The electrocatalytic carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO2RR) has the potential to convert carbon dioxide to higher value fuels and chemicals, offering a pathway for carbon neutral (or negative) synthesis of carbon monoxide, ethylene, and several other compounds. A common challenge for CO2RR research is driving the selective CO2RR over the competing hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). This key performance metric is quantified by the catalyst’s faradaic efficiency (FE): the number of electrons that go toward producing a specific product divided by the total number of electrons passed during electrolysis.FE is often determined by gas and liquid chromatography. However, these methods have long response times (minutes to hours) and therefore prevent selectivity analysis in real-time. Instead, rotating ring disk electrodes (RRDE) have emerged as a rapid and sensitive method for quantitative CO2RR selectivity measurements with negligible time delays. To date, work has focused on a polycrystalline Au RRDE, especially for bench scale mechanistic studies. The Au disk electrode catalyzes both CO2RR and HER, while the concentric Au ring electrode senses the CO produced at the disk and oxidizes it back to CO2. By comparing the ring and disk currents, FECO and FEHER can be determined using the subtraction method.However, comparison across several works have reported a wide range for FECO values, 60-83%, despite identical conditions: CO2 saturated 0.1 M NaHCO3 (pH = 6.8), Edisk = -0.6 V vs RHE, and rotation at 2500 rpm [A. Goyal, et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc., 142, 4154–4161 (2020); R. E. Vos and M. T. M. Koper, ChemElectroChem, 9, e202200239 (2022)]. This work investigates the possible causes of this poor reproducibility in RRDE selectivity measurements by comparing protocols with different electrochemical methods, reagent purities, and glassware cleaning procedures. Most notably, we observed rapid loss of selectivity toward CO production during chronoamperometry measurements. Lastly, we propose operational bounds for RRDE selectivity measurements on Au under CO2RR conditions and provide our perspective on next steps for developing this into a robust analytical technique.
Read full abstract