Pile Tests Research Articles

Evaluating the Direct CPT-Based Design Methods for Estimating the End Bearing and Side Resistance of Instrumented Test Piles

Evaluating the Direct CPT-Based Design Methods for Estimating the End Bearing and Side Resistance of Instrumented Test Piles

The vertical loading tests of single and group piles by centrifuge modelling

ABSTRACT Pile foundations are widely used for tall buildings, but determining their capacity and behavior under load often involves expensive and lengthy field tests or imprecise numerical models. This research employed a centrifuge to perform vertical loading tests on single and grouped piles in dry sand, subjected to 100 times gravitational acceleration, to investigate pile capacity and load transfer mechanisms. The results from centrifuge modeling, numerical simulations, and field tests were consistent. The total pile capacity for a single pile was 5800 kN/m², while short and long pile groups had capacities of 6800 kN/m² and 9200 kN/m², respectively. End-bearing accounted for 40% of the capacity in single and short pile groups, and 13% in long pile groups. Surface friction was 95 kN/m² for single piles and 140 kN/m² for grouped piles. A method for estimating total pile capacity based on soil properties showed good agreement with empirical results.

Displacement and Internal Force Response of Mechanically Connected Precast Piles Subjected to Horizontal Load Based on the m-Method

Mechanically connected precast piles are a type of precast piles that utilise snap-type mechanical connectors to restrain the pile ends of two identical or different precast piles at the top and bottom so as to quickly realise the purpose of the connection. However, the gap problem in the connectors of mechanically connected piles can lead to uneven and uniform deformation of the piles under horizontal loading, resulting in additional displacements and rotation angles of the piles at the connection. Solving the problem of calculating the internal force response of discontinuous deformed piles is a prerequisite for promoting and applying mechanically connected precast piles. Firstly, the theoretical derivation of mechanically connected piles with fixed constraints at the pile bottom is carried out. Secondly, the pile response equations of mechanically connected piles are established, and the theoretical solutions of pile displacement and internal force response of mechanically connected piles under horizontal loading are derived. Thirdly, the pile-soil model of the test pile is established using ABAQUS software (ABAQUS 2016) in combination with the design data of the test pile. The numerical simulation displacements and angles of rotation are compared with the test results. Finally, the theoretical and numerical simulation displacements and internal forces of the ordinary pile and the mechanically connected pile are compared. The relative errors of the displacements and angles of rotation of the established pile-soil model are less than 10%, indicating that the established model has good accuracy. The relative errors of the theoretical and numerical simulation displacements and internal forces of the mechanically connected pile are less than 10%, proving the correctness of the theoretical calculation by the m-method. This study can provide effective theoretical support and methodological guidance for the displacement and internal force response of discontinuous piles.

Analysis of pile end bearing capacity in Holocene interlayered silty deposits based on CPT soil behavior type index

The existing correlations between pile and cone penetration test (CPT) results often lack versatility for silty geomaterials, as they were primarily developed for clays or sands. To establish meaningful correlations, it is essential to understand the geology of the environment under examination. The CPT and its derived parameters, including the Soil Behavior Type (SBT) index, have proven to provide reliable soil information, particularly in the field of pile foundation engineering. This paper presents the findings and interpretations from several pile load tests conducted alongside field cone penetration tests on a Holocene saline interlayered silty formation, a distinct condition encountered in practice. Various CPT-based pile design methods were employed to evaluate pile capacity based on CPT results. As observed, predictions for pile shaft resistance in this geological formation remained consistent across all methods, while notable variations emerged in estimating pile end bearing. This was inferred to be a result of limited research on pile end bearing capacity in the literature, leading to proposals of broad ranges for pile influence zone and toe coefficient values, as well as various CPT tip resistance averaging techniques across different methods. Consequently, to improve accuracy, modifications based on site-specific test data may be necessary. Drawing from the assessments, effective modifications involved considering the SBT index near the pile tip. Subsequently, the current study introduces a new region-specific adjustment to the widely recognized Enhanced Unicone method based on the SBT index, resulting in a more accurate estimate of pile end bearing in such interlayered silty contexts, with less scatter compared to other available approaches.

STUDI KOMPARASI KAPASITAS DUKUNG RENCANA DAN KAPASITAS DUKUNG AKTUAL FONDASI TIANG PANCANG PADA KONSTRUKSI SLAB ON PILE JALAN TOL SEMARANG – DEMAK SEKSI 2

Semarang - Demak Toll Road Section 2 with a length of 16.31 km crosses the North Coast of Java. The regional geological map shows that the North Coast of Java has alluvial soil layers with clay and silt characteristics. The results of soil investigations show that the depth of the soft layer reaches more than 60 m. This condition triggers construction engineering to support the Highway above it. One of the efforts to fulfill the elevation plan (finish grade) is the flyover concept with slab on pile construction. The planned traffic lane is laid on a concrete slab which is supported by piles with a diameter of 600 mm. With sufficiently deep soft soil layers, the bearing capacity of the foundation piles is borne by the frictional resistance provided by the soil along the piles. This comparative study compares the planned carrying capacity calculated by the empirical formula with the actual carrying capacity of the field as a result of the PDA Test. Calculations were made on 5 test poles for later comparisons were made with the PDA test record data. For the case of 14 days driving at the research location, the pile bearing capacity from the PDA test results is still below the design bearing capacity. The average actual carrying capacity obtained from the 5 test piles is 278 tons. This value is below the planned carrying capacity of the Shio & Fukui method of 381 tons, Meyerhoff's 355 tons, Biaud et al's 777 tons, and Luciano Decourt's 605 tons. At the age of the pile 14 days after the erection was completed, the results of the calculation of the bearing capacity of the Meyerhoff method are closest to the actual bearing capacity of the PDA test results with a ratio of 1.26. The next method is Shio & Fukui with a ratio of 1.36, Luciano Decourt (2.16), and Biaud et al (2.81). Some of the results of previous studies showed a positive correlation between the age after completion of the pile and the frictional carrying capacity. For this type of friction pile, this is of course very influential, so that it is possible that when it is realized that it is carried out with a longer service life, the actual bearing capacity obtained will increase. This requires further research to obtain a time relationship with an increase in pile bearing capacity, especially for locations that have deep soft soil layers such as in this study location.

3D FE simulation of PISA monopile field tests at Dunkirk using SANISAND-MS

This paper presents an investigation into the suitability of the SANISAND-MS model for the three-dimensional finite-element (3D FE) simulation of cyclic monopile behaviour in sandy soils. In addition to previous work on the subject, the primary focus of this study is to further assess the model's capability to reproduce the accumulation of permanent deflection/tilt under cyclic lateral load histories. To this end, experimental data from the PISA field campaign are employed, particularly those emerged from the medium-scale cyclic tests conducted at the Dunkirk site in France. The methodology adopted herein involves calibrating the SANISAND-MS model's parameters to align with 3D FE simulation of a selected monotonic pile test reported by the PISA team using a bounding surface plasticity model partly similar to SANISAND-MS. Subsequently, the soil parameters governing SANISAND-MS’ ratcheting response are calibrated using only minimal information from published PISA field data. While representing the first attempt to simulate the reference data set using a fully ‘implicit’ 3D FE approach, this paper offers novel insights into calibrating and using advanced cyclic models for monopile analysis and design – particularly, with regard to the quantitative influence of pile installation effects and sand's microstructural evolution under drained cyclic loading.

Mechanism of Rapid Curing Pile Formation on Shoal Foundation and Its Bearing Characteristic.

This study explores the application effect of the new non-isocyanate polyurethane curing agent on the rapid curing mechanism and bearing characteristics of piles in beach foundations. Through laboratory tests and field tests, the effects of the curing agent on the physical and mechanical properties of sand were systematically analyzed, including compressive strength, shear strength, and elastic modulus, and the effects of water content and cement-sand mass ratio on the properties of sand after curing were investigated. The results show that introducing a curing agent significantly improves the mechanical properties of sand, and the cohesion and internal friction angle increase exponentially with the sand mass ratio. In addition, the increase in water content leads to a decrease in the strength of solidified sand, and the microstructure analysis reveals the change in the bonding effect between the solidified gel and the sand particles. The field static load tests of single piles and pile groups verify the effectiveness of the rapid solidification pile in beach foundations and reveal the significant influence of pile length and pile diameter on the bearing capacity. This study provides a theoretical basis and technical support for the rapid solidification and reinforcement of tidal flat foundations and provides important guidance for related engineering applications.

Life-cycle-based considerations in design of driven piles in sand

This study conducts a life-cycle assessment to evaluate the environmental impacts of driven shafts across 12 different siliceous sand sites, selected from a database of static load pile tests. Through parametric studies, this paper investigates the influence of soil properties, pile geometry and on-site activities on environmental impacts. For a single pile, the findings demonstrate that material production is the most impactful phase, contributing 88.4% of global warming potential (GWP) per unit capacity, while on-site operations contribute minimally at 1%. Sensitivity analyses show that variations in fuel consumption by ±25% and linear interpolations of blow counts result in negligible difference in GWP (less than 0.1 and 1%, respectively). On average, the total GWPs for steel and concrete piles are approximately 4.3 and 0.92 kg carbon dioxide (CO2) equivalent per kilonewton capacity, respectively. Although various factors influence pile design and installation, the results presented herein provide a foundational framework for geotechnical engineers to integrate environmental impacts into project planning, design and construction considerations.

METHOD FOR CALCULATING THE BEARING CAPACITY OF A SCREW PILE WITH A SPIRAL BLADE BY THE SOIL

Purpose. The purpose of the scientific article is to study and substantiate the principle methodology for calculating the bearing capacity of a screw pile with a spiral blade on the basis of field tests of a prototype pile using existing methods of theoretical calculation of similar piles. Determination of the bearing capacity of a pile with a spiral blade by the soil according to the first limit state. Also, the goal is to determine certain regularities in the modeling of pile structure. Methodology. A metal elements pile is used as a test sample. Determination of the theoretical bearing capacity of the pile in the vertical direction is conducted using formulas and calculation data from Appendix H.5 (DBN B.2.1-10-2009, 2011). The basic solution is that the load-bearing capacity of the pile is achieved due to the adhesion of each individual blade to the soil, which in total reflects the final value of the load-bearing capacity of the pile. Findings. Six experimental piles were installed and tested with static axial compressive and pullout loads. The estimated compressive, pullout and horizontal loads allowed for test piles, turned in to the design mark and tested without soaking subsoils, were determined. In this work, on the basis of experiments, the possibility of using the calculation data existing in the regulatory documentation as a justified theoretical calculation of pile-based foundations in the design of buildings and structures in general with the use of piles with a spiral blade is proven. Originality. A refined mathematical dependence for determining the bearing capacity of a screw pile with a spiral blade by the soil is proposed and the possibility of its use is confirmed experimentally. Practical value. The proposed method makes it possible to substantiate and use screw piles with a spiral blade for pile foundations.

Influence of Settlement on Base Resistance of Long Piles in Soft Soil—Field and Machine Learning Assessments

Understanding the role that settlement can have on the base resistance of piles is a crucial matter in the design and safety control of deep foundations under various buildings and infrastructure, especially for long to super-long piles (60–90 m length) in soft soil. This paper presents a novel assessment of this issue by applying explainable machine learning (ML) techniques to a robust database (1131 datapoints) of fully instrumented pile tests across 37 real-life projects in the Mekong Delta. The analysis of data based on conventional methods shows distinct responses of long piles to rising settlement, as compared to short piles. The base resistance can rapidly develop at a small settlement threshold (0.015–0.03% of pile’s length) and contribute up to 50–55% of the total bearing capacity in short piles, but it slowly rises over a wide range of settlement to only 20–25% in long piles due to considerable loss of settlement impact over the depth. Furthermore, by leveraging the advantages of ML methods, the results significantly enhance our understanding of the settlement–base resistance relationship through explainable computations. The ML-based prediction method is compared with popular practice codes for pile foundations, further attesting to the high accuracy and reliability of the newly established model.

Bayesian Back Analysis of Axially Loaded Pile Response Using Fibre Optic Strain Data

The load-transfer method has been extensively used to evaluate the deformation behavior of foundation piles, with the nonlinear load-settlement behavior of a pile-soil system modeled using load-transfer curves. Although load-transfer models have a considerable impact on the pile response, the model parameters are usually estimated empirically from soil parameters using transformation models, and the associated uncertainties are often neglected. Fiber optic sensing technology provides detailed axial strain information along the entire length of a pile; however, the full potential of such utilization has not yet been realized. This paper presents a Bayesian back analysis method for statistical descriptions of load-transfer curves and pile responses based on fiber optic measurement. A pile test case study is used to illustrate the proposed method, and several candidate model configurations are compared. The results show that the predicted pile response generally matches the measured data, and the quantified uncertainty allows for a better understanding of the possible ranges of the pile response, in addition to the single best-estimate result.

Assessment of the bearing capacity of variable profile piles in soil using static load model tests on a testing apparatus

The paper presents the results of the study of the proposed type of variable profile piles. The proposed type of piles is reinforced concrete driven piles segmented in length. Each subsequent section has a radial displacement along the axis of symmetry relative to the previous section. The positive effect of the performance of the proposed pile is to change the nature of the lateral contact of the pile with the soil, and to increase the drag of the soil. The conducted research is aimed at solving the problem related to the relatively low bearing capacity of traditional square section piles. The research was carried out by the method of model tests of piles on a test bench (tray) at a scale of 1:10. The tests were performed for variant pile types in comparison with a standard square section prismatic pile. The adopted dimensions of the pile model allow the use of this tray without the influence of its boundary conditions on the stress-strain state of the soil. A total of 42 tests were performed, 3 tests for each type of piles compared. Evaluation of pile bearing capacity was performed by static loading of pile models with vertical indentation load until failure. According to the results of the investigations, the resistance values of the compared pile types in the soil were obtained, as well as the dependence of bearing capacity changes on the section dimensions and on the rotation angle. According to the results, the optimal pile solution was selected. The bearing capacity of the proposed optimal pile solution exceeds the bearing capacity of the standard driven pile by 22 %. The results obtained allow us to conclude about the influence of the technological solution of the proposed pile type on its serviceability in soil conditions

Study on Pile Bearing Capacity Improvement in Soft Soil After Vacuum Consolidation

The main problem in developing property over soft soil is significant settlement due to the consolidation process. The soil settlement, which will occur gradually throughout the years, will disrupt existing infrastructures, in this case bridges. To mitigate this issue, the common method is by speeding up the consolidation. The consolidation process must be sped up to avoid the differential settlement problem at the bridge abutments. Due to the limited supply of fill material, a vacuum consolidation method is adopted. In this method, a Prefabricated Vertical Drain (PVD) is installed, and a vacuum is applied to impose pressure as preloading. Because of the consolidation process, theoretically, the effective stress of the consolidated soil increases, and the soil shear strength does as well. Increasing the shear strength of the soils will increases the pile capacity. However, the interesting question is how much the shear strength of the soil can increase and impacts the pile capacity. In this paper, the shear strength improvement of the consolidated soil and the effect on pile bearing capacity is evaluated. This study used a series of in-situ tests that were carried out before and after the vacuum consolidation. A pile loading test using the Pile Dynamic Analyzer (PDA) method was carried out to verify the pile bearing capacity improvements. From the comparison result, it is shown that the theoretical capacity of the piles after consolidation were close to the pile test results.

Analysis of lateral bearing mechanism for offshore monopiles in sand and development of an analytical method

Revealing lateral soil bearing mechanism around an offshore monopile is critical for understanding and solving soil-pile interactions. In this paper, the lateral bearing mechanism around an offshore monopile in sand is analyzed and a corresponding analytical method is established. Three soil bearing mechanisms, including wedge-type flow, triaxial extension and volume compression, near mudline under working load level are proposed by analyzing the distribution of the Lode's angle (θL) and soil displacement vectors. A corresponding analytical method to calculate the lateral response of the monopile is developed based on the strain wedge (SW) model. The proposed model is verified through three pile tests. Finally, the effect of the parameters of Duncan-Chang model on the monopiles in dry and saturated sand is discussed.

Assessment of Axial Resistance of Piles Considering Consolidation Setup and Aging Setup Using Direct Pile Cone Penetration Test Methods

This paper focuses on evaluating the increase in axial pile resistance subjected to both consolidation and aging setups. Consolidation and aging setup models were first developed to estimate the setup parameters based on databases collected from literature, which include 10 instrumented piles for consolidation setup and 26 test piles for long-term aging. The eight top-performing pile cone penetration test (CPT) methods that were evaluated in a previous study were used to estimate the side resistance of soil layers at 14 days after pile driving. The developed consolidation and aging setup models were then used to extrapolate the results to evaluate the side resistance of each soil layer at the end of consolidation and for long-term aging. The estimated side and total resistances were compared with the measurements from pile load tests considering both consolidation and aging setups. The resistances estimated before and after completion of excess pore water pressure dissipation indicates that significant aging takes place after consolidation setup. The value of consolidation setup parameter ( Ac) was 0.53, and, for aging, the setup parameter ( Ag) was 0.23 in clay and 0.16 in sand. The results show that all pile CPT methods with/without using a consolidation setup model tend to underestimate the unit side resistance of clay soil layers. The use of pile CPT methods in combination with an aging model improved the accuracy of pile CPT methods, and this was verified using load test results for five piles subjected to aging. The Philipponnat and University of Florida (UF) methods showed the best performance on estimating the total resistance of piles subjected to aging.

Evaluation of Design Parameters (α and β) for Analysis and Design of Piles on Soft Clays

This paper presents the analyses of 12 prestressed concrete instrumented test piles (TPs) that were driven in different bridge construction projects of Louisiana as part of a load testing program. The 12 TPs were driven mainly in cohesive soils. Detailed soil characterizations including both laboratory and in situ tests were conducted to determine the different soil properties. The TPs were instrumented with vibrating wire strain gauges to be able to calculate the distribution of skin friction and end-bearing capacities separately. Static load tests and dynamic load tests were conducted on each TP after end of driving to calculate the ultimate load capacity. Fifty six soil layers exhibiting clayey soil behavior and sandy soil behavior dominated the remaining 15 soil layers. The total stress parameter (α) and the effective stress parameter (β) were back-calculated for each soil layer. The α values ranged from 0.22 to 1.80, and the β values ranged from 0.11 to 0.83. Regression analyses were performed on 42 soil layers (75% data) to develop an empirical model to predict α as a function of undrained shear strength. The remaining 25% of the data were used to verify the developed model, and good agreement was observed between the measured and predicted values.

Study on load-bearing behaviors of prestressed post-grouting tubular piles in the karst region of northern Fujian Province, China

The karst that is dominated by medium-weathered limestone and caves with various spatial features is widely distributed in the northern Fujian Province. This paper discusses the load-bearing behaviors of post-grouting tubular piles in karst region of north Fujian Province with reference to the prestressed tubular piles adopted in the residential buildings of Haixi Comprehensive Trade City Phase II Project in Sanming City. The load-settlement curve, pile side friction resistance, and pile end resistance of tubular piles are analyzed by finite element numerical simulations and field static load tests. The load-bearing behaviors of prestressed tubular piles under karst geological conditions with two different spatial features are comparatively investigated, and the effectiveness of tubular pile reinforcement is verified by field settlement observation. The results reveal that the finite element numerical model can effectively simulate the tubular pile-soil interaction. The use of pile end post-grouting of prestressed tubular piles in the karst region can significantly increase their load-bearing capacities. The top settlements of grouted tubular piles under the maximum test load can be reduced by 16.8%–22.3% compared with these of ungrouted test piles, and the theoretical simulated ultimate load-bearing capacity can be increased by 27.3%. The adoption of pile end post-grouting technique can reduce the pile end displacement of tubular piles and improve the proportion of pile end resistance. Plastic-hard plastic breccia silty clay can be used as a bearing stratum for post-grouting to achieve excellent grouting performance. The bead-shaped karst caves are more unfavorable to the exertion of load-bearing capacity of the tubular piles than the karst caves filled with plastic-hard plastic breccia silty clay to which the piles have direct access. The field monitored average settlements of the 19# and 17# buildings under karst geological conditions with two different spatial features are −12.88 mm and −8.98 mm, respectively, both of which do not exceed the warning value, indicating that it is feasible for the project to adopt the pile end post-grouting technique of the tubular piles. The achievements of this study help to further reveal the load-bearing mechanism of this type of pile, which can provide a basis for its engineering design and construction optimization.

Centrifuge model tests of h-type anti-slide pile reinforced slope under different rainfall duration

The h-type anti-slide pile (h-pile) plays a crucial role in mitigating soil-rock mixture slope (SRMS) instability. Despite its significance, the limited availability of research outcomes has constrained the practical application of h-piles for SRMS reinforcement. This study employs three centrifuge model tests to investigate the behavior and performance of h-pile-reinforced SRMS under rainfall conditions. We systematically describe the response of earth pressure on the pile side and behind the pile, bending moment along the pile, and pore water pressure at the slope toe and pile side. This elucidates the evolution of soil arching for h-piles under rainfall conditions. The results reveal that rainfall duration influences the distribution pattern of earth pressure on the pile side, while the distribution pattern of bending moment for the h-pile remains unaffected. Additionally, the soil arching pattern between piles demonstrates joint arching, involving the combined action of frictional arching and end-bearing arching. The evolution process of soil arching between piles under rainfall conditions gradually dissipates from bottom to top and from far to near.

Improved Wave Equation Analysis for Piles in Soil-Based Intermediate Geomaterials with LRFD Recommendations and Economic Impact Assessment

The Wave Equation Analysis of Pile Driving (WEAP) has been widely used to determine drivability, predict static resistance, and assure the integrity of piles in soils. Assigning static and dynamic properties of Soil-based Intermediate Geomaterials (S-IGMs) remains a challenge in WEAP, partly attributed to IGMs that act as transition geomaterials between soil and hard rock. Furthermore, reliable static analysis methods for unit resistance predictions are rarely available for driven piles in S-IGMs in the default WEAP method. To alleviate these challenges, this study presents improved WEAP methods for steel piles driven in S-IGMs, including proposed damping parameters and Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) recommendations based on newly developed static analysis methods and the classification of S-IGMs. A back calculation approach is used to generate the appropriate damping parameters for S-IGMs for three distinct subsurface conditions utilizing a database of 34 steel H- and pipe piles. Newly developed WEAP and LRFD procedures are also recommended. Additional independent 22 test pile data are used to compare and evaluate the accuracy and efficiency of the proposed WEAP methods with the default WEAP method. Compared with the default WEAP, bearing graph analysis results revealed that the selected proposed WEAP method, on average, reduces the underprediction of pile resistances by 6% and improves the reliability with a 43% reduction in the coefficient of variation (COV). Calibrated resistance factors for the proposed WEAP method increase to as high as 0.75 compared to the current AASHTO recommendation of 0.50. An economic impact assessment reveals that the proposed WEAP method is more efficient than the default WEAP method as the average difference in steel weight for 32 test piles is 0.06 kg/kN, almost close to zero, reducing the construction challenges in the current engineering practice.

Comparison of Load Transfer Law of Pipe Pile between O-Cell Test and Traditional Static Load Test

In recent years, the detection of offshore pile foundations has received wide attention in engineering. Compared with traditional methods, the O-cell test has unique advantages in offshore pile foundation detection. To study the load transfer characteristics of the O-cell method for pile testing in coastal soft soil foundation, this paper established the pile–soil numerical model to simulate the O-cell and traditional testing processes. The finite element method and equal displacement method are combined to calculate the conversion coefficient and ultimate bearing capacity, and the distribution forms of axial force, side friction resistance, and tip resistance are discussed. The research results show that the O-cell test method and the traditional method have different load transfer forms. By introducing the equal displacement method into the O-cell pile–soil model, the error between the equivalent conversion ultimate bearing capacity and the calculation result of the surcharge method is less than 0.5%, and the O-cell conversion coefficient can be accurately calculated.