Objective: To evaluate esophageal speech quality in patients after total laryngectomy using cepstral, spectral and time-based measures. Patients and Methods: The subjects were all males and included 20 total laryngectomy patients and 20 age-matched normal controls. The sustained vowel /a/ was measured using the tools of MDVP (Multi-Dimensional Voice Program) and ADSV (Analysis of Dysphonia in Speech and Voice). Results: Compared to normal controls, esophageal speakers showed significantly lower values for cepstral peak prominence (CPP) and a low- to high-frequency spectral energy (L/H) ratio, but their mean CPP fundamental frequency (CPP F0) was higher. Highly negative correlations were found between CPP and jitter (percent jitter), shimmer (percent shimmer) and noise-to-harmonics ratio (NHR). Positive correlations were also found between L/H ratio and CPP. CPP F0 showed a positive correlation with F0, shimmer and NHR. In addition, CPP and L/H ratio parameters indicated an area under the curve of 0.93 or higher compared to that for time-based measures. Conclusion: This study showed that cepstral and spectral analyses are more effective than time-based analysis in examining the voice quality of alaryngeal speakers. The present findings are expected to contribute to establishing the baseline for voice quality characteristics in total laryngectomy patients.
Read full abstract