Reviewed by: Affiliated Identities in Jewish American Literature by David Hadar Naomi Taub (bio) Affiliated Identities in Jewish American Literature. By David Hadar. New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 2020. ix + 216 pp. "How do we know what we know about authors?" David Hadar asks at the start of Affiliated Identities in Jewish American Literature. "My answer," he quickly supplies, "is that we know them through the networks in which they are a node" (2). He then sets about mapping the networks of some of the best-known contemporary Jewish American authors, explicating their identity work and deconstructing their public identities in both text and paratext. In this, Hadar chooses his interlocutors effectively—they include the sociologists Erving Goffman and Bruno Latour, as well as cultural theorists Mark McGurl, Dan Miron, Harold Bloom, and Edward Said—though he omits voices like Marianne Hirsch, whose concepts of filiative and affiliative postmemory are intimately related [End Page 413] to his theoretical base. The bulk of Affiliated Identities is dedicated to Philip Roth, both the affiliations and public identity Roth crafted for himself as well as those others have projected onto him. Working through many of Roth's texts, Hadar produces a comprehensive catalog of Roth's literary network. As thorough as Hadar's treatment of Roth's public identity may be, his early chapters fail to tap the rich vein of political and cultural histories of post-World War II Jewish America. He often seems curiously incurious about the public itself, about the broader context in which this identity work was performed. In discussing The Counterlife, for example, Hadar asserts that when Zuckerman's brother absconds to the West Bank, "the family setting makes Zuckerman face issues (Israeli politics, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict) that otherwise would not enter his consciousness with any real force" (25). The Counterlife, however, takes place mere weeks after the Camp David Accords, a moment when, as many historians have demonstrated, these issues had a great deal of "real force" in the Jewish American psyche. Such an oversight matters precisely because part of the project's stated intention is to deconstruct Roth's engagement with the American Jewish public sphere, which, both in 1978, the year in which the novel is set, as well as in 1986, the year in which the novel was published, devoted plenty of attention to Israel/Palestine. The more relevant (and perhaps more interesting) question would be why Roth needed to, or at least decided to, mediate his commentary on such an exigent issue by filtering it through a familial conflict. Indeed, the most engaging parts of Affiliated Identities come when Hadar makes a point of bringing in historico-political context. His review of how the Israeli reception of Jewish American texts evolved along with attitudes toward Zionism offers several cogent insights. He also effectively critiques the persistence of the masculinist framing of the Diaspora/Zion binary and renders an intriguing portrait of how the characterization of Israelis in Jewish American literature shifted around the turn of the twenty-first century. Yet while his network theory of Jewishness is helpful, Hadar's approach is often strained to the point of breaking when he attends to non-Jewish authors. The prime example is the chapter on Israeli Palestinian author Sayed Kashua, whom Hadar accuses of "us[ing] Roth to be Jewish and not Jewish at the same time," thereby "[a]ligning and misaligning himself with Roth" as part of a "longterm project of marking himself as… deserving the attentive reading that goes along with the literary authority he seeks" (153). For a non-Jewish author, neither the desire to be legible to a Jewish audience nor identifying with a Jewish author necessarily translates into a desire to be or to be seen as Jewish, and [End Page 414] the political implications of such a claim are more or less unexplored. What's more, Hadar's linguistic and referential choices seem to imply throughout that Kashua has committed some kind of crime: for example, he refers to Kashua's column on meeting Roth as "misprision," a deceitful or treacherous act often meant to cover up knowledge of a felony. The sole example of ethnic passing in Israel...
Read full abstract