The elevated temperature tensile properties of SLM IN718 were measured as a function of strain rate and test temperature to better understand the time-dependent and thermal aspects of environmental sensitivity. SLM and wrought materials were solution treated, aged, and tested over the range of 550–750 °C and 10−3 to 10−6 s−1. The SLM material tested across all conditions had inferior strength and ductility compared to wrought material of the same heat treatment because of environmental sensitivity in the form of dynamic embrittlement. SLM samples show evidence of brittle intergranular fracture, crack growth, and oxidized NbC particles on the fracture surface, which all contribute to the observed poor ductility. These features, and subsequent embrittlement, are intensified with decreasing strain rate and increasing temperature. Higher strain rates and lower temperatures are shown to improve the ductility in SLM IN718 but despite this recovery it remains susceptible to environmental attack even in the extreme cases of the current study. The prevalence of NbC at grain boundaries in the SLM material is the principal source of dynamic embrittlement and environmental sensitivity.