Natural Selection Research Articles

Comprehensive Analysis of Codon Usage Bias in Human Papillomavirus Type 51.

Human papillomavirus type 51 (HPV-51) is associated with various cancers, including cervical cancer. Examining the codon usage bias of the organism can offer valuable insights into its evolutionary patterns and its relationship with the host. This study comprehensively analyzed codon usage bias in HPV-51 by examining 64 complete genome sequences sourced from the NCBI GenBank database. Our analysis revealed no noteworthy preference for codon usage in HPV-51 overall. However, there was a noticeable bias towards A/T-ending codons, accompanied by GC3s below 32%. Dinucleotide frequency analysis revealed reduced frequencies for ApA, CpG, and TpC dinucleotides, while CpA and TpG dinucleotides were more frequent than others. Relative Synonymous Codon Usage analysis revealed 30 favored codons, primarily concluding with A/T nucleotides. Further analysis using Parity Rule 2, Effective Number of Codons plot, and neutrality plot indicated a balance between mutational pressure and natural selection, with natural selection being the primary force shaping codon usage bias. The Isoacceptor tRNA Pool analysis indicates that HPV-51 has a higher translation efficiency within the human cellular translational system. Moreover, the Codon Adaptation Index and Relative Codon Deoptimization Index analyses suggested a moderate adaptation of HPV-51 to human codon preferences. Our discoveries offer valuable perspectives on how HPV-51 evolves and uses genetic codes, contributing to a deeper comprehension of its endurance and disease-causing potential.

Unlocking nature’s drought resilience: a focus on the parsimonious root phenotype and specialised root metabolism in wild Medicago populations

Abstract Background and aims Crop wild relatives, exposed to strong natural selection, exhibit effective tolerance traits against stresses. While an aggressive root proliferation phenotype has long been considered advantageous for a range of stresses, it appears to be counterproductive under drought due to its high metabolic cost. Recently, a parsimonious root phenotype, metabolically more efficient, has been suggested to be better adapted to semiarid environments, although it is not clear that this phenotype is a trait exhibited by crop wild relatives. Methods Firstly, we analysed the root phenotype and carbon metabolism in four Medicago crop wild relatives adapted to a semiarid environment and compared them with the cultivated M. truncatula Jemalong (A17). Secondly, we exposed the cultivated (probably the least adapted genotype to aridity) and the wild (the most common one in arid zones) M. truncatula genotypes to water deficit. The carbon metabolism response in different parts of their roots was analysed. Results A reduced carbon investment per unit of root length was a common trait in the four wild genotypes, indicative of an evolution towards a parsimonious root phenotype. During the water deficit experiment, the wild M. truncatula showed higher tolerance to drought, along with a superior ability of its taproot to partition sucrose and enhanced capacity of its fibrous roots to maintain sugar homeostasis. Conclusion A parsimonious root phenotype and the spatial specialization of root carbon metabolism represent two important drought tolerance traits. This work provides relevant findings to understand the response of Medicago species roots to water deficit.

Macro- and micro-geographic genetic variation in early fitness traits in populations of maritime pine (Pinus pinaster Ait.).

Assessing adaptive genetic variation and its spatial distribution is crucial to conserve forest genetic resources and manage species' adaptive potential. Macro-environmental gradients commonly exert divergent selective pressures that enhance adaptive genetic divergence among populations. Steep micro-environmental variation might also result in adaptive divergence at finer spatial scales, even under high gene flow, but it is unclear how often this is the case. Here, we assess genetic variation in early fitness traits among distant and nearby maritime pine (Pinus pinaster Ait.) populations, to investigate climatic factors associated with trait divergence, and to examine trait integration during seedling establishment. Open pollinated seeds were collected from seven population pairs across the European species distribution, with paired populations spatially close (between <1 km up to 21 km) but environmentally divergent. Seeds were sown in semi-natural conditions at three environmentally contrasting sites, where we monitored seedling emergence, growth and survival. At large spatial scales, we found significant genetic divergence among populations in all studied traits, with certain traits exhibiting association with temperature and precipitation gradients. Significant trait divergence was also detected between pairs of nearby populations. Besides, we found consistent trait correlations across experimental sites, notably heavier seeds and earlier seedling emergence were both associated with higher seedling survival and fitness over two years in all experimental conditions. We identified mean annual temperature and precipitation seasonality as potential drivers of P. pinaster population divergence in the studied early-life traits. Populations genetically diverge also at local spatial scales, potentially suggesting that divergent natural selection can override gene flow along local-scale ecological gradients. These results suggest the species exhibits substantial adaptive potential that has allowed it to survive and evolve under contrasting environmental conditions.

Measuring undergraduate evolution learning using the CANS: psychometric strengths and limitations

BackgroundEvolution continues to be one of the most difficult biological topics to teach, warranting innovative pedagogical tools and assessment strategies for enhancing evolutionary instruction. A major advance in measuring the evolution knowledge of undergraduate students came with the development of the Conceptual Assessment of Natural Selections (CANS). In this study, we use the CANS to measure knowledge and learning of natural selection in a large (N > 6000) sample of undergraduate students to expand upon prior validity testing of this instrument and advance knowledge of student evolutionary reasoning. We apply the Rasch measurement framework to examine if the CANS productively measures the intended construct and investigate the patterns of knowledge and learning about evolution among students with different backgrounds and demographic characteristics.ResultsWhile a unidimensional Rasch model demonstrated acceptable reliabilities and fit for most of the CANS items, some items showed problematic fit statistics and were resistant to instruction. The instrument items also did not span the full range of student abilities, which suggests relatively low measurement precision. Our large sample also allowed rigorous tests of multidimensionality, revealing the presence of multiple dimensions or constructs, some of which may not be intentional. These results generated specific item-level recommendations for improving this instrument. Using Rasch measures to examine learning patterns, we found that pre-test evolution knowledge was low but that there were high learning gains by the end of the course. However, some concept categories were found to be more difficult than others, suggesting the need for more attention to these areas by instructors. We also identified pre-test disparities in evolutionary knowledge by socially defined race and biological sex, yet students from all groups achieved comparable learning gains at the end of the course.ConclusionThe CANS holds great potential to generate critical insights about student evolutionary reasoning and provide information about which instructional approaches most effectively mitigate the notable knowledge disparities among students. We leverage the findings of this study to propose tangible ways in which this instrument may be improved in order to better achieve both of these goals.

The legacy and evolvability of Pere Alberch's ideas.

Pere Alberch played a pivotal role in shaping the field of evolutionary developmental biology during the 1980s and 1990s. Whereas initially his contributions were sidelined by the empirical advancements of the molecular revolution in developmental and evolutionary biology, his theoretical insights have left a lasting impact on the discipline. This article provides a comprehensive review of the legacy and evolvability of Alberch's ideas in contemporary evo-devo, which included the study of morphogenesis as the proper level of developmental causation, the interplay between developmental constraints and natural selection, the epistemic role of teratologies, the origin of evolutionary novelties and the concept of evolvability.

The influence of aridity on plant intraspecific chemical diversity supports adaptive differentiation and convergent evolution.

Plants synthesize a broad array of specialized chemical compounds that mediate their interactions with the surrounding environment. Some of this chemical diversity is functional and subject to natural selection, but the factors underlying chemical evolution at the intraspecific level remain largely unknown. Here, we combined chemical, environmental and genetic data to investigate the effect of aridity on the expression of chemotypes in the invasive shrub Senecio pterophorus. We studied the variation in pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs), a group of specialized metabolites widespread across the families Boraginaceae, Asteraceae and Fabaceae, from native populations spanning a cline of aridity and from three cross-continental introductions, under natural and common garden conditions. We examined whether the relationship between chemistry and aridity was compatible with a process of adaptive differentiation using a method that partitions the variance and covariance by controlling for the population neutral genetic structure. We found a consistent shift from retrorsine-like to seneciphylline-like compounds under increasing aridity in both natural and controlled conditions in coherence with the biosynthetic pathways. This pattern was independent of the neutral genetic structure and occurred along the environmental gradient in the native range and in a convergent manner in all nonnative regions, which suggests adaptive differentiation in response to aridity. Our findings show that the diversity of PAs in S. pterophorus has been partially shaped by aridity. Investigating how abiotic factors influence chemical evolution is key to elucidating the plant responses in future climate scenarios and the cascading effects on other trophic levels.

Genome-wide association study reveals effect of nsSNPs on candidate genes in rice during iron deficiency.

Resource-poor areas with moisture deficit lands following aerobic and direct seeded rice (DSR) methods of cultivation face severe problems of iron deficiency. In this study, Bengal and Assam Aus rice panel was phenotyped at the seedling stage using an iron-deprived hydroponic medium for various shoot and root traits. A novel iron deficiency scoring scale was used to classify the tolerance reaction and could range anywhere between 0 and 9, indicating the most tolerant and susceptible, respectively. The GWAS results identified four putative candidate genes; OsFLA for number of leaves and shoot length, OsBIDK1 for root traits; average diameter, volume, biomass, projected area, and surface area, OsHPL3 for chlorophyll index of the third leaf and AKR2B (XBOS252) was for Fe score, (which was earlier reported in relation to Xa21). The nsSNP (nsSNPs) variations in these gene sequences were used to group the panel and identify superior haplotypes and donors. BR16 was identified as a superior donor, with higher chlorophyll index and shoot length than RA23, also higher values for root traits like root average diameter, root volume, root projected area and root surface area followed by Shete Bhado. The impact of identified nsSNPs on protein structure and stability was investigated. The conserved domains detected in the mutated proteins of the superior haplotypes are very informative, highlighting that natural selection favors abiotic stress tolerant variants in resource poor areas. Thus, justifying our choice of Aus landraces for association mapping of Fe deficiency tolerant genes in rice.

Genomes of Microtus rodents highlight the importance of olfactory and immune systems in their fast radiation.

The characterization of genes and biological functions underlying functional diversification and the formation of species is a major goal of evolutionary biology. In this study, we investigated the fast radiation of Microtus voles, one of the most speciose group of mammals, which shows strong genetic divergence despite few readily observable morphological differences. We produced an annotated reference genome for the common vole, Microtus arvalis, and resequenced the genomes of 10 different species and evolutionary lineages spanning the Microtus speciation continuum. Our full genome sequences illustrate the recent and fast diversification of this group, and we identified genes in highly divergent genomic windows that have likely particular roles in their radiation. We found three biological functions enriched for highly divergent genes in most Microtus species and lineages: olfaction, immunity and metabolism. In particular, olfaction-related genes (mostly olfactory receptors and vomeronasal receptors) are fast evolving in all Microtus species indicating the exceptional importance of the olfactory system in the evolution of these rodents. Of note is e.g. the shared signature among vole species on Olfr1019 which has been associated with fear responses against predator odours in rodents. Our analyses provide a genome-wide basis for the further characterization of the ecological factors and processes of natural and sexual selection that have contributed to the fast radiation of Microtus voles.

Gravitropic Gene Expression Divergence Associated With Adaptation to Contrasting Environments in an Australian Wildflower.

Plants adapt to their local environment through complex interactions between genes, gene networks and hormones. Although the impact of gene expression on trait regulation and evolution has been recognised for many decades, its role in the evolution of adaptation is still a subject of intense exploration. We used a Multi-parent Advanced Generation Inter-Cross (MAGIC) population, which we derived from crossing multiple parents from two distinct coastal ecotypes of an Australia wildflower, Senecio lautus. We focused on studying the contrasting gravitropic behaviours of these ecotypes, which have evolved independently multiple times and show strong responses to natural selection in field experiments, emphasising the role of natural selection in their evolution. Here, we investigated how gene expression differences have contributed to the adaptive evolution of gravitropism. We studied gene expression in 60 pools at five time points (30, 60, 120, 240 and 480 min) after rotating half of the pools 90°. We found 428 genes with differential expression in response to the 90° rotation treatment. Of these, 81 genes (~19%) have predicted functions related to the plant hormones auxin and ethylene, which are crucial for the gravitropic response. By combining insights from Arabidopsis mutant studies and analysing our gene networks, we propose a preliminary model to explain the differences in gravitropism between ecotypes. This model suggests that the differences arise from changes in the transport and availability of the two hormones auxin and ethylene. Our findings indicate that the genetic basis of adaptation involves interconnected signalling pathways that work together to give rise to new ecotypes.

Inbreeding accelerates reproductive senescence, but not survival senescence, in a precocial bird.

Inbreeding depression is predicted to increase with age, because natural selection is less efficient at purging deleterious alleles that are only expressed later in life. However, empirical results are scarce, and equivocal between studies. Here we performed controlled matings between related and unrelated individuals of domesticated Japanese quail (Coturnix japonica), and monitored the performance of their offspring for all fitness components over their complete life course. We found rapid senescence in adult survival and egg laying performance, and inbreeding depression at all life stages (reduced embryo viability, increased age at maturity, as well as reduced adult survival and reproduction). Inbreeding depression did not increase at later ages for survival, but did so for egg laying, thereby accelerating reproductive senescence. Moreover, the effect of inbreeding on egg laying persisted after correcting for lifespan, indicating that both survival and reproduction were independently affected by inbreeding. We suggest that in heterogeneous populations intra-generational purging may at earlier ages already select out the individuals that are homozygous for the specific alleles responsible for depressed survival, preventing the appearance of increased inbreeding depression in survival with age. Given that inbreeding affects reproduction independent of survival this should not apply to reproductive senescence or homogeneous populations, which may explain equivocal results between traits and studies.

Making sense of chromosome polymorphisms in two leptysmine grasshoppers.

The touchstone of the 'New Synthesis' was population cytogenetics -rather than genetics - due to the abundant polymorphic inversions in the genus Drosophila. Grasshoppers were not a material of choice because of their conservative karyotypes. However, nowadays seven species of Acrididae were described for polymorphic centric fusions, five of them in South-America. Leptysma argentina and the likely biocontrol of water-hyacinth Cornops aquaticum are semiaquatic Leptysminae (Acrididae: Orthoptera), polymorphic for centric fusions, supernumerary segments and a B-chromosome. We sought to demonstrate the operation of natural selection on them, by detecting: (I) latitudinal clines; (II) regression on environmental variables; (III) deviation from null models, such as linkage equilibrium; (IV) seasonal variation; (V) comparison between age classes and (VI) selection component analyses. All of them were confirmed in L. argentina, just (I) and (II) in C. aquaticum. Furthermore, the relationship between karyotype, phenotype and recombination was confirmed in both species. Karyotype-phenotype relationship may be due to the body enlargement the fusions are associated with, along with a latitudinal transition in voltinism. Karyotype-related recombination reduction in both species may help explain all fusion clines, although there is probably more than one factor at work. No effects were noticed for a supernumerary segment in L. argentina, but it is ubiquitous and certainly non-neutral. C. aquaticum is poised for introduction in South-Africa as a biocontrol of water-hyacinths; the recent discovery of four more segment polymorphisms may imply more chromosomal markers to make sense of its genetic system.

"Understanding Natural Selection" by Michael Ruse, 2023 [book review

"Understanding Natural Selection" by Michael Ruse, 2023 [book review

Characterization, Codon Usage Pattern and Phylogenetic Implications of the Waterlily Aphid Rhopalosiphum nymphaeae (Hemiptera: Aphididae) Mitochondrial Genome.

The water lily aphid, Rhopalosiphum nymphaeae, is the only known aphid that can live in both terrestrial and aquatic conditions. In this study, the complete mitochondrial genome of R. nymphaeae was generated using Illumina sequencing technology. The typical circular DNA mitochondrial genome of R. nymphaeae is 15,772 bp in length, with a high A+T content (84.34%). It contains 37 coding genes (13 protein-coding genes, 22 transport RNAs, and two ribosomal RNAs) and two non-coding regions (one control region and one repeat region). Enc-plot, PR2-bias, and neutrality plot analysis indicated that the codon usage of the protein-coding genes is mainly affected by natural selection. The evolution rate analysis (the ratio of nonsynonymous to synonymous, Ka/Ks) indicated that all the PCGs in R. nymphaeae are under a strong purifying selection. The control region has conserved structure elements, and two types of tandem repeat units exist. The length and sequence of the aphid-unique repeat region has high similarity with closely related species. Phylogenetic analyses determined by both maximum likelihood and Bayesian inference support the monophyly of Aphidinae, Aphidini, Aphidina, and Rhopalosiphina. However, the monophyly of the genera in Rhopalosiphina, such as Rhopalosiphum, is still not resolved. This study may help us to understand the phylogenetic relationship of aphids, and much more aphid data are needed in future studies.

The Relationship Between Astronomical and Developmental Times Emerging in Modeling the Evolution of Agents.

The simplest evolutionary model for catching prey by an agent (predator) is considered. The simulation is performed on the basis of a software-emulated Intel i8080 processor. Maximizing the number of catches is chosen as the objective function. This function is associated with energy dissipation and developmental time. It is shown that during Darwinian evolution, agents with an initially a random set of processor commands subsequently acquire a successful catching skill. It is found that in the process of evolution, a logarithmic relationship between astronomical and developmental times arises in agents. This result is important for the ideas available in the literature about the close connection of such concepts as time, Darwinian selection, and the maximization of entropy production.

Higher oxygen content and transport characterize high-altitude ethnic Tibetan women with the highest lifetime reproductive success

We chose the "natural laboratory" provided by high-altitude native ethnic Tibetan women who had completed childbearing to examine the hypothesis that multiple oxygen delivery traits were associated with lifetime reproductive success and had genomic associations. Four hundred seventeen (417) women aged 46 to 86 y residing at ≥3,500 m in Upper Mustang, Nepal, provided information on reproductive histories, sociocultural factors, physiological measurements, and DNA samples for this observational cohort study. Simultaneously assessing multiple traits identified combinations associated with lifetime reproductive success measured as the number of livebirths. Women with the most livebirths had distinctive hematological and cardiovascular traits. A hemoglobin concentration near the sample mode and a high percent of oxygen saturation of hemoglobin raised arterial oxygen concentration without risking elevated blood viscosity. We propose ongoing stabilizing selection on hemoglobin concentration because extreme values predicted fewer livebirths and directional selection favoring higher oxygen saturation because higher values had more predicted livebirths. EPAS1, an oxygen homeostasis locus with strong signals of positive natural selection and a high frequency of variants occurring only among populations indigenous to the Tibetan Plateau, associated with hemoglobin concentration. High blood flow into the lungs, wide left ventricles, and low hypoxic heart rate responses aided effective convective oxygen transport to tissues. Women with physiologies closer to unstressed, low altitude values had the highest lifetime reproductive success. This example of ethnic Tibetan women residing at high altitudes in Nepal links reproductive fitness with trait combinations increasing oxygen delivery under severe hypoxic stress and demonstrates ongoing natural selection.

Design principles, growth laws, and competition of minimal autocatalysts

The difficulty of designing simple autocatalysts that grow exponentially in the absence of enzymes, external drives or ingenious internal mechanisms severely constrains scenarios for the emergence of evolution by natural selection in chemical and physical systems. Here, we systematically analyze these difficulties in the simplest and most generic autocatalyst: a dimeric molecule that duplicates by templated ligation. We show that despite its simplicity, such an autocatalyst can achieve exponential growth autonomously. We also show, however, that it is possible to design as simple sub-exponential autocatalysts that have an advantage over exponential autocatalysts when competing for a common resource. We reach these conclusions by developing a theoretical framework based on kinetic barrier diagrams. Besides challenging commonly accepted assumptions in the field of the origin of life, our results provide a blueprint for the experimental realization of elementary autocatalysts exhibiting a form of natural selection, whether on a molecular or colloidal scale.

Genetic Adaptations of the Tibetan Pig to High-Altitude Hypoxia on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau.

The Tibetan Plateau's distinctive high-altitude environment, marked by extreme cold and reduced oxygen levels, presents considerable survival challenges for both humans and mammals. Natural selection has led to the accumulation of adaptive mutations in Tibetan pigs, enabling them to develop distinctive adaptive phenotypes. Here, we aim to uncover the genetic mechanisms underlying the adaptation of Tibetan pigs to high-altitude hypoxia. Therefore, we conducted a systematic analysis of 140 whole-genome sequencing (WGS) data points from different representing pig populations. Our analysis identified a total of 27,614,561 mutations, including 22,386,319 single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) and 5,228,242 insertions/deletions (INDELs, size < 50 bp). A total of 11% (2,678,569) of the SNVs were newly identified in our project, significantly expanding the dataset of genetic variants in Tibetan pigs. Compared to other pig breeds, Tibetan pigs are uniquely adapted to high-altitude environments, exhibiting the highest genetic diversity and the lowest inbreeding coefficient. Employing the composite of multiple signals (CMS) method, we scanned the genome-wide Darwinian positive selection signals and identified 32,499 Tibetan pig positively selected SNVs (TBPSSs) and 129 selected genes (TBPSGs), including 213 newly discovered genes. Notably, we identified eight genes (PHACTR1, SFI1, EPM2A, SLC30A7, NKAIN2, TNNI3K, and PLIN2) with strong nature selection signals. They are likely to improve cardiorespiratory function and fat metabolism to help Tibetan pigs become adapted to the high-altitude environment. These findings provide new insights into the genetic mechanisms of high-altitude adaptation and the adaptive phenotypes of Tibetan pigs.

The impact of social complexity on the efficacy of natural selection in termites

The impact of social complexity on the efficacy of natural selection in termites

Ecological speciation in East African freshwater crabs of the genus Arcopotamonautes Bott, 1955 across a lake-river boundary in the Lake Malawi catchment (Potamoidea: Potamonautidae: Potamonatinae)

Abstract Geological, climate and ecosystem changes in Africa likely influenced speciation of Afrotropical freshwater crabs. In total, the subfamily Potamonautinae comprises over 120 species, and this diversity provides a valuable opportunity to explore speciation processes. Here we study diversification of potamonautid crabs in the Lake Malawi catchment, and investigate whether speciation has taken place across a lake-river boundary. Specifically, we reconstruct evolutionary relationships of the Malawi blue crab, Arcopotamonautes orbitospinus (Cunnington, 1907), an endemic of Lake Malawi, and of A. montivagus (Chace, 1953) from rivers and streams draining into Lake Malawi, and smaller lakes within this catchment. Our phylogenetic analysis of over 28,000 single nucleotide polymorphisms shows a monophyletic A. orbitospinus nested within a clade otherwise comprised of A. montivagus from across the Lake Malawi catchment (A. montivagus Group I). We also identified a second allopatric clade of A. montivagus from the Rungwe mountains of Tanzania, and neighbouring Zambia (A. montivagus Group II). Morphological differences were apparent between all three groups. Collectively these results show A. montivagus is a paraphyletic riverine taxon that has diversified in allopatry, and that this species entered Lake Malawi and seeded the specialised heavily armoured lacustrine species, A. orbitospinus. We hypothesise that formation of deep-water conditions within Lake Malawi, together with differences in predation pressures between the rivers and lake, provided ecological opportunities for natural selection to drive speciation across the lake-river boundary. We conclude that geographical separation and ecological adaptation are potentially important drivers of evolutionary diversification in these enigmatic freshwater crabs.

Screening of functional genes for hypoxia adaptation in Tibetan pigs by combined genome resequencing and transcriptome analysis.

The high-altitude, low-oxygen environment of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau poses significant challenges for the introduction of superior livestock breeds. However, local plateau species have adapted to thrive and reproduce under these harsh conditions. Understanding the molecular mechanisms behind plateau animals' adaptation to low-oxygen environments is essential for breeding livestock suited to high-altitude regions. Tibetan pigs, which have undergone long-term natural selection and artificial breeding, have developed the ability to survive and reproduce in hypoxic environments. In this study, we conducted whole-genome resequencing of 30 Tibetan pigs from high-altitude regions and 30 Diannan small-ear pigs from low-altitude areas, to identify candidate genes that support Tibetan pigs' adaptation to hypoxic conditions through selection signal analysis. Additionally, we performed transcriptome sequencing on five tissues (heart, liver, spleen, lung, and bone marrow) from both Tibetan pigs and Diannan small-ear pigs to identify genes with significant differential expression between the two breeds. We then integrated the genomic and transcriptomic data by examining the expression of candidate genes identified in selection signal analysis across different tissues. The selection signal analysis identified 10 genes-HES4, ANGPT1, HIF3A, SPHK2, PCK2, RCN3, HIGD2A, DNM2, IRF9, and SRF-that were under positive selection in the Tibetan pig population and are associated with hypoxia adaptation. When combined with transcriptome data, we found that five of these genes-HIF3A, RCN3, HIGD2A, PCK2, and IRF9-exhibited differential expression. Through an integrated approach of selection signal and transcriptome analysis, we identified five key functional genes that contribute to the adaptation of Tibetan pigs to hypoxic environments. These findings offer new insights into the adaptability of plateau animals.