Metalloporphyrins are widely used as homogeneous electrocatalysts for the production of renewable fuels from abundant feedstocks and sustainable energy. The modularity of porphyrin catalysts has led to the establishment of structure‐function correlations that aid in predicting and optimizing catalytic activity. Although metalloporphyrins are widely known to aggregate due to their planar structure that promotes π–π stacking, it is surprising that the influence of metalloporphyrin aggregation on electrocatalytic performance has not been previously investigated. Herein, we will document the relative aggregation and electrocatalytic activity for CO2 reduction to CO with three structurally related iron meso-phenylporphyrins in commonly used N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) electrolyte. An inverse dependence of kinetics on catalyst concentration is observed for all three porphyrins based on cyclic voltammetry data. Furthermore, this inhibition extends to bulk electrolysis performance, where up to 75% of the catalyst in a 1 mM solution is inactive compared to in a 0.25 mM solution. This talk will additionally discuss how aggregation is influenced by organic additives, axial ligands, redox state, metal identity, and porphyrin substituents. Overall, this work emphasizes that metalloporphyrins can aggregate severely (even in well-solubilizing organic electrolytes) and that aggregation effects must be considered for optimization of performance and for meaningful catalytic activity comparisons.