Phage Resistance Mechanisms Research Articles

Homologous Recombination between a Lactococcal Bacteriophage and the Chromosome of Its Host Strain

Genetic exchanges constitute a significant means by which bacteriophages acquire novel characteristics. Phages of Lactococcus lactis occupy a particular niche, the dairy factory environment, where their populations are subjected to constant changes. Little is known about the mechanisms of evolution that lead to the genetic diversity of lactococcal phages. In this study, we described two DNA exchanges involving the lytic phage ul36, a member of the P335 species, and its L. lactis host. They occurred by homologous recombination with phage-related sequences present in the host chromosome. Both mutants generated by these recombination events are insensitive to the phage resistance mechanism AbiK and one has a reduced burst size as well as a new origin of replication. We propose that this type of DNA exchange with prophages or remnants of prophages occurs frequently within the P335 species as supported by DNA-DNA comparisons between P335-like phages.

Genetic analysis of chromosomal regions of Lactococcus lactis acquired by recombinant lytic phages.

Recombinant phages are generated when Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis harboring plasmids encoding the abortive type (Abi) of phage resistance mechanisms is infected with small isometric phages belonging to the P335 species. These phage variants are likely to be an important source of virulent new phages that appear in dairy fermentations. They are distinguished from their progenitors by resistance to Abi defenses and by altered genome organization, including regions of L. lactis chromosomal DNA. The objective of this study was to characterize four recombinant variants that arose from infection of L. lactis NCK203 (Abi(+)) with phage phi31. HindIII restriction maps of the variants (phi31.1, phi31.2, phi31.7, and phi31.8) were generated, and these maps revealed the regions containing recombinant DNA. The recombinant region of phage phi31.1, the variant that occurred most frequently, was sequenced and revealed 7.8 kb of new DNA compared with the parent phage, phi31. This region contained numerous instances of homology with various lactococcal temperate phages, as well as homologues of the lambda recombination protein BET and Escherichia coli Holliday junction resolvase Rus, factors which may contribute to efficient recombination processes. A sequence analysis and phenotypic tests revealed a new origin of replication in the phi31.1 DNA, which replaced the phi31 origin. Three separate HindIII fragments, accounting for most of the recombinant region of phi31.1, were separately cloned into gram-positive suicide vector pTRK333 and transformed into NCK203. Chromosomal insertions of each plasmid prevented the appearance of different combinations of recombinant phages. The chromosomal insertions did not affect an inducible prophage present in NCK203. Our results demonstrated that recombinant phages can acquire DNA cassettes from different regions of the chromosome in order to overcome Abi defenses. Disruption of these regions by insertion can alter the types and diversity of new phages that appear during phage-host interactions.

Phage abortive infection of Bacillus licheniformis ATCC 9800; identification of the abiBL11 gene and localisation and sequencing of its promoter region.

The virulent bacteriophage BL11 infects almost all Bacillus licheniformis strains tested, including the industrial bacitracin-producing B. licheniformis 19. B. licheniformis ATCC 9800, however, was virtually insensitive to phage BL11 infection, and all of the few surviving progeny phages proved to be mutants. The phage-resistance mechanism was neither inhibition of adsorption, nor restriction or exclusion provided by a resident prophage, but was, instead, of another type. Phage BL11 adsorbed well on to ATCC 9800 cells, its DNA was injected, but replication of phage DNA was inhibited and the infected cells died. Thus, the mechanism of phage resistance was identified as abortive infection (AbiBL11). The so-called abiBL11 gene was identified on the chromosome of strain ATCC 9800 by Tn917PF1 transposon mutagenesis. Part of the abiBL11 gene from the phage-sensitive ATCC 9800::Tn917PFI was cloned. Gene-disruption analysis, based on Campbell-type integration, showed that a 0.3-kb EcoRI fragment contained the 5' end of abiBL11. The promoter region of abiBL11 was identified using promoter- and terminator-probe plasmids. The deduced sequence (206 amino acids) of the N-terminal part of abiBL11 showed no significant homology to known abortive-infection genes, but did show homology to a Saccharomyces cerevisiae gene coding for a serine/threonine protein kinase (RCK1).

AbiQ, an abortive infection mechanism from Lactococcus lactis.

Lactococcus lactis W-37 is highly resistant to phage infection. The cryptic plasmids from this strain were coelectroporated, along with the shuttle vector pSA3, into the plasmid-free host L. lactis LM0230. In addition to pSA3, erythromycin- and phage-resistant isolates carried pSRQ900, an 11-kb plasmid from L. lactis W-37. This plasmid made the host bacteria highly resistant (efficiency of plaquing <10(-8)) to c2- and 936-like phages. pSRQ900 did not confer any resistance to phages of the P335 species. Adsorption, cell survival, and endonucleolytic activity assays showed that pSRQ900 encodes an abortive infection mechanism. The phage resistance mechanism is limited to a 2.2-kb EcoRV/BclI fragment. Sequence analysis of this fragment revealed a complete open reading frame (abiQ), which encodes a putative protein of 183 amino acids. A frameshift mutation within abiQ completely abolished the resistant phenotype. The predicted peptide has a high content of positively charged residues (pI = 10.5) and is, in all likelihood, a cytosolic protein. AbiQ has no homology to known or deduced proteins in the databases. DNA replication assays showed that phage c21 (c2-like) and phage p2 (936-like) can still replicate in cells harboring AbiQ. However, phage DNA accumulated in its concatenated form in the infected AbiQ+ cells, whereas the AbiQ- cells contained processed (mature) phage DNA in addition to the concatenated form. The production of the major capsid protein of phage c21 was not hindered in the cells harboring AbiQ.

Phage Resistance Mechanisms in Lactic Acid Bacteria

Dairy fermentations involving Lactococcus lactis and more recently Streptococcus thermophilus, are commonly attacked by bacteriophages. Efforts to protect these dairy starter cultures have resulted in a significant body of knowledge about the bacterio-phages, their interactions with the host, and natural phage defense mechanisms that have evolved within bacteria operating under the most dynamic and devastating phage environment faced by industrial fermentations. This paper will overview this area and discuss the novel genetic approaches that are now being investigated in an effort to provide long term phage protection to dairy starter cultures that are used extensively in the industry.

Isolation, cloning and characterisation of the abiI gene from Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis M138 encoding abortive phage infection

Plasmid pND852 (56 kb) encodes nisin resistance and was isolated from Lactococcus lactis ssp lactis ( L. lactis) M138 by conjugation to L. lactis LM0230. It conferred strong resistance to the isometric-headed phage φ712 and partial resistance to the prolate-headed phage φc2. A 2.6 kb HpaII fragment encoding phage resistance was cloned into the streptococcal/ Bacillus hybrid vector pGB301 to generate pND817. The mechanism of phage resistance encoded by pND817 involved abortive infection and this was illustrated by a reduction in burst size from 166 to 6 at 30°C and from 160 to 90 at 37°C. Partial resistance was therefore retained at 37°C. DNA sequencing revealed that the abortive infection was encoded by a single open reading frame (ORF), designated abiI, encoding a 332 amino acid protein. Neither abiI nor the predicted product showed significant homology to any existing sequence in the GenBank database. Frame shift mutation at the unique EcoRI site within the ORF resulted in loss of the Abi + phenotype, confirming that the ORF is responsible for the encoded phage resistance.

Phenotypic and genetic characterization of the bacteriophage abortive infection mechanism AbiK from Lactococcus lactis.

The natural plasmid pSRQ800 isolated from Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis W1 conferred strong phage resistance against small isometric phages of the 936 and P335 species when introduced into phage-sensitive L. lactis strains. It had very limited effect on prolate phages of the c2 species. The phage resistance mechanism encoded on pSRQ800 is a temperature-sensitive abortive infection system (Abi). Plasmid pSRQ800 was mapped, and the Abi genetic determinant was localized on a 4.5-kb EcoRI fragment. Cloning and sequencing of the 4.5-kb fragment allowed the identification of two large open reading frames. Deletion mutants showed that only orf1 was needed to produce the Abi phenotype. orf1 (renamed abiK) coded for a predicted protein of 599 amino acids (AbiK) with an estimated molecular size of 71.4 kDa and a pI of 7.98. DNA and protein sequence alignment programs found no significant homology with databases. However, a database query based on amino acid composition suggested that AbiK might be in the same protein family as AbiA. No phage DNA replication nor phage structural protein production was detected in infected AbiK+ L. lactis cells. This system is believed to act at or prior to phage DNA replication. WHen cloned into a high-copy vector, AbiK efficiency increased 100-fold. AbiK provides another powerful tool that can be useful in controlling phages during lactococcal fermentations.

The Lactococcal Plasmid pNP40 Encodes a Third Bacteriophage Resistance Mechanism, One Which Affects Phage DNA Penetration

The lactococcal plasmid pNP40 mediates insensitivity to (phi)c2 by an early-acting phage resistance mechanism in addition to the previously identified abortive infection system, AbiF, in the Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis MG1614 background. A second abortive infection determinant on pNP40, AbiE, does not confer resistance to (phi)c2. The early-acting mechanism on pNP40 does not prevent phage adsorption nor does it appear to operate by restriction/modification. Phage DNA was not detected in pNP40-containing cells until 30 min following exposure to (phi)c2 compared with 5 min in a sensitive host; however, electroporation of phage DNA into resistant hosts resulted in the release of phage progeny from a dramatically elevated number of cells compared with conventionally infected hosts. It appears therefore that pNP40 encodes a novel phage resistance mechanism which blocks DNA penetration specifically for (phi)c2.

Characterization of Serratia entomophila Bacteriophages and the Phage-Resistant Mutant Strain BC4B

Successful large-scale fermentations of the bacterium Serratia entomophila for use in biological control of the soil-dwelling insect Costelytra zealandica has required the development of a phage-resistant mutant, BC4B. We report our investigations into S. entomophila phages and the nature of the phage resistance mechanism of strain BC4B. The parental strain of BC4B, A1MO2, was found to contain two previously unidentified prophages, (phi)9A and (phi)9B, which were UV inducible and also released spontaneously in large numbers. BC4B was shown to be completely cured of (phi)9A. Single lysogens of (phi)9A and (phi)9B were not homoimmune to any other S. entomophila phages. However, on the basis of DNA-DNA homology, all S. entomophila phages except (phi)CW3 were shown to have significant regions of homology and also packaged their DNA via pac-like mechanisms. The failure of phage particles to adsorb was identified as the basis of phage resistance in BC4B. In addition, it was demonstrated that all known S. entomophila phages are naturally temperature sensitive.

Expression of a Lactococcus lactis Phage Resistance Mechanism by Streptococcus thermophilus

The 7.8-kb lactococcal plasmid pSRQ700 encodes the LlaII restriction/modification system which recognizes and cleaves the sequence 3(prm1)-GATC-5(prm1). When the plasmid pSRQ700 is introduced into a phage-sensitive Lactococcus lactis strain, strong phage resistance is conferred by the LlaII system. In this report, we show that pSRQ700 cannot replicate in Streptococcus thermophilus. However, if cloned into the vector pNZ123, the native LlaII system is expressed and strong phage resistance is conferred to various industrial S. thermophilus strains. Resistance against phages isolated from yogurt and mozzarella wheys was observed. To our knowledge, this is the first report of increased phage resistance in S. thermophilus.

Restriction-modification systems in lactococcus lactis

Several restriction-modification (R-M) systems have been identified in Lactococcus lactis. Most of the systems have been plasmid encoded and function as phage-resistance mechanisms. At least five different type-II R-M systems, LlaAI, LlaBI, LlaCI, LlaDI and LlaEI, were identified in isolates from a mixed Cheddar starter culture. LlaAI and LlaBI recognized the DNA sequences 5′-↓GATC-3′ and 5′-C↓TRYAG-3′, respectively. The genes coding for the LlaAI and LlaBI R-M systems have been cloned and sequenced. The LlaAI R-M system had two genes coding for methyltransferases (MTases) and one gene coding for a restriction endonuclease (ENase). The MTases showed high homology to the MTases from DpnII. The LlaBI R-M system had one gene coding for a MTase and one gene coding for an ENase.

Molecular genetics of bacteriophage and natural phage defence systems in the genus Lactococcus

Bacteriophage infection of starter cultures used in a range of milk fermentation processes, particularly those involving Lactococcus lactis, poses a significant problem in industrial practice. The application of genetic and molecular technologies to the study of lactococcal bacteriophages has proven to be very rewarding in terms of understanding the nature of phage with respect to their physical and genetic organisation. The availability of the full genomic sequence of a number of phages provides an unambiguous basis for determining the relationship between them, for elucidating their evolutionary progression and will also yield strategies for obstructing successful phage proliferation on previously sensitive hosts. The genetic analysis of phage/host interactions has also highlighted the presence of natural defence systems (e.g. adsorption blocking, inhibition of phage DNA entry, restriction modification and abortive infection) in lactococci. A number of restriction modification systems and abortive infection mechanisms have been characterized at a molecular level and the genes involved have been cloned and sequenced. Plasmid-encoded phage resistance mechanisms can be exploited to generate strains which can successfully counter phage proliferation and will provide a basis for understanding the complex interactions between phages and their target hosts at a molecular level.

Phenotypic variability among cells of Lactobacillus helveticus ATCC 15807

Lactobacillus helveticus ATCC 15807 is a slime-producing, fast milk-coagulating strain. During growth under optimum conditions, it spontaneously produces variants able to ferment mannose (0.01% of the total population), and fructose (0.004%), which then remain stable through several subcultures. These variants did not revert, during our test, to the wild phenotype, whereas those clones unable to ferment fructose and mannose regularly produced fermenting variants. In addition, by using the lytic phage, ATCC 15807-B1, it was possible to determine that 0.004% of the cell population was phage resistant. Adsorption interference was the phage-resistance mechanism involved in these spontaneous mutants. The proteolytic activity was also shown to be heterogeneously distributed among cells of this strain, and it was possible to isolate clones with less and more proteolytic activity when compared with the parent strain. Every variant type retained other phenotypes of the wild-type strain such as cell and colony morphology and slime production. Plasmid DNA content did not seem to be involved in these phenotypic variations. The practical interest of this cell heterogeneity is discussed.

Evolution of a Lytic Bacteriophage via DNA Acquisition from the Lactococcus lactis Chromosome

We discovered a phage-host interaction in which the lytic phage ul36, in response to pressure exerted by an abortive phage resistance mechanism, acquired a large DNA fragment from the chromosome of Lactococcus lactis NCK203 to form a new phage, ul37. Phage ul37 was characterized at morphological, phenotypic, and genotypic levels and was found to be a member of the P335 species. Although it exhibits a high level of DNA homology with ul36, phage ul37 is resistant to the abortive mechanism and has a longer tail, a different base plate, and apparently a different origin of replication. The chromosomal DNA implicated in the formation of new phage ul37 was disrupted by site-specific integration in NCK203. This strategy prevented the appearance of ul37 during subsequent infections with ul36.

Isolation and characterization of large lactococcal phage resistance plasmids by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis

Five phage-resistant Lactococcus lactis strains were able to transfer by conjugation the lactose-fermenting ability (Lac+) to a plasmid-free Lac−L. lactis strain. In each case, some Lac+ transconjugants were phage-resistant and contained one or two additional plasmids of high molecular mass, as demonstrated by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis. Plasmids pPF144 (144 kb), pPF107 (107 kb), pPF118 (118 kb), pPF72 (72 kb) and pPF66 (66 kb) were characterized: they are conjugative (Tra+), they confer a phage-resistant phenotype and they bear lactose-fermenting ability (Lactose plasmid) except for the last two. Plasmids pPF144, pPF107 and pPF118 resulted probably from a cointegrate formation between the Lactose plasmid and another plasmid of the donor strain, whereas pPF72, pPF66 and the Lactose plasmid were distinct in the corresponding transconjugants. Plasmids pPF72 and pPF66 produced a bacteriocin. At 30°C, the phage resistance conferred by the plasmids was complete against small isometric-headed phage and partial against prolate-headed phage, except for pPF107 whose phage resistance mechanism was totally effective against both types of phages, but was completely inactivated at 40°C. Restriction maps of four of the plasmids were constructed using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis.

Effect of Increasing the Copy Number of Bacteriophage Origins of Replication, in trans , on Incoming-Phage Proliferation

Bacteriophage resistance mechanisms which are derived from a bacteriophage genome are termed Per (phage-encoded resistance). When present in trans in Lactococcus lactis NCK203, Per50, the cloned origin of replication from phage phi50, interferes with phi50 replication. The per50 fragment was found to afford negligible protection to NCK203 against phi50 infection when present in a low-copy-number plasmid, pTRK325. A high-copy-number Per50 construct (pTRK323) dramatically affected phi50 infection, reducing the efficiency of plaquing (EOP) to 2.5 x 10 and the plaque size to pinhead proportions. This clone also afforded significant protection against other related small isometric phages. Per31 was cloned from phage phi31 and demonstrated to function as an origin of replication by enabling replication of per31-containing plasmids, in NCK203, on phi31 infection. A low-copy-number Per31 plasmid (pTRK360) reduced the EOP of phi31 on NCK203 to 0.3 and the plaque diameter from 1.5 to 0.5 mm. When this plasmid was cloned in high copy number, the EOP was further reduced to 7.2 x 10 but the plaques were large and contained Per31-resistant phages. Characterization of these "new" phages revealed at least two different types that were similar to phi31, except that DNA alterations were noted in the region containing the origin. This novel and powerful abortive phage resistance mechanism should prove useful when directed at specific, problematic phages.

Analysis of phage resistance mechanisms encoded by lactococcal plasmid pAJ2074

Lactococcal plasmid pAJ2074 is a 74-kb plasmid that confers phage resistance at 30 °C against all lactococcal phages with prolate heads (referred to as prolate phage), and most small lactococcal phages with isometric heads (referred to as small isometric phage) that have been tested. The presence of pAJ2074 had no effect on phage adsorption or injection of phage DNA. Replication of prolate phage c2 DNA could not be detected in bacterial cells containing the plasmid up to 60 min after phage infection, whereas phage c2 DNA replication could be demonstrated at 20 min in the control strain. With pAJ2074 present there was no detectable growth of phage c2 and an 87% reduction in burst size for the small isometric phage sk1. Infective centres were reduced in the presence of pAJ2074 by 99% for phage c2 and by 93% for phage sk1. Plasmid pAJ2074 differed from pTR2030, in that the major effect of pAJ2074 was on prolate phage c2, rather than on the small isometric phage sk1, and no restriction and modification system could be detected. In addition, no DNA homology was detected between pAJ2074 and pTRK67 (derived from pTR2030). A recombinant plasmid pAJ88 containing an 8.4-kb insert from pAJ2074 conferred an intermediate level of phage resistance. The DNA region that encoded reduced phage sensitivity was further defined by the subcloning of a 5.6-kb EcoRV fragment that conferred resistance similar to pAJ88. The possibility of two phage-resistance mechanisms being encoded by pAJ2074 is discussed.Key words: phage resistance, lactococcal phages, lactococcal plasmids, lactococci.

Differentiation of Two Abortive Mechanisms by Using Monoclonal Antibodies Directed toward Lactococcal Bacteriophage Capsid Proteins

Monoclonal antibodies were used to monitor the accumulation of the major capsid protein of the lactococcal small isometric bacteriophage u136 (P335 species) over the course of a one-step growth curve. A sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay was then used to distinguish two abortive phage resistance mechanisms, Hsp and Prf. Capsid protein production of u136 was almost totally inhibited by the Hsp-induced abortive mechanism, supporting previous data that this mechanism blocks phage DNA replication. Prf-induced abortive infection only partially (50%) inhibited capsid protein production, suggesting that this mechanism targets some other point, perhaps within transcription or translation processes. The results confirmed that Hsp and Prf act at different targets in the phage lytic cycle. Use of monoclonal antibodies also demonstrated that production of the major capsid protein is a nonlimiting step in the lytic cycle of lactococcal phage u136.

Deriving Phage-Insensitive Lactococci Using a Food-Grade Vector Encoding Phage and Nisin Resistance

Plasmid pFK012 is a potential food-grade vector comprising only lactococcal DNA, and it encodes bacteriophage insensitivity and nisin resistance. Efforts were made to transform several lactococcal strains with pFK012 via electroporation. Nisin-resistant transformants were selected on M17 agar containing .5% glucose and 300 IU of nisin/ml. Southern hybridization analysis of plasmid pools of the transformants using a nisin resistance probe confirmed the presence of pFK012. Two plasmid-free strains (Lactococcus lactis ssp. lactis LM0230 and MG1363) were successfully transformed and evaluated for phage sensitivity. Wild-type lactococcal strains were more difficult to transform, although two acquired pFK0l2 (L. lactis ssp. lactis C2 and SK2). These transformants acquired an abortive phage resistance mechanism, were stably maintained at 21 and 37°C after 100 generations, and retained the same rate of acid production as the parental strains. The difficulty in transforming parental strains could be related to incompatibility of plasmids or to restriction of incoming DNA. In this study, L. lactis ssp. lactis H1 was found to be naturally resistant to nisin but did not produce nisin. The plasmid pool from H1 was found to contain a plasmid that had strong homology with a nisin resistance probe.

Cloning, expression, and sequence determination of a bacteriophage fragment encoding bacteriophage resistance in Lactococcus lactis

A number of host-encoded phage resistance mechanisms have been described in lactococci. However, the phage genome has not been exploited as a source of additional resistance determinants. A 4.5-kb BamHI-HindIII fragment of phage nck202.50 (phi 50) was subcloned in streptococcus-Escherichia coli shuttle plasmid pSA3 and introduced into Lactococcus lactis NCK203 and MG1363 by protoplast transformation. This cloned phage fragment directed a bacteriophage resistance phenotype designated Per (phage-encoded resistance). Both phi 50 and a distantly related phage, nck202.48 (phi 48), formed small plaques on strain NCK213 at a slightly reduced efficiency of plaquing on the Per+ host. The per locus was further reduced to a 1.4-kb fragment through in vitro deletion analysis. The 1.4-kb fragment was sequenced, and the Per phenotype was found to be associated with a ca. 500-bp region rich in direct and inverted repeats. We present evidence that the Per region contains a phage origin of replication which, in trans, may interfere with phage replication by titration of DNA polymerase or other essential replication factors. It was demonstrated that the Per+ phenotype is not a result of reduced adsorption or action of a restriction and modification system. Per+ activity was not detected against six independent phages which were previously shown to be sensitive to the Hsp+ mechanism. The mutually exclusive resistance mechanisms could be combined to confer resistance to both types of phages (Hsp resistant and Per resistant) in a single host. This is the first description in lactococci of a phage resistance phenotype, other than superinfection immunity, originating from a lactococcal phage genome.