THE recognition that aluminum contaminated dialyzate was responsible for dementia and osteomalacic bone disease led to the expectation that with suitable water treatment, aluminum storage, and, on occasion, intoxication, would be eliminated. I -5 Instead the epidemiology has changed so that sporadic cases are occurring rather than the clusters seen previously. 5-8 This represents an indication of the more gradual, insidious exposure to aluminum by the oral rather than by the dialyzate route. In areas such as our own where dialyzate has always been essentially aluminum free, 26 out of 47 patients or 55 % on dialysis for at least one year have stainable bone aluminum. All except three had taken oral aluminum compounds and these had negative staining. The prescription of oral aluminum salts, usually the hydroxide (AI(OHh), has been widely employed once it was shown that hyperphosphatemia was pivotal in the progression of the secondary hyperparathyroidism of end-stage renal disease (ESRD). It is necessary then to examine the major determinants of serum phosphorus in patients on renal replacement therapy. These would include residual renal function, bone resorption, dietary phosphorus, dialysis prescription, and, finally, dose of Al(OHh. Residual renal function, urine volume, and, hence, solute excretion are generally insignificant in patients on dialysis. The few with creatinine clearances of 4 to 6 mLimin will see these decline following the initiation of dialysis. The subjects own excretory function for phosphate (although not necessarily for water and other solutes) can therefore usually be ignored. Increased rates for bone resorption are characteristic of secondary hyperparathyroidism and would lead to increased flux of calcium and phosphate into extracellular fluid. Hypercalcemia, while it does occur, is uncommon and because calcium and phosphorus are found in a fixed ratio in apatite, hyperphosphatemia also would be infrequent. The reason for this anomaly is the coupling of formation to resorption so that although more bone is removed more is also formed at roughly equal rates. A further consideration is that if hyperphosphatemia is in fact responsible for secondary hyperparathyroidism then the finding of high serum phosphate levels are not necessarily the result of the parathyroid hyperactivity leading to augmented bone turnover but rather the cause. This is probably the reason for the previous report of higher serum phosphorus levels in patients with overt hyperparathyroidism when compared to those without, although several in the former group were hypercalcemic. 9 In our data, 39 patients were divided on the basis of their bone histology into either absent or minimal hyperparathyroidism (17 patients) or active disease (22 patients). Predialysis serum phosphorus was 6.2 ± 0.3 in both groups. Agreement with these propositions means that dietary phosphorus intake and the dialysis prescription for most patients are the only important parameters determining the predialysis serum phosphorus levels, in addition to oral AI(OHh intake. Any attempt to decrease AI(OH)3 intake will necessitate changes in either dietary phosphorus and/ or the amount of phosphorus removed by dialysis. Dietary phosphorus intake in the usual European and North American diet is quite high and the decreased incidence of renal osteodystrophy in Israel was reported to be associated with lower protein and phosphorus intakes and lower serum phosphorus values. lo In the National Cooperative Dialysis Study (NCDS) mean dietary phosphorus during the control phase for the 162 subjects was 879 mg/d with a standard deviation of 248 mg. II This indicates that a proportion of these selected compliant patients were ingesting more than 1,000
Read full abstract