Children, Youth and Environments Vol. 18 No. 2 (2008) ISSN: 1546-2250 Schools and Kindergartens: A Design Manual Dudek, Mark (2007). Switzerland: Birkhaüser Verlag AG; 255 pages. $129. ISBN 9783764370534. Schools and Kindergartens: A Design Manual assembles two books in one, though this is not the stated intention of the author. The first part of the book is a collection of very good essays about various aspects of school design. The second part is a collection of projects presented in the format of well-known architectural magazines: short description, diagrammatic plans, and pretty pictures of the completed building. The essays of the book’s first half are erudite and useful discourses on different concepts and problems that confront contemporary school designers. After an introduction by the author/editor, short essays by different experts unfold to introduce “Historical Paradigms,” “Educational Systems,” “Schools in Community,” “School Typologies,” “Spatial Configurations,” “Acoustic Design,” “Lighting Design,” “Sustainability,” “Outdoor Spaces,” and the concluding “An Educationalist’s Perspective on Nursery Design” and “Schools and Kindergartens Under Reconstruction.” Although the topics at times overlap, (e.g., “Historic Paradigms and Educational Systems”) or set forth competing systems of architectural theory (e.g., “School Typologies” and “Spatial Configurations”), they nonetheless cover a wide range of materials that will prove useful, both for professionals familiar with school design and for clients and communities looking for a guide to successfully understanding the problems of designing for education. The information in the essays is precise without being pedantic, sophisticated while remaining clear. However, there are three critical topics that remain neglected: community participation, context, and evaluation. Although the essay on “Schools in Community” addresses the importance of understanding the social setting of education, in the end the essay 276 stops short of defining or recommending possible ways in which the community can participate in the design of their school. This is unfortunate on two fronts. First, the value of contributions made by a community of citizens in democratic assembly is overshadowed in the essay by the need for designers to establish ties with organizations within the community. Second, although this same essay concludes that “The future is in making these facilities open to the public, yet at the same time safe, secure and effective for those attending as full time students,” the value of life-long learning models within a community is left unexplored. The aspirations of a community for its structures must be clearly articulated, especially when considering schools, for it is in these buildings that the values and needs of the citizenry are established. The difficulty with this book, and indeed with most books on public projects, is that the specific socio-political context of the project is left ill-defined, if not ignored completely. The corollary aspect of school design that is missing from this book is an evaluation of the successes and failures of the designs. This lack of critique is especially evident in the second half of the book. “What is the relationship between pedagogical visions and spaces for children?” Although the preface of the book begins with this provocative question, it unfortunately remains largely unexplored in the examples provided. Rather than critique the collected designs using the criteria assembled by the experts in their essays, the book reverts to a traditional catalogue of attractive buildings organized by loosely defined categories of age groups: Nurseries and Kindergartens, Special Schools, Primary Schools, Secondary Schools, and Academies and Vocational Schools. The failure of this book’s second half, unfortunately, is not unusual. The illustration of buildings in the catalogue, by following the industry standard, undermines the possibility for any serious critique. For example, despite the essay authors’ call for lighting, acoustic and sustainable designs, almost all of the drawings in the catalogue are plans. Without cross-section drawings it becomes impossible to understand how or why the examples given are “good design.” Similarly, despite a clearly written and compelling essay on the importance of outdoor play areas, almost none of the projects 277 includes a site plan, let alone details about a project’s landscape strategy. And these are just technical considerations. Nowhere in the catalogue of projects, for example, is there an attempt to assess the success of...
Read full abstract