374 SEER, 84, 2, 2oo6 James, Beverly A. Imagining Postcommunism: VisualNarratives of Hungary's I956 Revolution. Texas A&M UniversityPress,College Station, TX, 2005. xii + 20I pp. Illustrations.Notes. Bibliography.Index. C36.95. BEVERLY JAMESis Professor of Communication at the University of New Hampshire.Basedon interviewsand archivalresearch,as well as a wide range of theoreticaland secondarysources,thisis a book which will be welcomed by anyone interestedin contemporaryHungary. However, it will also be of interest to studentsof post-Communismmore generally,since it raisesissuesabout historicaljustice and reconciliationwhich are relevant throughoutthe region (asindeed in allpost-authoritariansocieties).Imagining Postcommunism containsa wealth of excellent backgroundmaterialwhich will make the book accessible to readerswho do not have a specializedknowledge of Hungary. The museums and statuesdiscussedare: the House of Terror in Budapest, honouring the victims of Communism and Fascism; the 1956 exhibition at Budapest'sMilitaryHistoryMuseum;the privately-owned1956 Museum near Kiskunmajsa;the Statue Park Museum on the outskirts of Budapest; the memorial commemorating Ilona Toth, a medical student executed for supposed murder of a secret policeman during the Revolution, and unveiled by the Minister ofJustice in 2000; the I996 statue of Imre Nagy, standingnear the Parliamentbuilding;and two statuesno longer in place: the 26-foot-high Stalin which was torn down duringthe Revolution, and the Memorial to the Martyrsof the Counter-Revolutionwhich has been removed from Republic Square in Budapestto the Statue ParkMuseum. Of course this is not a complete list of new Hungarian memorials and museums- the site of the I989 Pan-EuropeanPicnic by the Austrianborder, and the labour camp at Recsk spring to mind as other fascinatingexamples. James, however, has chosen to focus on sites linked specificallyto the revolution of I956, which, she argues, has been taken as the 'foundationalmyth' (p. 5) in post-CommunistHungary. The main focus of the book, as the title suggests, is on post-Communist narratives interpretationsof the Communistpastwith which contemporary Hungariansshape understandingsof the present. Such narrativesare created not only by sculptors,historiansand other artistsand intellectuals,but also by politicians, activists(often veterans of 1956),and the ordinarypublic.James suggeststhat the symbolismof I956 has been importantpartlyjust because of the pacted and peacefulqualityof the transitionin I989. 'The transformations that were negotiated in I989 afforded no opportunity for the courageous, heroic actions associated with 1956 and, perhaps for that reason, symbolic action became the main strategyfor stakingout political and moral positions' (p. I69). Hence, for example, the passing of a Law on the Memory of the Revolution in I990. With referenceto the role of politicalparties,for example,James opens the book with a discussionof the House of Terror, opened six weeks before the parliamentaryelections of 2002 and interpretedas an attempt by the Fidesz (Young Democrat) government to discredittheir Socialist opponents by linking them to atrocitiesof the Communistera. The Socialistsproposedchanging the name to House of Reconciliationbut droppedthe idea, aftertheir election REVIEWS 375 victory,when Fidesz threatenedto mobilize millions of demonstratorsagainst the change (p. 4). Zigzags in public assessmentsof the Communist past reflect the pattern of alternatingsocialistand centre-rightgovernmentsin Hungary since I990 but, at a deeper level, link to ambiguous attitudes towards Hungary's comparativelyliberalpost -I956 Communistregime. It is interestingthat Fideszfelt that millions could be mobilized on this issue.James illustratesthe mixed opinions of ordinaryHungarianswith referenceto an opinion poll askingBudapesters to name people they associated with I956. Although most mentioned Imre Nagy, only 56 per cent considered him a 'positive' actor. Discussing the controversyover Tam'asV'arga'sstatueof the executed PrimeMinister,James explores why it is that Nagy has not achieved the status of 'postcommunist foundationalhero' (p. I47)despite the extraordinarysymbolic significanceof his public reburialinJune I989. James also discusses many dilemmas which are not specific to Hungary. There is the issueof whether some crimesaremore heinous than others are Fascistatrocitiesunderrepresentedin the House of Terror?The desirabilityof a dispassionateapproachis also implicitlyquestioned:the even-handednessof the official I956 exhibit in the MilitaryMuseum is contrastedwith the more moving but partisan approach of Gergely Pongratz in his private I956 museum. Although its main focus in on post-Communism, the book includes many vignettes of the Communist period -the terrorof the unfortunatesculptors commissioned to design the Stalin statue, or the ironic attitude of the public towardsgrandiosememorialswhich were given irreverentnicknamesand used as meeting places and landmarks. The book is generously illustrated,with forty-two photographs...