Molecular Catalysts Research Articles

Mechanistic insights into multimetal synergistic and electronic effects in a hexanuclear iron catalyst with a [Fe3(μ3-O)(μ2-OH)]2 core for enhanced water oxidation.

Multinuclear molecular catalysts mimicking natural photosynthesis have been shown to facilitate water oxidation; however, such catalysts typically operate in organic solutions, require high overpotentials and have unclear catalytic mechanisms. Herein, a bio-inspired hexanuclear iron(III) complex I, Fe6(μ3-O)2(μ2-OH)2(bipyalk)2(OAc)8 (H2bipyalk = 2,2'-([2,2'-bipyridine]-6,6'-diyl)bis(propan-2-ol); OAc = acetate) with desirable water solubility and stability was designed and used for water oxidation. Our results showed that I has high efficiency for water oxidation via the water nucleophilic attack (WNA) pathway with an overpotential of only ca. 290 mV in a phosphate buffer of pH 2. Importantly, key high-oxidation-state metal-oxo intermediates formed during water oxidation were identified by in situ spectroelectrochemistry and oxygen atom transfer reactions. Theoretical calculations further supported the above identification. Reversible proton transfer and charge redistribution during water oxidation enhanced the electron and proton transfer ability and improved the reactivity of I. Here, we have shown the multimetal synergistic and electronic effects of catalysts in water oxidation reactions, which may contribute to the understanding and design of more advanced molecular catalysts.

Cobalt Tetracationic 3,4-Pyridinoporphyrazine for Direct CO2 to Methanol Conversion Escaping the CO Intermediate Pathway.

Molecular catalysts offer a unique opportunity to implement different chemical functionalities to steer the efficiency and selectivity for the CO2 reduction for instance. Metalloporphyrins and metallophthalocyanines are under high scrutiny since their most classic derivatives the tetraphenylporphyrin (TPP) and parent phthalocyanine (Pc), have been used as the molecular platform to install, hydrogen bonds donors, proton relays, cationic fragments, incorporation in MOFs and COFs, to enhance the catalytic power of these catalysts. Herein, we examine the electrocatalytic properties of the tetramethyl cobalt (II) tetrapyridinoporphyrazine (CoTmTPyPz) for the reduction of CO2 in heterogeneous medium when adsorbed on carbon nanotubes (CNT) at a carbon paper (CP) electrode. Unlike reported electrocatalysis with cobalt based phthalocyanine where CO was advocated as the two electron and two protons reduced intermediate on the way to the formation of methanol, we found here that CoTmTPyPz does not reduce CO to methanol. Henceforth, ruling out a mechanistic pathway where CO is a reaction intermediate.

Ligand engineering towards electrocatalytic urea synthesis on a molecular catalyst

Electrocatalytic C-N coupling from carbon dioxide and nitrate provides a sustainable alternative to the conventional energy-intensive urea synthetic protocol, enabling wastes upgrading and value-added products synthesis. The design of efficient and stable electrocatalysts is vital to promote the development of electrocatalytic urea synthesis. In this work, copper phthalocyanine (CuPc) is adopted as a modeling catalyst toward urea synthesis owing to its accurate and adjustable active configurations. Combining experimental and theoretical studies, it can be observed that the intramolecular Cu-N coordination can be strengthened with optimization in electronic structure by amino substitution (CuPc-Amino) and the electrochemically induced demetallation is efficiently suppressed, serving as the origination of its excellent activity and stability. Compared to that of CuPc (the maximum urea yield rate of 39.9 ± 1.9 mmol h−1 g−1 with 67.4% of decay in 10 test cycles), a high rate of 103.1 ± 5.3 mmol h−1 g−1 and remarkable catalytic durability have been achieved on CuPc-Amino. Isotope-labelling operando electrochemical spectroscopy measurements are performed to disclose reaction mechanisms and validate the C-N coupling processes. This work proposes a unique scheme for the rational design of molecular electrocatalysts for urea synthesis.

Molecular catalysts for electrocatalytic ammonia oxidation

Molecular catalysts for electrocatalytic ammonia oxidation

Stabilization of High-Valent Molecular Cobalt Sites through Oxidized Phosphorus in Reduced Graphene Oxide for Enhanced Oxygen Evolution Catalysis.

Heterogeneous molecular cobalt (Co) sites represent one type of classical catalytic sites for electrochemical oxygen evolution reaction (OER) in alkaline solutions. There are dynamic equilibriums between Co2+, Co3+ and Co4+ states coupling with OH-/H+ interaction before and during the OER event. Since the emergence of Co2+ sites is detrimental to the OER cycle, the stabilization of high-valent Co sites to shift away from the equilibrium becomes critical and is proposed as a new strategy to enhance OER. Herein, phosphorus (P) atoms were doped into reduced graphene oxide to link molecular Co2+ acetylacetonate toward synthesizing a novel heterogeneous molecular catalyst. By increasing the oxidation states of P heteroatoms, the linked Co sites were spontaneously oxidized from 2+ to 3+ states in a KOH solution through OH- ions coupling at an open circuit condition. With excluding the Co2+ sites, the as-derived Co sites with 3+ initial states exhibited intrinsically high OER activity, validating the effectiveness of the strategy of stabilizing high valence Co sites.

A Stepwise Electrochemical Baeyer-Villiger Oxidation with Water as the Oxygen Source.

Baeyer-Villiger oxidation is a method with a 125-year history that produces lactones through a synergistic mechanism by reaction with stoichiometric peracids. Therefore, substituted lactones can be obtained from only substituted cyclic ketones. In this context, an electrochemical Baeyer-Villiger oxidation was developed using a CeO2@PbO2@Ti electrode, which produces substituted lactones through a stepwise mechanism. PbO2, in combination with a benzoic acid molecular catalyst, can generate and utilize reactive oxygen species from electrochemical water splitting to serve as the oxidant. CeO2 is designed to promote the stepwise mechanism while suppressing the synergistic mechanism. Therefore, substituted lactone can be produced from unsubstituted cyclic ketone with high selectivity (77%) and yield (20 mM) through a carbocation rearrangement process. The developed stepwise electrochemical Baeyer-Villiger oxidation, using water as the oxygen source, offers a new green approach to organic synthesis.

Heterobimetallic NiFe Complex for Photocatalytic CO2 Reduction: United Efforts of NiFe Dual Sites.

Catalytic CO2 reduction poses a significant challenge for the conversion of CO2 into chemicals and fuels. Ni-Fe carbon monoxide dehydrogenase ([NiFe]-CODH) effectively mediates the reversible conversion of CO2 and CO at a nearly thermodynamic equilibrium potential, highlighting the heterobimetallic cooperation for the design of CO2 reduction catalysts. However, numerous NiFe biomimetic model complexes have realized little success in CO2 reduction catalysis, which underscores the crucial role of precise bimetallic configuration and functionality. Herein, we presented a heterobimetallic NiFe complex for the photocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CO, demonstrating significantly enhanced catalytic performance compared to the homonuclear NiNi catalyst. Photocatalytic and mechanistic investigations revealed that with the assistance of a redox-active phenanthroline ligand, NiFe achieves dual-site activation of CO2 through a pivotal intermediate, NiII(μ-CO22--κC:κO)FeII, where the Lewis acidity of the FeII site plays an important role, as corroborated in the homonuclear FeFe system. This study introduces the first heteronuclear NiFe molecular catalyst capable of efficiently catalyzing the reduction of CO2 to CO, deepening insights into heterobimetallic cooperation and offering a novel strategy for designing highly active and selective CO2 reduction catalysts.

Conversion of Nitrate to Ammonia by Amidinothiourea-Coordinated Metal Molecular Electrocatalysts with d-π Conjugation.

The electrochemical reduction of nitrate to ammonia (NO3RR) provides a desired alternative of the traditional Haber-Bosch route for ammonia production, igniting a research boom in the development of electrocatalysts with high activity. Among them, molecular electrocatalysts hold considerable promise for the NO3RR, suppressing the competing hydrogen evolution reaction. However, the complicated synthesis procedure, usage of environmentally unfriendly organic solvents, and poor stability of Cu-based molecular electrocatalysts greatly limit their employment in NO3RR, and the development of desired Cu-based molecular catalysts remains challenging. Herein, a simple nonorganic solvent involving a one-step strategy was proposed to synthesize d-π-conjugated molecular electrocatalysts metal-amidinothiourea (M-ATU). Cu-ATU is composed of Cu coordinated with two S and two N atoms, whereas Ni-ATU is formed by Ni with four N atoms from two ATU ligands. Remarkably, Cu-ATU with a Cu-N2S2 coordination configuration exhibits superior NO3RR activity with a NH3 yield rate of 159.8 mg h-1 mgcat-1 (-1.54 V) and Faradaic efficiency of 91.7% (-1.34 V), outperforming previously reported molecular catalysts. Compared to Ni-ATU, Cu-ATU transfers more electrons to the *NO intermediate, effectively breaking the strong sp2 hybridization system and weakening the energy of N═O bonds. The increase in free energy of *NO reduced the energy barriers of the rate-determining step, facilitating the further hydrogenation process over Cu-ATU. Our work opened up a new horizon for exploring molecular electrocatalysts for nitrate activation and paved a way for the in-depth understanding of catalytic behaviors, aligning more closely with industrial demands.

Hydrophobic assembly of molecular catalysts at the gas-liquid-solid interface drives highly selective CO2 electromethanation.

Molecular catalysts offer tunable active and peripheral sites, rendering them ideal model systems to explore fundamental concepts in catalysis. However, hydrophobic designs are often regarded as detrimental for dissolution in aqueous electrolytes. Here we show that established cobalt terpyridine catalysts modified with hydrophobic perfluorinated alkyl side chains can assemble at the gas-liquid-solid interfaces on a gas diffusion electrode. We find that the self-assembly of these perfluorinated units on the electrode surface results in a catalytic system selective for electrochemical CO2 reduction to CH4, whereas every other cobalt terpyridine catalyst reported previously was only selective for CO or formate. Mechanistic investigations suggest that the pyridine units function as proton shuttles that deliver protons to the dynamic hydrophobic pocket in which CO2 reduction takes place. Finally, integration with fluorinated carbon nanotubes as a hydrophobic conductive scaffold leads to a Faradaic efficiency for CH4 production above 80% at rates above 10 mA cm-2-impressive activities for a molecular electrocatalytic system.

Voltage-Driven Molecular Photoelectrocatalysis of Water Oxidation.

Molecular photocatalysis and photoelectrocatalysis have been widely used to conduct oxidation-reduction processes ranging from fuel generation to electroorganic synthesis. We recently showed that an electrostatic potential drop across the double layer contributes to the driving force for electron transfer (ET) between a dissolved reactant and a molecular catalyst immobilized directly on the electrode surface. In this article, we report voltage-driven molecular photoelectrocatalysis with a prevalent homogeneous water oxidation catalyst, (bpy)Cu (II), which was covalently attached to the carbon surface and exhibited photocatalytic activity. The strong potential dependence of the photooxidation current suggests that the electrostatic potential drop across the double layer contributes to the driving force for ET between a water molecule and the excited state of surface-bound (bpy)Cu (II). Scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM) was used to analyze the products and determine the faradaic efficiencies for the generation of oxygen and hydrogen peroxide. Unlike electrocatalytic water oxidation by (bpy)Cu (II) in the dark, which produces only O2, the voltage-driven photooxidation includes an additional 2e- pathway generating H2O2. DFT calculations show that the applied voltage and the presence of light can alter the activation energy for the rate-determining water nucleophilic attack steps, thereby increasing the reaction rate of photo-oxidation of water and opening the 2e- pathway. These results suggest a new route for designing next-generation hybrid molecular photo(electro)catalysts for water oxidation and other processes.

Supramolecular Anchoring of Fe(III) Molecular Redox Catalysts into Graphitic Surfaces Via CH‐π and π–π Interactions for CO2 Electroreduction

AbstractPhotoelectrochemical devices require solid anodes and cathodes for the easy assembling of the whole cell and thus redox catalysts need to be deposited on the electrodes. Typical catalyst deposition involves drop casting, spin coating, doctor blading or related techniques to generate modified electrodes where the active catalyst in contact with the electrolyte is only a very small fraction of the deposited mass. We have developed a methodology where the redox catalyst is deposited at the electrode based on supramolecular interactions, namely CH‐π and π–π between the catalyst and the surface. This generates a very well‐defined catalysts‐surface structure and electroactivity, together with a very large catalytic response. This approach represents a new anchoring strategy that can be applied to catalytic redox reactions in heterogeneous phase and compared to traditional methods involves about 4–5 orders of magnitude less mass deposition to achieve comparable activity and with very well‐behaved electroactivity and stability.

Selective coupling on molecular catalysts

Selective coupling on molecular catalysts

Synthesis of Branched α-Olefins via Trimerization and Tetramerization of Ethylene.

α-Olefins are very important bulk and fine chemicals and their synthesis from ethylene, an abundantly available and inexpensive feedstock, is highly attractive. Unfortunately, the direct or on-purpose synthesis of olefins from ethylene is limited to three examples, 1-butene, 1-hexene, and 1-octene, all having a linear structure. Herein, the direct synthesis of 3-methylenepentane and 4-ethylhex-1-ene, branched trimerization, and tetramerization products of ethylene, respectively, is reported. Different molecular titanium catalysts, all highly active, with a selectivity toward the formation of the branched ethylene trimer or tetramer, the employment of different activators, and different reaction conditions are the key to selective product formation. The long-time stability of selected catalysts employed permits upscaling as demonstrated for the synthesis of 4-ethylhex-1-ene (52g isolated, TON(ethylene) 10.7 · 106).

{Co4O4} Cubanes in a conducting polymer matrix as bio-inspired molecular oxygen evolution catalysts

Exploration of efficient molecular water oxidation catalysts for long-term application remains a key challenge for the conversion of renewable energy sources into fuels. Cuboidal {Co4O4} complexes keep attracting interest as molecular water oxidation catalysts as they combine features of both heterogeneous and homogeneous catalysis with bio-inspired motifs. However, the application of many cluster-based catalysts for the oxygen evolution reaction still requires new stabilization strategies. Drawing inspiration from the stabilizing effects of natural polymers, we introduce a conductive polymer-hybrid approach to covalently immobilize {Co4O4} cubane oxo clusters as oxygen evolution catalysts. Polypyrrole is applied as an efficient p-type conducting polymer that promotes hole transfer during the oxygen evolution reaction, resulting in higher turnover frequency compared to the pristine {Co4O4} oxo cluster and heterogeneous Co-oxide benchmarks. The asymmetric coordination of {Co4O4} not only mitigates catalyst decomposition pathways, but also increases the catalytic efficiency by exposing a directed cofacial dihydroxide motif during catalysis.

Heterometallic Transition Metal Oxides Containing Lewis Acids as Molecular Catalysts for the Reduction of Carbon Dioxide to Carbon Monoxide with Bimodal Activity.

Electrocatalytic CO2 reduction (e-CO2RR) to CO is replete with challenges including the need to carry out e-CO2RR at low overpotentials. Previously, a tricopper-substituted polyoxometalate was shown to reduce CO2 to CO with a very high faradaic efficiency albeit at -2.5 V versus Fc/Fc+. It is now demonstrated that introducing a nonredox metal Lewis acid, preferably GaIII, as a binding site for CO2 in the first coordination sphere of the polyoxometalate, forming heterometallic polyoxometalates, e.g., [SiCuIIFeIIIGaIII(H2O)3W9O37]8-, leads to bimodal activity optimal both at -2.5 and -1.5 V versus Fc/Fc+; reactivity at -1.5 V being at an overpotential of ∼150 mV. These results were observed by cyclic voltammetry and quantitative controlled potential electrolysis where high faradaic efficiency and chemoselectivity were obtained at -2.5 and -1.5 V. A reaction with 13CO2 revealed that CO2 disproportionation did not occur at -1.5 V. EPR spectroscopy showed reduction, first of CuII to CuI and FeIII to FeII and then reduction of a tungsten atom (WVI to WV) in the polyoxometalate framework. IR spectroscopy showed that CO2 binds to [SiCuIIFeIIIGaIII(H2O)3W9O37]8- before reduction. In situ electrochemical attenuated total reflection surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (ATR-SEIRAS) with pulsed potential modulated excitation revealed different observable intermediate species at -2.5 and -1.5 V. DFT calculations explained the CV, the formation of possible activated CO2 species at both -2.5 and -1.5 V through series of electron transfer, proton-coupled electron transfer, protonation and CO2 binding steps, the active site for reduction, and the role of protons in facilitating the reactions.

Photosynthetic biohybrid systems for solar fuels catalysis.

Photosynthetic reaction center (RC) proteins are finely tuned molecular systems optimized for solar energy conversion. RCs effectively capture and convert sunlight with near unity quantum efficiency utilizing light-induced directional electron transfer through a series of molecular cofactors embedded within the protein core to generate a long-lived charge separated state with a useable electrochemical potential. Of current interest are new strategies that couple RC chemistry to the direct synthesis of energy-rich compounds. This Feature Article highlights recent work from our lab on RC and RC-inspired hybrid systems that capture the Sun's energy and convert it to chemical energy in the form of H2, a carbon-neutral energy source derived from water. Biohybrids made from the Photosystem I (PSI) RC are among the best photocatalytic H2-producing protein hybrids to date. Targeted self-assembly strategies that couple abiotic catalysts to PSI translate to catalyst incorporation at intrinsic PSI sites within thylakoid membranes to achieve complete solar water-splitting systems. RC-inspired biohybrids interface synthetic photosensitizers and molecular catalysts with small proteins to create photocatalytic systems and enable the spectroscopic discernment of the structural features and electron transfer processes that underpin solar-driven proton reduction. In total, these studies showcase the incredible scientific opportunities photosynthetic biohybrid research provides for harnessing the optimal qualities of both artificial and natural photosynthetic systems and developing materials that capture, convert, and store solar energy as a fuel.

Electroreduction of CO2 to methane with triazole molecular catalysts

Electroreduction of CO2 to methane with triazole molecular catalysts

Electrocatalytic Conversion of CO2 to Formic Acid: A Journey from 3d-Transition Metal-Based Molecular Catalyst Design to Electrolyzer Assembly.

ConspectusElectrochemical CO2 reduction to obtain formate or formic acid is receiving significant attention as a method to combat the global warming crisis. Significant efforts have been devoted to the advancement of CO2 reduction techniques over the past few decades. This Account provides a unified discussion on various electrochemical methodologies for CO2 to formate conversion, with a particular focus on recent advancements in utilizing 3d-transition-metal-based molecular catalysts. This Account primarily focuses on understanding molecular functions and mechanisms under homogeneous conditions, which is essential for assessing the optimized reaction conditions for molecular catalysts. The unique architectural features of the formate dehydrogenase (FDH) enzyme provide insight into the key role of the surrounding protein scaffold in modulating the active site dynamics for stabilizing the key metal-bound CO2 intermediate. Additionally, the protein moiety also triggers a facile proton relay around the active site to drive electrocatalytic CO2 reduction forward. The fine-tuning of FDH machinery also ensures that the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction leads to the production of formic acid as the major yield without any other carbonaceous products, while limiting the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction. These lessons from the enzymes are key in designing biomimetic molecular catalysts, primarily based on multidentate ligand scaffolds containing peripheral proton relays. The subtle modifications of the ligand framework ensure the favored production of formic acid following electrocatalytic CO2 reduction in the solution phase. Next, the molecular catalysts are required to be mounted on robust electroactive surfaces to develop their corresponding heterogeneous versions. The surface-immobilization provides an edge to the molecular electrocatalysts as their reactivity can be scaled up with improved durability for long-term electrocatalysis. Despite challenges in developing high-performance, selective catalysts for the CO2 to formic acid transformation, significant progress is being made with the tactical use of graphene and carbon nanotube-based materials. To date, the majority of the research activity stops here, as the development of an operational CO2 to formic acid converting electrolyzer prototype still remains in its infancy. To elaborate on the potential future steps, this Account covers the design, scaling parameters, and existing challenges of assembling large-scale electrolyzers. A short glimpse at the utilization of electrolyzers for industrial-scale CO2 reduction is also provided here. The proper evaluation of the surface-immobilized electrocatalysts assembled in an electrolyzer is a key step for gauging their potential for practical viability. Here, the key electrochemical parameters and their expected values for industrial-scale electrolyzers have been discussed. Finally, the techno-economic aspects of the electrolyzer setup are summarized, completing the journey from tactical design of molecular catalysts to their appropriate application in a commercially viable electrolyzer setup for CO2 to formate electroreduction. Thus, this Account portrays the complete story of the evolution of a molecular catalyst to its sustainable application in CO2 utilization.

Bimetallic Copper Complexes for Electrocatalytic Bidirectional O2/H2O Conversion in Aqueous Solution

AbstractThe distinctive interplay between abundant transition metal‐containing active sites and their surrounding outer coordination sphere (OCS) is pivotal in achieving remarkable catalytic responses. In this context, copper complexes continue to garner attention as promising catalysts for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) and oxygen evolution reaction (OER). In this article, we report two macrocyclic binuclear Cu complexes having variable peripheral functionalities around a common N2O2 like core. A mononuclear complex bearing the salophen‐type ligand design was used as a control. The complex featuring peripheral OH groups demonstrates the highest catalytic activity in ORR (3050 s−1) and OER (6700 s−1), suggesting the crucial role of the alcoholic group during catalysis. In contrast, the mononuclear complex necessitates an additional thermodynamic stimulus to attain catalytic conditions for ORR and OER obverse to the case of binuclear complexes. Hence, this study establishes a template for designing molecular catalysts to mediate energy‐relevant multielectron/multiproton reactions in both oxidizing and reducing environments.

Covalently Anchored Molecular Catalyst onto a Graphitic Carbon Nitride Surface for Photocatalytic Epoxidation of Olefins.

This study explores an innovative photocatalytic approach using pristine graphitic carbon nitride (C3N4) to anchor iron salen-type complexes (FeSalenCl2) without the need for additional linkers or heterojunctions. The resulting hybrid catalyst, [C3N4-FeCl(Salen)]Chem, exhibits a promising catalytic performance in the selective epoxidation of cyclic and linear olefins using gaseous oxygen as the oxidant. The catalyst's selectivity closely resembles that of the free iron complex, and its effectiveness varies depending on the olefin substrate. Additionally, solvent selection plays a critical role in achieving optimal performance, with acetonitrile proving to be the best choice. The study demonstrates the potential of C3N4 as an environmentally friendly, recyclable, and efficient support for molecular catalysts. The results highlight the versatility and significance of C3N4-based materials in advancing light-driven catalysis.