Martin Davis, in Computability & Unsolvability (1958), said of Church's thesis, "For how can we ever exclude the possibility of our being presented, some day (perhaps by some extraterrestrial visitors), with a (perhaps extremely complex) device or 'oracle' that 'computes' a noncomputable function?" The recent television revival of the Stephen Spielberg film ET presented a script sadly deficient with respect to Davis's question and to mathematics generally. To be fair, this film was made for American juveniles, for whom any mathematical references would have been mysterious. Still, one can imagine a scenario for an actual ET visit. In this scenario, the ET landing occurs at Princeton, NJ, and the colloquy takes place in English, between ET and a mathematician from the Institute for Advanced Study (who agreed reluctantly to be the designated Presidential Representative only after assurance that he would not first have to be approved by any Senate committee) .. . ET: You have some questions for me?
Read full abstract