We develop a physically-motivated mechanical theory for predicting the behavior of nematic elastomers — a subset of liquid crystal elastomers (LCEs). We begin with a statistical description of network geometry that naturally incorporates independent descriptors for the mesogens, which create the nematic phase, and the polymer chains, which are assumed to not deform affinely with global deformations. From here, we develop thermodynamically consistent constitutive laws based on classical continuum mechanics principles and ultimately provide simple governing equations with transparent physical interpretation. We found that our framework converges identically to two previously developed mechanical theories, including the well-known neo-classical theory, when considering the extreme ends of our parametric space. We then explore the new predictive capabilities of our model inside these two extremes and illustrate its unique predictions at finite strains, which are distinct in form from other theories. We validate our model using published experimental data from four monodomain nematic liquid crystal elastomers.