We compared the variability in forage fish recruitment over the last 27 years against major ecological changes that occurred in Lake Erie over the same time period. During a period of high adult walleye abundance and declining phosphorus loading (1976-1982), we observed a decline in the abundance of later hatching forage fish species (e.g., July) and those species that did not shift their diets from zooplankton to benthos during the summer of their life. During years of high young-of-the-year (YOY) white perch abundance (1983-1990), forage fishes whose hatching dates and (or) diet overlapped with YOY white perch declined in abundance. When the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha) became abundant (1991-1995), most forage fishes showed no change in abundances. Given a YOY's ability to switch to benthos during summer, the date on which this occurred was determined by a combination of zooplankton abundance and fish size. Hence, the dates individual taxa of fish hatch relative to seasonal cycles of zooplankton abundance and the size at which they can undergo an ontogenetic diet shift to benthos and (or) fish could be influencing fish growth and recruitment and need to be incorporated into YOY recruitment models.