Melodies can be recognized (a) by recognition of the exact pitches in the melody and (b) by recognition of melodic contour—the sequence of ups and downs. Recognition memory for brief melodies shows that subjects use process (a) when melodies are repeated without transposition, and process (b) when the melody to be recognized is transposed in pitch. On each trial a pair of computer generated five-note melodies was presented. In different sessions the second melody of the pair was (1) either identical to the first or random; (2) either identical to the first or had the same contour with different interval sizes; or (3) either had the same contour or was random. In separate sessions the second melody was either transposed to another part of the pitch scale or not. Results show that without transposition conditions 1 and 2 are comparable (d′ = 2.8 and 3.0), suggesting that melody recognition is based on exact pitch recognition. With transposition Conditions 1 and 3 are comparable (d′ = 1.7 and 1.5), suggesting that contour recognition is important even in recognizing identical transpositions. Discriminating identical from contour preserving transpositions is difficult (Condition 2, d′ = 0.3). Performance in Condition 3 is comparable with and without transposition (d′ = 1.5 and 1.3).
Read full abstract