Normal Diploid Osteoblasts Research Articles

Runx2 deficiency and defective subnuclear targeting bypass senescence to promote immortalization and tumorigenic potential

The osteogenic Runt-related (Runx2) transcription factor negatively regulates proliferation and ribosomal gene expression in normal diploid osteoblasts, but is up-regulated in metastatic breast and prostate cancer cells. Thus, Runx2 may function as a tumor suppressor or an oncogene depending on the cellular context. Here we show that Runx2-deficient primary osteoblasts fail to undergo senescence as indicated by the absence of beta-gal activity and p16(INK4a) tumor suppressor expression. Primary Runx2-null osteoblasts have a growth advantage and exhibit loss of p21(WAF1/CIP1) and p19(ARF) expression. Reintroduction of WT Runx2, but not a subnuclear targeting-defective mutant, induces both p21(WAF/CIP1) and p19(ARF) mRNA and protein resulting in cell-cycle inhibition. Accumulation of spontaneous phospho-H2A.X foci, loss of telomere integrity and the Mre11/Rad50/Nbs1 DNA repair complex, and a delayed DNA repair response all indicate that Runx2 deficiency leads to genomic instability. We propose that Runx2 functions as a tumor suppressor in primary diploid osteoblasts and that subnuclear targeting contributes to Runx2-mediated tumor suppression.

Post-proliferative cyclin E-associated kinase activity in differentiated osteoblasts: Inhibition by proliferating osteoblasts and osteosarcoma cells

Spontaneous differentiation of normal diploid osteoblasts in culture is accompanied by increased cyclin E associated kinase activity on (1) the retinoblastoma susceptibility protein pRB, (2) the p107 RB related protein, and (3) two endogenous cyclin E-associated substrates of 78 and 105 kD. Activity of the differentiation-related cyclin E complexes (diff.ECx) is not recovered in cdc2 or cdk2 immunoprecipitates. Phosphorylation of both the 105 kD endogenous substrate and the p107 exogenous substrate is sensitive to inhibitory activity (diff.ECx-i) present in proliferating osteoblasts. This inhibitory activity is readily recruited by the cyclin E complexes of differentiated osteoblasts but is not found in cyclin E immunoprecipitates of the proliferating cells themselves. Strong inhibitory activity on diff.ECx kinase activity is excerted by proliferating ROS 17/2.8 osteosarcoma cells. However, unlike the normal diploid cells, the diff.ECx-i activity of proliferating ROS 17/2.8 cells is recovered by cyclin E immunoprecipitation. The cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor p21CIP1/WAF1 inhibits diff.ECx kinase activity. Thus, our results suggest the existence of a unique regulatory system, possibly involving p21CIP1/WAF1, in which inhibitory activity residing in proliferating cells is preferentially targeted towards differentiation-related cyclin E-associated kinase activity.

Runt homology domain proteins in osteoblast differentiation: AML3/CBFA1 is a major component of a bone-specific complex.

The AML/CBFA family of runt homology domain (rhd) transcription factors regulates expression of mammalian genes of the hematopoietic lineage. AML1, AML2 and AML3 are the three AML genes identified to date which influence myeloid cell growth and differentiation. Recently AML-related proteins were identified in an osteoblast-specific promoter binding complex that functionally modulates bone-restricted transcription of the osteocalcin gene. In the present study we demonstrate that in primary rat osteoblasts AML-3 is the AML family member present in the osteoblast-specific complex. Antibody specific for AML-3 completely supershifts this complex, in contrast to antibodies with specificity for AML-1 or AML-2, AML-3 is present as a single 5.4 kb transcript in bone tissues. To establish the functional involvement of AML factors in osteoblast differentiation, we pursued antisense strategies to alter expression of rhd genes. Treatment of osteoblast cultures with rhd antisense oligonucleotides significantly decreased three parameters which are linked to differentiation of normal diploid osteoblasts: the representation of alkaline phosphatase-positive cells, osteocalcin production, and the formation of mineralized nodules. Our findings indicate that AML-3 is a key transcription factor in bone cells and that the activity of rhd proteins is required for completion of osteoblast differentiation.

Requirement of distal and proximal promoter sequences for chromatin organization of the osteocalcin gene in bone-derived cells.

The osteocalcin (OC) gene encodes a 10 Kda bone-specific protein which is expressed with the onset of mineralization during the differentiation of normal diploid osteoblasts. We have previously reported that transcriptional activation of this gene is accompanied by the presence of two DNase I hypersensitive sites, both located in the promoter region spanning key basal (proximal site, -170 to -70) and steroid-dependent enhancer (distal site, -600 to -400) elements. Here, we have examined stably transfected ROS 17/2.8 cell lines carrying OC promoter-reporter transgenes which contain a series of 5'-deletions and determined the effects of these truncations on the chromatin organization. It has been found that: (1) DNase I hypersensitivity at -600 is not a requirement for vitamin D-dependent transcriptional upregulation; (2) basal transcriptional activity and proximal nuclease hypersensitivity depend exclusively on protein-DNA interactions occurring within the proximal promoter region, and (3) within the chromatin context, the proximal 100 bp promoter fragment, containing essential elements such as the OC box (-99 to -76) and TATA box (-44 to -31), is insufficient to support formation of the proximal nuclease hypersensitive site and transcriptional activity.

Requirement of distal and proximal promoter sequences for chromatin organization of the osteocalcin gene in bone‐derived cells

The osteocalcin (OC) gene encodes a 10 Kda bone-specific protein which is expressed with the onset of mineralization during the differentiation of normal diploid osteoblasts. We have previously reported that transcriptional activation of this gene is accompanied by the presence of two DNase I hypersensitive sites, both located in the promoter region spanning key basal (proximal site, -170 to -70) and steroid-dependent enhancer (distal site, -600 to -400) elements. Here, we have examined stably transfected ROS 17/2.8 cell lines carrying OC promoter-reporter transgenes which contain a series of 5'-deletions and determined the effects of these truncations on the chromatin organization. It has been found that: (1) DNase I hypersensitivity at -600 is not a requirement for vitamin D-dependent transcriptional upregulation; (2) basal transcriptional activity and proximal nuclease hypersensitivity depend exclusively on protein-DNA interactions occurring within the proximal promoter region, and (3) within the chromatin context, the proximal 100 bp promoter fragment, containing essential elements such as the OC box (-99 to -76) and TATA box (-44 to -31), is insufficient to support formation of the proximal nuclease hypersensitive site and transcriptional activity.

A composite intragenic silencer domain exhibits negative and positive transcriptional control of the bone-specific osteocalcin gene: promoter and cell type requirements.

The osteocalcin (OC) silencer is a unique example of exonic sequences contributing to negative transcriptional control of mammalian gene expression. In this paper we demonstrate, using a reporter transfection assay, that multiple elements reside within the OC +24/+151 domain. Thirty-fold repression is mediated by the +49/+104 fragment, experimentally relocated 3' of the poly(A) signal. Deletion of either the +49/+54 protein-coding sequence or the +98/+104 intronic part of this fragment results in loss of repression activity, suggesting a bipartite organization of the +49/+104 silencer. Of particular interest, we have mapped an antisilencer activity to the ACCCTCTCT motif (+40/+48), found in silencers associated with several other genes. Extension of the +49/+104 silencer to include the +24/+48 and/or the +105/+151 sequences results in increased silencer activity up to 170-fold, suggesting the presence of additional silencer elements within these sequences. The activity of the silencer contained within the +24/+151 OC sequence is directed to the basal promoter and is not dependent on 5' distal enhancer elements, including those that mediate responsiveness of OC transcription to vitamin D. The OC silencer represses the heterologous thymidine kinase promoter and is operative in osseous (normal diploid osteoblasts, ROS 17/2.8 osteosarcoma) as well as HeLa cells. Our results, which suggest the presence of at least five regulatory elements downstream of the OC transcription start site, indicate the complexity of sequences that mediate repression of OC promoter activity.

Expression of cell growth and bone phenotypic genes during the cell cycle of normal diploid osteoblasts and osteosarcoma cells

Establishing regulatory mechanisms that mediate proliferation of osteoblasts while restricting expression of genes associated with mature bone cell phenotypic properties to post-proliferative cells is fundamental to understanding skeletal development. To gain insight into relationships between growth control and the developmental expression of genes during osteoblast differentiation, we have examined expression of three classes of genes during the cell cycle of normal diploid rat calvarial-derived osteoblasts and rat osteosarcoma cells (ROS 17/2.8): cell cycle and growth-related genes (e.g., histone), genes that encode major structural proteins (e.g., actin and vimentin), and genes related to the biosynthesis, organization, and mineralization of the bone extracellular matrix (e.g., alkaline phosphatase, collagen I, osteocalcin, and osteopontin). In normal diploid osteoblasts as well as in osteosarcoma cells we found that histone genes, required for cell progression, are selectively expressed during S phase. All other genes studied were constitutively expressed both at the transcriptional and posttranscriptional levels. Alkaline phosphatase, an integral membrane protein in both osteoblasts and osteosarcoma cells, exhibited only minimal changes in activity during the osteoblast and osteosarcoma cell cycles. Our findings clearly indicate that despite the loss of normal proliferation-differentiation interrelationships in osteosarcoma cells, cell cycle regulation or constitutive expression of growth and phenotypic genes is maintained.

Cell cycle controlled histone H1, H3, and H4 genes share unusual arrangements of recognition motifs for HiNF‐D supporting a coordinate promoter binding mechanism

Cell cycle and growth control of the DNA binding and transactivation functions of regulatory factors provides a direct mechanism by which cells may coordinate transcription of a multitude of genes in proliferating cells. The promoters of human DNA replication dependent histone H4, H3, and H1 genes interact with at least seven distinct proteins. One of these proteins is a proliferation-specific nuclear factor, HiNF-D, that interacts with a key cis-regulatory element (H4-Site II; 41 bp) present in H4 genes. Here we describe binding sites for HiNF-D in the promoters of H3 and H1 genes using cross-competition, deletion analysis, and methylation interference assays, and we show that HiNF-D recognizes intricate arrangements of at least two sequence elements (CA- and AG-motifs). These recognition motifs are irregularly dispersed and distantly positioned in the proximal promoters (200 bp) of both the H3 and H1 genes. In all cases, these motifs either overlap or are in close proximity to other established transcriptional elements, including ATF and CCAAT sequences. Although HiNF-D can interact with low affinity to a core recognition domain, auxiliary elements in both the distal and proximal portions of each promoter cooperatively enhance HiNF-D binding. Thus, HiNF-D appears to bridge remote regulatory regions, which may juxtapose additional trans-activating proteins interacting within histone gene promoters. Consistent with observations in many cell culture systems, the interactions of HiNF-D with the H4, H3, and H1 promoters are modulated in parallel during the cessation of proliferation in both osteosarcoma cells and normal diploid osteoblasts, and these events occur in conjunction with concerted changes in histone gene expression. Thus, HiNF-D represents a candidate participant in coordinating transcriptional control of several histone gene classes.

Variations in vitamin D receptor transcription factor complexes associated with the osteocalcin gene vitamin D responsive element in osteoblasts and osteosarcoma cells

Vitamin D responsive transcription of the bone-specific osteocalcin gene differs markedly in osteosarcoma cells and normal diploid osteoblasts. In osteoblasts the osteocalcin gene is transcribed, and upregulated by Vitamin D, only in post-proliferative cells, but in osteosarcoma cells expression is constitutive. This distinction in transcriptional regulation of the osteocalcin gene correlates with striking differences in the relative representation of two principal Vitamin D-dependent protein/DNA complexes designated V1 and V2 at the Vitamin D responsive element in the osteocalcin promoter. Formation of both complexes is Vitamin D dependent and they contain the Vitamin D receptor as well as an RXR related protein. Pore size exclusion and sedimentation velocity analyses suggest that the V1 and V2 complexes represent oligomeric protein assemblies (respectively, tetramers and trimers), and reflect primarily DNA-directed association of the monomeric protein components at the osteocalcin Vitamin D responsive element. UV crosslinking and methylation interference analyses of the V1 and V2 complexes at the osteocalcin Vitamin D responsive element indicate differences in protein/DNA recognition. For example, the V1 complex interacts with both steroid half-elements, whereas the V2 complex appears to recognize the proximal half-element. Our findings suggest variations in protein/protein and protein/DNA interactions of the VDR and RXR related complexes V1 and V2 at the osteocalcin Vitamin D responsive element that reflect unique properties of the osteosarcoma and normal diploid osteoblast phenotype.

Influence of DNA replication inhibition on expression of cell growth and tissue-specific genes in osteoblasts and osteosarcoma cells.

Interrelationships between proliferation and expression of cell growth as well as bone cell-related genes were examined from two standpoints. First, the consequence of downregulating proliferation by DNA synthesis inhibition on expression of a cell cycle-regulated histone gene and genes associated with development of the bone cell phenotype (type I collagen, alkaline phosphatase, osteopontin, and osteocalcin) was investigated. Second, the requirement for stringent growth control to support functional relationships between expression of proliferation and differentiation-related genes was explored. Parameters of cell growth and osteoblast-related gene expression in primary cultures of normal diploid osteoblasts, that initially express proliferation-dependent genes and subsequently postproliferative genes associated with mature bone cell phenotypic properties, were compared to those operative in ROS 17/2.8 osteosarcoma cells that concomitantly express cell growth and mature osteoblast phenotypic genes. Our findings indicate that in both normal diploid osteoblasts and osteosarcoma cells, expression of the cell cycle regulated histone genes is tightly coupled with DNA synthesis and controlled predominantly at a posttranscriptional level. Inhibition of proliferation by blocking DNA synthesis with hydroxyurea upregulates a subset of developmentally expressed genes that postproliferatively support progressive establishment of mature osteoblast phenotypic properties (e.g., alkaline phosphatase, type 1 collagen, and osteopontin). However, the osteocalcin gene, which is expressed during the final stage of osteoblast differentiation when extracellular matrix mineralization occurs, is not upregulated. Variations in the extent to which inhibition of proliferation in normal diploid osteoblasts and in ROS 17/2.8 osteosarcoma cells selectively affects transcription and cellular levels of mRNA transcripts from bone cell-related genes (e.g., osteocalcin) may reflect modifications in proliferation/differentiation interrelationships when stringent growth control is abrogated.

Effects of 1,25(OH) 2D 3 and vitamin D analogs on developmental control of cell growth and tissue-specific gene expression during osteoblast differentiation

Cultured normal diploid osteoblasts provide a model for identifying selective effects of vitamin D and 1,25(OH) 2D 3 analogs on expression of cell growth and tissue-specific genes that are dependent on the differentiated state of the bone cell. Transcription of the bone-specific osteocalcin gene is responsive to the vitamin D receptor complex together with other cellular signaling factors. Cultured normal diploid osteoblasts provide a model for identifying selective effects of vitamin D and 1,25-(OH) 2D 3 analogs on expression of cell growth and tissue-specific genes that are dependent on the differentiated state of the bone cell. Transcription of the bone-specific osteocalcin gene is responsive to the vitamin D receptor complex together with other cellular signaling factors.

Constitutive transcription of the osteocalcin gene in osteosarcoma cells is reflected by altered protein-DNA interactions at promoter regulatory elements.

The bone-specific osteocalcin (OC) gene is transcribed only after completion of proliferation in normal diploid calvarial-derived osteoblasts during extracellular matrix mineralization. In contrast, the OC gene is expressed constitutively in both proliferating and nonproliferating ROS 17/2.8 osteosarcoma cells. To address molecular mechanisms associated with these tumor-related modifications in transcriptional control, we examined sequence-specific interactions of transactivation factors at key basal and hormone-responsive elements in the OC gene promoter. In ROS 17/2.8 cells compared to normal diploid osteoblasts, the absence of a stringent requirement for cessation of proliferation to support both induction of OC transcription and steroid hormone-mediated transcriptional modulation is reflected by modifications in transcription factor binding at (i) the two primary basal regulatory elements, the OC box (which contains a CCAAT motif as a central core) and the TATA/glucocorticoid-responsive element domain, and (ii) the vitamin D-responsive element. Particularly striking are two forms of the vitamin D receptor complex that are present in proliferating osteoblasts and osteosarcoma cells. Both forms of the complex are sensitive to vitamin D receptor antibody and retinoic X receptor antibody. After the down-regulation of proliferation, only the lower molecular weight complex is found in normal diploid osteoblasts. Both forms of the complex are present in nonproliferating ROS 17/2.8 cells with increased representation of the complex exhibiting reduced electrophoretic mobility that is phosphorylation-dependent.

Expression of cell growth and bone specific genes at single cell resolution during development of bone tissue-like organization in primary cultures of normal diploid osteoblasts

Expression of cell growth and bone specific genes at single cell resolution during development of bone tissue-like organization in primary cultures of normal diploid osteoblasts

Expression of cell growth and bone specific genes at single cell resolution during development of bone tissue-like organization in primary osteoblast cultures.

Primary cultures of calvarial derived normal diploid osteoblasts undergo a developmental expression of genes reflecting growth, extracellular matrix maturation, and mineralization during development of multilayered nodules having a bone tissue-like organization. Scanning electron microscopy of the developing cultures indicates the transition from the uniform distribution of cuboidal osteoblasts to multilayered nodules of smaller cells with a pronounced orientation of perinodular cells towards the apex of the nodule. Ultrastructural analysis of the nodule by transmission electron microscopy indicates that the deposition of mineral is confined to the extracellular matrix where cells appear more osteocytic. The cell body contains rough endoplasmic reticulum and golgi, while these intracellular organelles are not present in the developing cellular processes. To understand the regulation of temporally expressed genes requires an understanding of which genes are selectively expressed on a single cell basis as the bone tissue-like organization develops. In situ hybridization analysis using 35S labelled histone gene probes, together with 3H-thymidine labelling and autoradiography, indicate that greater than 98% of the pre-confluent osteoblasts are proliferating. By two weeks, both the foci of multilayered cells and internodular cell regions have down-regulated cell growth associated genes. Post-proliferatively, but not earlier, initial expression of both osteocalcin and osteopontin are restricted to the multilayered nodules where all cells exhibit expression. While total mRNA levels for osteopontin and osteocalcin are coordinately upregulated with an increase in mineral deposition, in situ hybridization has revealed that expression of osteocalcin and osteopontin occurs predominantly in cells associated with the developing nodules. In contrast, proliferating rat osteosarcoma cells (ROS 17/2.8) concomitantly express histone H4, along with osteopontin and osteocalcin. These in situ analyses of gene expression during osteoblast growth and differentiation at the single cell level establish that a population of proliferating calvarial-derived cells subsequently expresses osteopontin and osteocalcin in cells developing into multilayered nodules with a tissue-like organization.

Effect of caffeine on parameters of osteoblast growth and differentiation of a mineralized extracellular matrix in vitro

The effects of caffeine exposure on bone formation were examined using a chick osteoblast culture system. Secondary cultures of normal diploid osteoblasts were exposed to chronic doses of 0, 0.1, 0.2, or 0.4 mM caffeine beginning on day 0 through day 28. Neither the rate of cell proliferation nor cell number, as measured by total DNA, was decreased for any of the doses examined. In contrast, osteocalcin levels, alkaline phosphatase activity, and total calcium levels showed a dose-related decrease in cultures treated with caffeine. These parameters were significantly decreased at the highest dose of 0.4 mM. The reduction in total protein levels ranged from 29 to 66% of control values and was independent of dose. In contrast, total collagen levels were more affected by the dose of caffeine used. Inhibition of collagen levels was most apparent on days 17 and 21, time points during the period of active formation of the matrix immediately preceding the deposition of mineral. By day 28 collagen levels in cultures exposed to the lower doses of caffeine had returned to control levels, and only the cultures exposed to the highest dose (0.4 mM) remained significantly inhibited with respect to both collagen and mineral. Histochemically, alkaline phosphatase and mineral staining of day 28 cultures mirrored the biochemical events with the 0.4 mM caffeine exposure. The results indicate that one of the effects of caffeine on bone development is to inhibit the formation of a competent extracellular matrix during the osteoblast differentiation sequence, which results in the inhibition of mineralization analogous to the delayed ossification observed in fetal animals after prenatal caffeine exposure.

Coordinate occupancy of AP-1 sites in the vitamin D-responsive and CCAAT box elements by Fos-Jun in the osteocalcin gene: model for phenotype suppression of transcription.

Osteocalcin, a bone-specific protein and marker of the mature osteoblast, is expressed only in nonproliferating osteoblasts in a mineralizing extracellular matrix, while type I collagen is expressed in proliferating cells. The nuclear proteins encoded by the c-fos and c-jun protooncogenes are expressed during the proliferation period of osteoblast phenotype development. We present evidence that AP-1 (HeLa cell-activating protein 1) sites residing within two promoter elements of the osteocalcin gene bind the Fos-Jun protein complex: the osteocalcin box (OC box; nucleotides -99 to -76), which contains a CCAAT motif as a central element and influences tissue-specific basal levels of osteocalcin gene transcription, and the vitamin D-responsive element (VDRE; nucleotides -462 to -440), which mediates enhancement of osteocalcin gene transcription. Gel electrophoretic mobility-shift analysis demonstrated high AP-1 binding activity in proliferating osteoblasts and dramatic changes in this activity after the down-regulation of proliferation and the initiation of extracellular-matrix mineralization in primary cultures of normal diploid osteoblasts. Methylation interference analysis established at single nucleotide resolution that purified recombinant Fos and Jun proteins bind in a sequence-specific manner to the AP-1 sites within the VDRE and OC box. Similarly, an AP-1 motif within a putative VDRE of the alkaline phosphatase gene, which is also expressed after the completion of proliferation, binds the Fos-Jun complex. These results support a model in which coordinate occupancy of the AP-1 sites in the VDRE and OC box in proliferating osteoblasts may suppress both basal level and vitamin D-enhanced osteocalcin gene transcription as well as transcription of other genes associated with osteoblast differentiation--a phenomenon we describe as phenotype suppression. This model is further supported by binding of the Fos-Jun complex at an AP-1 site in the type alpha I collagen promoter that is contiguous with, but not overlapping, the VDRE. Such a sequence organization in the collagen VDRE motif is compatible with vitamin D modulation of collagen but not with osteocalcin and alkaline phosphatase expression in proliferating osteoblasts.