pH Gradient Ion Exchange Chromatography Research Articles

A generic method for intact and subunit level characterization of mAb charge variants by native mass spectrometry

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are heterogeneous macromolecules that display a complex isoform profile as a result of the large series of modifications they can undergo. Product-related charge variants that are associated with a loss of biological activity or affected half-life and immunogenicity are especially important. Consequently, they are often considered critical quality attributes such that acceptance criteria and controls should be established. The characterization of mAbs charge variants has long been a time and resource consuming task. Recent successes in the use of salt mediated pH gradient ion exchange chromatography with volatile mobile phases have shown there to be significant promise in using online mass spectrometric (MS) detection to facilitate peak detection.In this study, a newly developed 3 µm non-porous cation exchange column technology was investigated for its capability to be hyphenated to MS for the purpose of characterizing mAb charge variants. A 2 mm ID format was selected for the ease of configuring it to classical MS ESI ion sources. A monoclonal antibody reference material from NIST (RM 8671; NISTmAb) was used in its intact and IdeS/IgdE-digested forms to test for column performance and MS sensitivity. Furthermore, three different mAbs with highly basic isoelectric points (pI) were analyzed in their native and proteolyzed forms to demonstrate the straightforward application of the developed technique even with mAbs having strong retention on cation exchange media. The MS detection of low-abundance charge variant species (<0.1%) demonstrated there to be acceptable sensitivity and dynamic range even from routine analyses. The capability of the column to separate different mAbs having high basic pI was demonstrated, and it was found that slight adjustment of ammonium acetate concentration in the eluent can be a convenient way to rapidly optimize a separation if necessary. Linearity was shown to exist between protein mass loads of 2.5 and 50 µg while an optimal balance between chromatographic resolution and MS sensitivity was observed between 5 and 10 µg. Excellent run-to-run and column-to-column repeatability was achieved in terms of retention times, resolution and recovery.

Semiautomated pH gradient ion-exchange chromatography of monoclonal antibody charge variants.

A new approach using a chromatography system equipped with isocratic pumps and an electrolytic eluent generator (EG) is introduced, replacing external pH gradient delivery using conventional gradient systems, in which bottled buffers with preadjusted pH are mixed using a gradient pump. The EG is capable of generating high purity base or acid required for online preparation of the buffer at the point of use, utilizing deionized water as the only carrier stream. Typically, the buffer was generated from online titration of a reagent composed of low molecular weight amines. The reagent was delivered isocratically into a static mixing tee, where it was titrated to the required pH with electrolytically generated base or acid. The required pH gradient was thus conveniently generated by electrically controlling the concentration of titrant. Also, since the pH was adjusted at the point of use, this approach offered enhanced throughput in terms of eluent preparation time and labor, and with a more reproducible pH profile. The performance of the system was demonstrated by running pH gradients ranging from pH 8.2 to 10.9 on a polymer monolith cation-exchange column for high throughput profiling of charge heterogeneity of intact, basic therapeutic monoclonal antibodies. A high degree of flexibility in modulating the key parameters of the pH gradient, including the buffer concentration, the pH gradient slope and the operating pH range was demonstrated. This enabled fine-tuning of the separation conditions for each individual antibody in order to enhance the chromatographic resolution.

Analytical characterization of complex, biotechnological feedstocks by pH gradient ion exchange chromatography for purification process development

The accelerating growth of the market for proteins and the growing interest in new, more complex molecules are bringing new challenges to the downstream process development of these proteins. This results in a demand for faster, more cost efficient, and highly understood downstream processes. Screening procedures based on high-throughput methods are widely applied nowadays to develop purification processes for proteins. However, screening highly complex biotechnological feedstocks, such as complete cell lysates containing target proteins often expressed with a low titre, is still very challenging. In this work we demonstrate a multidimensional, analytical screening approach based on pH gradient ion exchange chromatography (IEC), gel electrophoresis and protein identification via mass spectrometry to rationally characterize a biotechnological feedstock for the purpose of purification process development. With this very simple characterization strategy a two-step purification based on consecutive IEC operations was rapidly laid out for the purification of a diagnostic protein from a cell lysate reaching a purity of ∼80%. The target protein was recombinantly produced using an insect cell expression system.

Systematic generation of buffer systems for pH gradient ion exchange chromatography and their application

pH gradient protein separations are widely used techniques in the field of protein analytics, of which isoelectric focusing is the most well known application. The chromatographic variant, based on the formation of pH gradients in ion exchange columns is only rarely applied due to the difficulties to form controllable, linear pH gradients over a broad pH range. This work describes a method for the systematic generation of buffer compositions with linear titration curves, resulting in well controllable pH gradients. To generate buffer compositions with linear titration curves an in silico method was successfully developed. With this tool, buffer compositions for pH gradient ion exchange chromatography with pH ranges spanning up to 7.5 pH units were established and successfully validated. Subsequently, the buffer systems were used to characterize the elution behavior of 22 different model proteins in cation and anion exchange pH gradient chromatography. The results of both chromatographic modes as well as isoelectric focusing were compared to describe differences in between the methods.

Combining multidimensional liquid chromatography and MALDI–TOF-MS for the fingerprint analysis of secreted peptides from the unexplored sea anemone species Phymanthus crucifer

Sea anemones are sources of biologically active proteins and peptides. However, up to date few peptidomic studies of these organisms are known; therefore most species and their peptide diversity remain unexplored. Contrasting to previous venom peptidomic works on sea anemones and other venomous animals, in the present study we combined pH gradient ion-exchange chromatography with gel filtration and reversed-phase chromatography, allowing the separation of the 1–10kDa polypeptides from the secretion of the unexplored sea anemone Phymanthus crucifer (Cnidaria/Phymanthidae). This multidimensional chromatographic approach followed by MALDI–TOF-MS detection generated a peptide fingerprint comprising 504 different molecular mass values from acidic and basic peptides, being the largest number estimated for a sea anemone exudate. The peptide population within the 2.0–3.5kDa mass range showed the highest frequency whereas the main biomarkers comprised acidic and basic peptides with molecular masses within 2.5–6.9kDa, in contrast to the homogeneous group of 4–5kDa biomarkers found in sea anemones such as B. granulifera and B. cangicum (Cnidaria/Actiniidae). Our study shows that sea anemone peptide fingerprinting can be greatly improved by including pH gradient ion-exchange chromatography into the multidimensional separation approach, complemented by MALDI–TOF-MS detection. This strategy allowed us to find the most abundant and unprecedented diversity of secreted components from a sea anemone exudate, indicating that the search for novel biologically active peptides from these organisms has much greater potential than previously predicted.

Characterization of the basic charge variants of a human IgG1

We report a case study of an IgG1 with a unique basic charge variant profile caused by C-terminal proline amidation on either one or two heavy chains. The proline amidation was sensitive to copper ion concentration in the production media during cell culture: the higher the Cu2+ ion concentration, the higher the level of proline amidation detected. This conclusion was supported by the analysis of samples that revealed direct correlation between the proline amidation level observed from peptide maps and the level of basic peaks measured by imaged capillary isoelectric focusing and a pH gradient ion-exchange chromatography method. The importance of these observations to therapeutic antibody production is discussed.

PH-gradient ion-exchange chromatography: An analytical tool for design and optimization of protein separations

This work demonstrates that a highly linear, controllable and wide-ranged pH-gradient can be generated through an ion-exchange chromatography (IEC) column. Such a pH-gradient anion-exchange chromatography was evaluated with 17 model proteins and found that acidic (p I < 6) and basic (p I > 8) proteins elute roughly at their p I, whereas neutral proteins (p I 6–8) elute at pH 8–9 regardless their p I values. Because of the flat nature of protein titration curves from pH ∼6 to ∼9, neutral proteins indeed exhibit nearly zero net charge at pH ∼9. The elution-pH in pH-gradient IEC or the titration curve, but not the p I, was identified as the key parameter for pH optimization of preparative IEC in a fast and rational way. The pH-gradient IEC was also applied and found to be an excellent analytical tool for the fractionation of crude protein mixtures.

Two-dimensional capillary liquid chromatography: pH Gradient ion exchange and reversed phase chromatography for rapid separation of proteins

In the present work, an orthogonal two-dimensional (2D) capillary liquid chromatography (LC) method for fractionation and separation of proteins using wide range pH gradient ion exchange chromatography (IEC) in the first dimension and reversed phase (RP) in the second dimension, is demonstrated. In the first dimension a strong anion exchange (SAX) column subjected to a wide range (10.5-3.5) descending pH gradient was employed, while in the second dimension, a large pore (4000 Å) polystyrene-divinylbenzene (PS-DVB) RP analytical column was used for separation of the protein pH-fractions from the first dimension. The separation power of the off-line 2D method was demonstrated by fractionation and separation of human plasma proteins. Seventeen pH-fractions were manually collected and immediately separated in the second dimension using a column switching capillary RP-LC system. Totally, more than 200 protein peaks were observed in the RP chromatograms of the pH-fractions. On-line 2D analysis was performed for fractionation and separation of ten standard proteins. Two pH-fractions (basic and acidic) from the first dimension were trapped on PS-DVB RP trap columns prior to back-flushed elution onto the analytical RP column for fast separation of the proteins with UV/MS detection.

Isoelectric point separation of proteins by capillary pH-gradient ion-exchange chromatography

In the present work, isoelectric point (p I) separation of proteins by pH-gradient ion-exchange chromatography (IEC) on packed capillary columns is demonstrated. The development of a miniaturized flow-through pH probe for reliable pH monitoring of the column effluent, which was an important technical challenge for adapting this technique to capillary dimensions, was solved by designing a low microliter per minute flow rate housing to a commercially available micro pH probe. Highly linear outlet pH-gradients within the pH range 8.5–4.0 were obtained when applying simple inexpensive buffers consisting solely of piperazine, N-methylpiperazine and imidazole on 10 cm×0.32 mm i.d. fused silica capillaries packed with anion-exchange poly(styrene divinylbenzene)-based macroporous materials, i.e. 10 μm Mono P from Amersham Biosciences and 10 μm PL-SAX from PolymerLabs. Furthermore, when using a pH-gradient from 6.8 to 4.3, both columns were able to baseline separate the A and B genetic variants of β-lactoglobulin, which differ with two amino acid residues only, but the PL-SAX column provided almost a two-fold decrease in peak widths compared to the Mono P column. The influence of varying the buffer concentration, injection volume and column temperature on the peak widths and resolution of the β-lactoglobulins was investigated, e.g. a 100 μl sample of dilute β-lactoglobulins was injected directly on the column with practically no increase in peak width as compared to what obtained with conventional injection volumes. Finally, a pH-gradient from 6.8 to 4.3 was used to separate proteins in skimmed bovine milk on the PL-SAX column. The milk was simply diluted 1:10 (v/v) with water and filtrated before injection.

Refolding human lysozyme produced as an inclusion body by urea concentration and pH gradient ion exchange chromatography

A new dual-gradient ion exchange chromatographic method was developed to improve the refolding yield of human lysozyme produced inEscherichia coli as an inclusion body. The dissolved and stretched polypeptide chain in a concentrated non-ionic denaturant was adsorbed onto an ion exchange column and induced to refold by gradually decreasing the denaturant concentration and increasing pH in the flowing buffer. The dual gradients of denaturant concentration and pH provided a gradual change of the solution environment along the chromatographic column for the protein to refold, resulting in enhanced activity yield and purity. A post-separation was also studied using size-exclusion chromatography to remove protein aggregates and mis-folded proteins after the refolding step.

The use of pH-gradient ion-exchange chromatography to separate sheep liver cytoplasmic aldehyde dehydrogenase from mitochondrial enzyme contamination, and observations on the interaction between the pure cytoplasmic enzyme and disulfiram.

1. Sheep liver cytoplasmic aldehyde dehydrogenase can be purified from contamination with the mitochondrial form of the enzyme by pH-gradient ion-exchange chromatography. The method is simple, reproducible and efficient. 2. The purified cytoplasmic enzyme retains about 2% of its original activity in the presence of a large excess of disulfiram. This suggests that the disulfiram-reactive thiol groups are not essential for covalent interaction with the aldehyde substrate during catalysis, as has sometimes been suggested. 3. Between 1.5 and 2.0 molecules of disulfiram per tetrameric enzyme molecule account for the observed loss of activity, suggesting that the enzyme may have only two functional active sites. 4. Experiments show that disulfiram-modified enzyme retains the ability to bind NAD+ and NADH.