, yet stand in opposition to it. I propose to look at heterotopia through the lens of youth citizenship that is presented in different forms of self-identification in the discursive practices of the selected youth organisations. The article analyses the discursive language of six Ukrainian youth organisations that appear as spaces of their own, drawing on Foucault’s notion of heterotopia. The task of the article is to examine how these contemporary heterotopias are identified through the language and specific keywords used by their members and how this language defines the space in which their members function, as well as gain insight into the categories of We and They, including their role in self-identification and the delineation of boundaries between the different heterotopias. In this article, I argue that the contexts of the use of the categories We and They with which young people name themselves and separate themselves from non-members of the organisation, have a strong influence on their citizen participation strategies. The empirical results show that organizations position and locate themselves as political and community acting-spaces—heterotopias of citizenship—that have responsibilities and act in accordance with their mission. Although the forms of citizen participation they use vary, their ultimate mission seems to be the same, and may be related to a sense of insecurity caused by a political threat from the Other.

Modular organization of shoot system and ontogenesis of Hedysarum branthii Trautv. &amp; C.A. Mey.

The shoot formation of Hedysarum branthii and ontogeny in natural populations on the territory of the Russian Far East were studied from the position of a modular organization. The structure of three categories of modules (elementary, universal and basic) is described. In different ecological-cenotic conditions were revealed two types of shoot. In the structure of the shoot were identifi ed the 15 types of elementary modules, which form 3 types of universal and 3 types of basic modules. The variability of the basic module is leads to the formation of three type of the life form. The life form, which consists of taproot system and elongated, ascending type of shoot is dominant of the H. branthii and in the Gamotion section of the genus Hedysarum. It has been established that a change in the life form occurs with a change in environmental conditions, namely, the altitude above sea level and the type and humidity of the substrate due to the inclusion of two types of additional adaptive elementary modules.

Examining academic freedom within WB and UNESCO discourses on higher education: A Foucauldian discourse analysis

Academic freedom constitutes an integral part of traditional university values that ensure the proper functioning of universities in pursuing truth and inculcating civic values. In a globalized world where Higher Education (HE) policy is the result of the interaction of local, national, and international levels, the positions of international organizations on questions of academic freedoms deem significant. Within global discourses on HE, literature contrasts the World Bank’s human capitalist to UNESCO’s humanistic approach. Through Foucauldian Discourse Analysis of both organizations’ documents, the paper presented a genealogical analysis of academic freedom that challenged the existence of static, opposite, and binary positions. Transformations, ruptures, juxtapositions as well as gaps, limits, and exclusions were detected within and across International Organizations’ discourses. Juxtaposition of economic and humanistic rationales as well as academic freedom protection and neoliberal policy interventions have muted discursive conflicts and inherent contradictions. The failure of UNESCO to address contemporary threats to academic freedom emerged from the appearance of neoliberal transnational governmentality as an inevitable social regularity that delimits what can be said and cannot be said about academic freedom. Through coercive funding schemes and technologies of differentiation, surveillance, and monitoring, the WB created the space for such transnational governmentality, and placed faculty members under its gaze resulting in undermining academic freedoms and de-professionalization of academics.