Milk casein is a rich source of antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) and the most common way to produce AMPs is enzymatic hydrolysis in vitro. In this study, active casein antimicrobial peptide (CAMPs) mixtures were generated by optimized proteolytic cleavage of milk casein. These natural-safe CAMPs mixtures exhibited high activity in the inhibition of Streptococcus mutans and Porphyromonas gingivalis. Morphological characterization suggested the pathogenic bacteria presented incomplete or irregular collapsed membrane surface after the treatment with active CAMPs mixtures. The CAMPs inhibition activity was also effective in the attachment and development of microbial biofilm. Potential CAMPs sequences were unambiguously determined by unbiased proteomic analysis and 301 potential CAMPs were obtained. The activity of 4 novel CAMPs was successfully confirmed by using synthetic standards. This study provides a promising milk CAMPs resource for the development of safe agents in oral bacteria inhibition and functional foods.