On-task Behavior Research Articles

Improving Behavior in a Self-Contained Elementary Classroom for Students With Emotional or Behavioral Disorders: A Study of CW-FIT

Class-wide Function-related Intervention Teams (CW-FIT) is a classroom management intervention in which teachers incorporate positive behavior support (PBS) principles by teaching specific classroom expectations and providing feedback on student behavior as part of an interdependent group contingency. Interventions like CW-FIT may be helpful for students with emotional or behavioral disorders (EBD), as such students often struggle to succeed in school. In the present replication study, researchers examined the effects of CW-FIT in a self-contained elementary EBD classroom. One teacher and her five students with EBD participated. Researchers used an A-B-A-B withdrawal design with maintenance probes to examine changes in students’ on-task behavior, as well as teacher praise and reprimand rates. Results revealed the teacher was able to implement CW-FIT with fidelity with corresponding increases in student on-task behavior and teacher praise, though there was little effect on teacher reprimands. The teacher and the students found CW-FIT to be socially valid. Results suggest CW-FIT can be an effective classroom management intervention in self-contained elementary EBD classrooms.

Behavior-specific praise: Enhancing on-task behavior in a rural elementary school

Behavior-specific praise (BSP) is a low-intensity strategy used to reinforce positive student behaviors in school settings. BSP is currently a potentially evidence-based practice, with more studies with three or more participants needed to contribute to the literature base. This study investigated the impact of teacher-delivered BSP on student on-task behavior in an inclusive second grade classroom taught by a general and special education coteacher dyad in a rural Southeast school. Using an A-B-A-B withdrawal design, we observed the on-task behavior of four students with emotional and/or behavioral disorders (EBD) when the coteaching pair increased their rates of BSP after a brief training. All four students increased on-task behavior during BSP intervention conditions. Social validity questionnaires identified a positive impression from three out of four students and both teachers about the implementation of BSP in the classroom. Limitations and future directions are discussed.

Remote Microphone Systems for Autistic and Nonautistic Youth: Effects on Audiovisual Task Engagement

Objectives: A recent study has provided empirical support for the use of remote microphone (RM) systems to improve listening-in-noise performance of autistic youth. It has been proposed that RM system effects might be achieved by boosting engagement in this population. The present study used behavioral coding to test this hypothesis in autistic and nonautistic youth listening in an ecologically valid, noisy environment. Design: We drew on extant data from a recent experimental study in which 56 youth (32 autistic, 24 nonautistic) matched at the group level on age and biological sex completed listening-in-noise tasks wherein they reported their perception of audiovisual syllables, words, sentences, and passages with and without an RM system; conditions were counter-balanced across participants. As previously reported, perceptual accuracy varied with stimulus complexity and overall improved with the RM system, with improvements not significantly different between groups. Video recordings of participants completing listening-in-noise tasks in both conditions were coded via a 5-second, partial-interval coding system by naive coders for (a) engagement in the task (indexed via proportion of intervals in which participants displayed on-task behaviors) and (b) verbal, stimulus-specific protesting in the task (indexed via proportion of intervals in which participants displayed verbal, stimulus-specific protesting behaviors). Examples of on-task behaviors included attending to the screen and completing task activities. Examples of protesting behaviors included complaining about stimuli volume or the inability to hear. Chronological age, autism features, language ability, audiovisual speech integration as measured by psychophysical tasks, tactile responsiveness, and nonverbal intelligence quotient were evaluated as putative predictors and/or moderators of effects on behaviors of interest. Results: In general, participants were highly engaged in the task, and there were few protests, reflecting more than 90% and fewer than 0.5% of coded intervals, respectively. We did not detect any statistically significant effects of group or RM system use on task engagement. Nonautistic youth were engaged in the listening-in-noise task for an average of 97.45% of intervals, whereas autistic youth were engaged in the listening-in-noise task for an average of 94.25% of intervals. In contrast, verbal, stimulus-specific protesting in the listening-in-noise task was significantly reduced, on average, in the RM (0.04% of intervals) versus the No RM (0.2% of intervals) conditions. There were no effects related to group for this behaviorally coded outcome. In addition, select participant characteristics predicted engagement within conditions across participants. Greater language ability and nonverbal intelligence quotient predicted increased engagement when not using an RM system. Increased features of autism and wider temporal binding windows for audiovisual speech predicted reduced engagement while using an RM system, and greater audiovisual integration predicted increased engagement while using an RM system. Conclusions: The results of this study suggest that RM system use reduces verbal, stimulus-specific protesting, which likely reflects difficulty engaging when listening in noise. The present study extends our previous study to provide additional empirical support for RM system use in autistic and nonautistic youth.

The use of visual schedules to increase academic-related on-task behaviors of individuals with autism: a literature review

A literature review was conducted to examine the existing studies on visual schedules to increase academic-related on-task behaviors for individuals with autism. Systematic searches of electronic databases and reference lists identified 10 studies meeting the inclusion criteria. These studies were evaluated in terms of the effectiveness of visual schedules based on (a) participant characteristics; (b) intervention settings and activities; (c) independent variables including visual schedule forms, presentation modes, and other methods or strategies combined with visual schedules; (d) research design and measures; and (e) generalization, maintenance, and social validity. Also, the methodological rigor of each study in this review was assessed (e.g. against Reichow’s evaluation standards). The results provided evidence that visual schedules could be utilized in combination with other strategies or methods, especially prompting and reinforcement, to increase the academic-related on-task behaviors of individuals with autism. Seven studies reported social validity, six studies programmed for generalization, and four studies reported maintenance effects. According to Reichow’s evaluation standards, six studies met strong criteria and one study met acceptable criteria, indicating that they provide good evidence for the effectiveness of VS on the academic-related on-task behaviors of individuals with autism. Implications and suggestions for practitioners and researchers are provided.

Comparison of synchronous reinforcement and accumulated reinforcement for increasing on-task behavior in preschoolers.

In synchronous-reinforcement schedules, the duration of behavior directly controls the duration of reinforcement on a moment-to-moment basis. We replicated and extended Diaz de Villegas et al. (2020) by comparing the effects of synchronous reinforcement with two accumulated-reinforcement schedules for increasing on-task behavior for seven preschoolers. One accumulated schedule was the same as the one used in Diaz de Villegas et al. and did not include tokens, whereas the other accumulated schedule included the delivery of tokens within session. Furthermore, we assessed preference for the three reinforcement schedules. The results showed that synchronous reinforcement was effective for increasing on-task behavior for all seven participants. Furthermore, it was most effective for increasing on-task behavior for three out of seven participants and preferred by all participants. For some participants, other schedules were also similarly effective. The results are discussed with respect to implications for application.

Increasing the Duration of On-Task Behavior in Children with Borderline Intellectual Functioning through Shaping Techniques

This study aims to investigate and apply behavior modification principles, specifically using shaping techniques, to increase the duration of on-task behavior in children with Borderline Intellectual Functioning (BIF). The techniques used include antecedent control, reinforcement through token economy, and providing prompts to the participant. This study uses a single-subject design conducted over a total of 22 intervention sessions. The participant in this study is an 8-year and 7-month-old boy with BIF. The results of the study indicate an increase in the average duration of on-task behavior from 19 minutes in the initial measurement (pre-test) to 64 minutes in the final measurement (post-test) and 54 minutes in the follow-up measurement. It can be concluded that behavior modification principles, specifically using shaping techniques, can help to improve on-task behavior duration in children with Borderline Intellectual Functioning.

Evaluating the Effects of Self-Monitoring of Performance with a Peer Component on Disruptive Behavior and Task Completion of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder.

Self-monitoring (SM) is a widely used intervention to address a myriad of problem behaviors exhibited by individuals with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and other disabilities (e.g., specific learning disability). SM of performance (SMP) interventions have been effective in increasing task completion and on-task behaviors in the general education setting. However, most of the research on SM interventions has been completed in a school setting, and few have evaluated the inclusion of a peer mediator component within a SM treatment package. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of a SMP intervention on disruptive behavior and task completion in three children with ASD. This study extends previous research by incorporating a peer mediator component, including children with ASD, and implementing the intervention in a clinic setting. The results show that the SM treatment package was effective, as the level of disruptive behavior and task completion improved for all three participants compared to baseline levels.

Cultivating Compassion in Jewish-Israeli Kindergartners: The Effectiveness of Mindfulness- and Empathy-Based Interventions As Facilitators of Compassion

ABSTRACT We examined the effectiveness of a mindfulness-based intervention (MBI) compared to a social-emotional empathy-based intervention (EBI), and a passive control group in promoting compassion among Jewish-Israeli kindergartners. Three middle-class public kindergartens were randomly assigned to the MBI (n = 26;M age = 5.03), EBI (n = 24;M age = 5.02), or control groups (n = 24;M age = 5.16; N girls = 40). The interventions lasted 12-weeks. Pre- and post-intervention, children’s cognitive compassion was assessed utilizing computerized continuous performance tasks for attention/impulsivity, and structured observations of attention to teacher and on-task behaviors; emotional compassion was measured with structured observations of prosociality, negative affect, social-emotional difficulties, and aggression; intentional and actual compassion was measured using a compassionate responding paradigm. Research Findings: Results showed that MBI participants decreased impulsivity and improved sustained attention, increased attentiveness to the teacher, and reduced social difficulties and aggression – these effects did not appear for either other group. Additionally, the MBI and EBI participants increased prosociality and compassionate behaviors more than the control group, however the magnitude of change from the MBI was significantly larger. The MBI increased cognitive, emotional, intentional, and behavioral skills and understanding that are essential components necessary to engage in compassion. Practice or Policy: MBIs can be effectively led by teachers and integrated into school curriculum to facilitate just and caring educational communities.

Fostering Autonomy: A Technology-Aided Check-In/Check-Out Intervention for Online High School Students With Autism

Many students diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) encounter difficulties related to self-management, which subsequently hinder their capacity to actively engage in online learning. As the enrollment of students with ASD in online education continues to rise, the exploration of self-management techniques adaptable to this educational modality becomes imperative. However, the existing body of research in this area remains limited. To bridge this gap, the present study aimed to evaluate the efficacy of a technology-aided Check- In/Check-Out (CICO) intervention to promote on-task behavior among three students with ASD attending online high school. A multiple baseline across participants design was used to measure the percentage of ontask behavior for each student. The findings suggest the implementation of the CICO intervention increased on-task behavior of all three students. This investigation underscores crucial considerations for devising and implementing personalized interventions within the context of online learning environments. The study’s constraints are acknowledged, and recommendations for prospective research avenues are outlined.

Implementation and Outcomes of Outdoor Science Education in an Urban Setting on Primary and Intermediate Level Students with Emotional and Behavioral Disorders

The term nature deficit disorder describes the “human costs of alienation from nature” (Louv, 2019). While not meant to be a medical diagnosis, Louv argues that the condition has, “profound implications, not only for the health of future generations but for the health of the earth itself” (Louv, 2008). Children most at risk are those who live or go to school in an urban setting, as well as students diagnosed with Emotional and Behavioral Disorders (EBD). Students diagnosed with EBD are often kept indoors as their teachers and caretakers are frequently trained in the indoor use only of behavior management techniques (Riden et al., 2022). This means that during professional development training, any that pertain to behavior management techniques, procedure, or protocol are routinely taught inside of a classroom, conference room, or recently home office, using an indoor scenario (classroom, auditorium, cafeteria, etc.) as an example of when and how to use these behavior management tools. Outdoor professional development, equipping students with natural tools that can help improve not only their physical but also their mental health, as well as connecting students with nature in a way that teaches them to advocate for the health of the earth, thus becoming citizen stewards are all themes that are part of the massive, currently dysfunctional system that is outdoor education in schools. This study shows that when students are encouraged to interact with nature on their own terms on-task behaviors and motivation increase. Students also retained lesson information and asked follow-up questions after the lesson when taught outside using hands-on activities.

The datafication of student engagement and children's digital rights

In this commentary paper, I will introduce the concept of engagement data. I define engagement data as the digital metrics, calculations and visualisations that are deemed to give an insight into students’ on-task behaviour, their participation, their perceived capacity to pay attention, or their (technical) interactions with an educational platform. These kinds of data are common in Learning Management Systems and learning content platforms on which schools increasingly rely. The categories of engagement data discussed in this paper include time spent on-task, task completion, contribution, and biometric data. Besides conceptualising engagement data, this paper invites both scholars and educators to reflect critically on the datafication of engagement. I will argue that engagement data only offer a limited, quantified idea of student engagement and that this has far-reaching implications for children's digital rights. Children's behavioural data is harvested without their explicit consent or knowledge. These engagement data then become prescriptive constructs used for monitoring and accountability purposes, ignoring children's voice in relation to their own (dis)engagement.

Physically active learning for children with learning disorders attending special-needs schools: A program evaluation

BackgroundPhysically active learning (PAL) is a potentially valuable method to stimulate academic performance and physical activity (PA) in children with learning disorders (LD) attending special-needs schools. It is yet unknown whether PAL can be successfully implemented in special-needs schools. AimsThis study aimed to evaluate a PAL-program in special-needs schools by examining teacher’s dose delivered, children’s dose received, and associations of children’s characteristics with dose received. MethodsChildren (N = 37) from two special-needs schools participated in a six-week PAL-program. Dose delivered was evaluated based on PAL-lessons’ implementation rate and duration. Dose received was assessed through time-on-task observations (n = 23) and PA (n = 37). To assess the association between dose received and children’s characteristics (sex, behavioral disorders, motor skills, and physical fitness), Mann-Whitney U tests and Spearman’s rho correlations were used. ResultsFor teacher’s dose delivered, the implementation rate exceeded 95%, and the PAL-lessons lasted the intended 12 minutes. For dose received, children’s on-task behavior was above 79%, and children spent 43% of the time in moderate-to-vigorous PA during PAL. Motor skills were positively related to on-task behavior related to the movements, and physical fitness was positively related to moderate-to-vigorous PA. ConclusionsPAL was successfully implemented in terms of dose delivered and dose received for children with LD attending special-needs schools.

Managing Student Behavior in Middle School Special Education Classrooms: A Single-Subject Study of CW-FIT

Teachers have the responsibility of managing student classroom behavior. The positive effects of evidence-based classroom management methods, like Class-Wide Function-related Intervention Teams (CW-FIT), have been demonstrated in a variety of settings; however, research on the efficacy of CW-FIT in special education classrooms is scarce. The purpose of this study was to determine the effectiveness of CW-FIT in two middle school special education math classrooms. Teachers implemented CW-FIT by instructing students in classroom behavior expectations and using a group contingency involving the use of teams, a timer, praise, points, and group rewards. One teacher alternated between using an audible and inaudible timer, while the other used an audible timer. There was an increase in student on-task behavior and teacher praise when CW-FIT was implemented, with no significant difference in outcomes between conditions with an audible versus inaudible timer. Teachers and students indicated that they found the intervention to be socially valid.

Adding to the Evidence Base: Effects of I-Connect in a Secondary Special Education Rural Classroom

The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of a technology-based self-monitoring application, I-Connect, to enhance the on-task behavior of five secondary students (ages 15–16) with autism spectrum disorder, intellectual disability, and specific learning disability during Biology instruction in a rural special education classroom. We used an A-B-A-B withdrawal design with a generalization condition. The primary dependent variable was percent of intervals with on-task behavior as measured by momentary time sampling procedures. Results indicated overall higher levels of on-task behavior for all students when using I-Connect to monitor their behavior. However, there were also high percentages of overlapping data, and student satisfaction with the application was relatively low. Students used I-Connect in an employability seminar offered at their school as a means to generalize to a different setting. We provide implications for practice in rural settings and suggestions for future research related to I-Connect. We also provide recommendations for enhancing the social validity of technology-based self-monitoring for secondary students with disabilities.

Implementing a Picture Prompt and Proximity Intervention in a Classroom with an Adult Learner: A Case Study

The current case study investigated the use of a picture prompt and teacher proximity with an adult learner with significant disabilities during a postsecondary classroom management class and generalization setting. Results indicated that the learner had a higher percentage of intervals of on-task behavior during intervention than baseline. Teacher and learner satisfaction ratings suggested that the intervention was an acceptable strategy. A discussion of study limitations, implications, and future research directions are included.• A simple low tech instructional strategy can improve student on-task behavior.• Teachers can use an antecedent strategy to improve student behavior.• Strategies used in K–12 environments may work in higher education settings.• Successful applied behavior analysis strategies help include students in group participation.

The Effects of Chromebook Use on Student Engagement

This action research project is intended to determine the effects of Chromebook technology on student engagement in the secondary classroom. The study involved a classroom of first-year students enrolled in a health course. These students used Chromebooks for the first time as part of the one-to-one (1:1) initiative. Chromebooks were utilized as a part of the curriculum, incorporating daily lessons, teaching tools, applications, and various activities for student learning. Data collection methods included observations, teacher journals, and field notes. On-task and off-task behaviors were noted, and the results of the data analysis showed the level of engagement involved when using Chromebooks in the classroom. Levels of engagement were explored through a six-week study in a 9th-grade classroom comprised of 28 students using Chromebook one-to-one. Engagement included focus, interest, participation in the lesson and activity, and positive social interactions between the teacher and classmates. This action research investigation indicated that incorporating Chromebook technology into lessons effectively increased student engagement and motivation.

App-based self-monitoring as an intervention to support attention in students with learning difficulties

This study examines the effectiveness of an app-based self-monitoring intervention to support attention in students with learning difficulties. Two quantitative single-case studies were conducted in special education school settings. Study 1 used an AB design in which 12 seventh-grade students with learning difficulties were assessed for attentional behavior during a math exercise by systematic observation using the Munich Attention Inventory with five-second time sampling by two raters. Study 2 used a multiple baseline design to assess the attentional behavior of three students with combined learning and attention difficulties during a math exercise by systematic observation using Direct Behavior Rating to measure on-task and off-task behavior. Both studies also used a competency screening to elicit teacher ratings of change in attention behavior in a pre-post measurement. The results indicate that the app-based self-monitoring interventions were successful, highlighting the potential of app-based self-monitoring to support students with learning and attention difficulties. In particular, the development of personalized self-monitoring interventions holds promising potential for improving learning outcomes in this target group.

Application of Virtual Reality in STEM Education for Enhancing Immersive Learning and Performance of At-Risk Secondary School Students

Integration of Virtual Reality (VR) in education is increasingly recognised for its potential to enhance immersive learning environments, especially for at-risk students facing challenges like insecurity and inadequate infrastructure in Sokoto State, Nigeria. The study applied virtual reality in teaching STEM subjects (Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics) and explored how it improved engagement in learning, interest in laboratory practicals and educational outcomes for at-risk students, guided by Albert Bandura’s Social Cognitive Theory (SCT). A mixed-method approach incorporated qualitative observations and a quantitative quasi-experimental design. The study assessed the impact of VR-based instruction on at-risk students compared to traditional teaching methods. A sample of 65 students was divided into an experimental group (n=31) receiving VR-based instruction and a control group (n=34) with traditional instruction. Data analysis involved pre-test/post-test comparisons, descriptive statistics, and t-tests. Results revealed that VR-based teaching significantly improved students’ engagement, learning outcomes, and interest in hands-on skills. The experimental group showed higher participation, on-task behaviour, and satisfaction, and achieved better post-test scores in complex subjects such as Human Anatomy and Trigonometry. The study concluded that virtual reality (VR) technology effectively enhances STEM education for at-risk students at the secondary school level engagement with scores increasing from 3.5/5 to 4.6/5, significant improvement in performance with a mean gain of 33.4 points, and an increase in interest for the Hands-on laboratory practicals from 3.5 to 4.6. The study recommended the integration of virtual reality technologies into the secondary education curriculum. Further research should focus on translating immersive experiences into academic performance, emphasising on teacher training and support.

Investigating the Impact of a Motor Program on Preschoolers With Disabilities

A semistructured preschool motor program was developed in response to the paucity of evidence-based motor programs for preschoolers with disabilities in inclusive classrooms. A randomized controlled trial (RCT) was undertaken to examine the impact of the CHildren in Action: Motor Program for PreschoolerS (CHAMPPS), a 21-week intervention that includes 42 Universal Design for Learning–embedded lessons with suggestions for supporting school readiness skills. Eight intervention and 8 control classrooms across 2 states participated in the RCT. Data on 51 children with disabilities provide initial evidence on how CHAMPPS positively impacted children's active engagement, motor, and social development. The promising results include gains in motor skills, sustained physical activity levels during motor play, increased on-task behavior, and high feasibility and usability ratings by teachers. Implications for practice and future research are discussed.

An Open-Label Study of a Wearable Device Targeting ADHD, Executive Function, and Academic Performance.

This was an open-label pilot study to test the feasibility and preliminary efficacy of a wearable digital intervention developed to improve on-task behavior. This was an exploratory study to test for specificity of response on parent- and teacher-reported symptom outcomes in attention and hyperactive/impulsive symptoms, as well as domains of functional impairment, including school behavior and learning and executive function. Participants included 38 children aged 8-12 years with a parent-reported past diagnosis of ADHD. Following baseline ratings from parents (N = 38) and teachers (N = 26), participants wore the device to school for four weeks. Parent and teacher ratings of ADHD symptoms, executive function, and functional impairment were repeated at the end of the four-week intervention period. Statistically significant improvement was seen in the total scores for all parent and nearly all teacher outcomes, with moderate effect size improvements in attention, organization and planning, self-monitoring, school functioning, and teacher-reported academic performance. Preliminary evidence from this open-label pilot study suggests that having a child interact with a wearable device to self-monitor attention is feasible. This exploratory, open-label pilot study found real-world improvement in functional domains, including academic performance. Future research will require a blinded, randomized, controlled trial using an appropriate sham comparator to confirm these findings.