The utilization of heavy metal-organic polluted cultivated land caused by the e-waste dismantling industry was affected by multi-dimensional factors. Thus a comprehensive evaluation of these multi-dimensional impacts was necessary for the technical selection and solution of cultivated land utilization. This study attempted to conduct a total benefit simulation analysis on the redevelopment of polluted cultivated land, which was of great significance to decision-making. With a systematic framework designed including the casual relations between components, a system dynamics model was constructed to simulate the technological, economic, and ecological benefits of different polluted cultivated land-used modes, along with which a questionnaire was designed to investigate and analyze the associated social effects. Based on these, the total benefits of the land-use mode were evaluated and optimized within the framework of the “technological-economic-ecological-social” evaluation system. This study included microscale, mesoscale, and macroscale, with multi-dimensional and complex influencing factors, and had advanced research value. The results of the system dynamics model simulation showed that remediation plants played a decisive role in pollutants removal. The flower industry had the highest net present value, but its ecological performance was poor. The overall analysis showed that the scenario of utilization after remediation had the highest performance score, which was attributed to high pollutant removal, low cost, and high carbon sink. This study was meaningful for providing research ideas of comprehensive benefits of polluted cultivated land utilization and also helpful for decision-making. This paper also provided research ideas for other industries such as contaminated site remediation and sewage sludge treatment.