Reviewed by: Renaissance Woman: The Life of Vittoria Colonna by Ramie Targoff Marjorie Och Renaissance Woman: The Life of Vittoria Colonna. By Ramie Targoff. (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. 2018. Pp. x, 342. $30.00. ISBN 978-0-374-14094-6.) The title of Ramie Targoff's biography of Vittoria Colonna, Renaissance Woman, alludes to Jacob Burckhardt's celebration of the Renaissance Man. And as Targoff reminds the reader, Burckhardt considered Colonna "the most famous woman of Italy" (p. 8). Vittoria Colonna's fame today rests, for the general audience of this biography, with her friendship with Michelangelo. Targoff goes beyond that expectation and places Colonna within a Renaissance society that identified greatness in family connections and personal accomplishments. Burckhardt would recognize the Vittoria Colonna we meet in these pages and delight in the details of her Renaissance life. But writing the life of an early modern woman is problematic. Like most women of her time, Vittoria's life is known to us primarily through connections her family made for her for the family's profit. It was the death of her husband, Ferrante Francesco d'Avalos, in 1525 that allowed Vittoria to engage as an individual in her own right, or at least as much "right" as a woman could then possess. [End Page 547] Targoff presents Colonna as a significant member of notable courts and ecclesiastical centers. Colonna came of age when it was more likely for a female child to receive some level of education. One gathers from Colonna's later accomplishments as a poet praised by humanists Pietro Bembo and Paolo Giovio that the young Vittoria voraciously consumed biblical and classical texts and developed a critical ear for language. Further, Colonna's friendship and correspondence with Michelangelo suggests her eye was no less cultivated, and Targoff's analysis of their correspondence suggests that Colonna was a demanding as well as discerning patron. The location of Colonna's coming of age was equally auspicious. The heart of Christian Europe, Rome, had long been the center of Colonna family power. Colonna was aware of the secularism of early sixteenth-century popes and was deeply engaged with compatriots who sought Church reform. Targoff presents Colonna as boldly writing of her Christian faith and desire for directness of communication with God. Colonna's writings on the importance of faith combined with good works support Targoff's view that Colonna not only promoted the teachings of her close friends, Bernardino Ochino and Reginald Pole, but also was surely aware of the work of Martin Luther and Juan Valdés. Targoff compellingly presents Colonna as more emotional and sensitive, and hence more human, than the figure we encounter in traditional academic texts. One example stands out. While Colonna shared her poetry with friends in manuscript form, as was customary in the sixteenth century, her sonnets were not printed until a "pirated edition" of 1538 (p. 161). As the first published female poet, Colonna could have responded with trepidation to her sonnets receiving public scrutiny. According to Pietro Bembo, Colonna felt she deserved "'the injury and villainy . . . for worrying about vain things'" (p. 166). Targoff accepts Bembo's account as accurately representing Colonna's response, writing that it was "an act of self-flagellation" to have taken personal joy in her writing. According to Targoff, "the printing of the poems seemed to her a just punishment for wasting her time in the first place" on "'vain things'" (p. 167). But Bembo wrote what his culture expected: that Colonna felt some shame or guilt in being presented in such a public manner. We have no record of Colonna's response to this publication, but she did not stop sharing her sonnets even as it became clear they would be published. The first and still essential biography of Colonna in English is Maud F. Jerrold's Vittoria Colonna, with some account of her friends and her times (1906), which, like Julia Cartwright Ady's Beatrice d'Este, Duchess of Milan, 1475–1497, a study of the Renaissance (1899) and Isabella d'Este, Marchioness of Mantua, 1474–1539, a study of the Renaissance (1903), raised public awareness of great women in history for a British...
Read full abstract