This article presents and examines two distinctive approaches to the mixed virtual element method (VEM) applied to parabolic integro-differential equations (PIDEs) with non-smooth initial data. In the first part of the paper, we introduce and analyze a mixed virtual element scheme for PIDE that eliminates the need for the resolvent operator. Through the introduction of a novel projection involving a memory term, coupled with the application of energy arguments and the repeated use of an integral operator, this study establishes optimal L2-error estimates for the two unknowns p and σ. Furthermore, optimal error estimates are derived for the standard mixed formulation with a resolvent kernel. The paper offers a comprehensive analysis of the VEM, encompassing both formulations.