AbstractThis work investigates the addition of milled carbon fiber reinforcement and its effect on scratch resistance and mechanical durability for basalt fiber/epoxy composites, assessed under varied loading conditions with the aid of different indenter types according to a factorial design. Composites with MCF content from 0 to 10 wt% were prepared. Scratch behaviors under Vickers and Rockwell indenters were studied for loads of 5, 10, and 15 N. The addition of 10 wt% MCF has resulted in scratch hardness increase from 13.255 N/mm2 up to 47.952 N/mm2, depending on the type of indenter used. Precisely, in conditions of a 5 N load and when a Rockwell‐type indenter was used, a scratch hardness maximum of 47.952 N/mm2 was achieved, while for a Vickers‐type indenter under the same conditions, the maximum value of its equivalent was 23.327 N/mm2. Profilometric and SEM analyses evidence that matrix cracks and surface deformation have been reduced with higher MCF content, at least for the application of lower scratch test loads. The mechanical and surface performances of the basalt fiber composites were found to be considerably improved by the reinforcement with MCF.Highlights Scratch resistance for milled carbon fibers increases and peaks at 10 wt% reinforcement. The Rockwell indenter indicates a steady increase in hardness up to 47,952 N/mm2. Peak hardness of 10 wt% is observed under the Vickers indenter for the 5 N load. Higher milled carbon fiber content reduces matrix cracking and surface deformation. There is a clear correlation between scratch performance, milled carbon fiber content, and indenter type.