Despite numerous studies on the low-salinity waterflooding (LSWF) technique, a robust predictive capability has not yet been established. Predictive capability development is essential to reduce costs and time during the early screening or prioritization of candidate fields for LSWF in the opportunity realization process (ORP). This study aims at proposing a set of screening methods that offer the best LSWF predictive capability for various crude oil-brine-carbonate rock systems. In this regard, the robustness of different methods for predicting oil recovery factor (RF) from core-scale spontaneous imbibition (SI) experiments in carbonate rocks was investigated here. The relevant small-scale screening methods were divided into two distinct categories. The first category includes methods based on rock/fluid interactions: wettability assessment based on flotation and contact angle measurement, and geochemical assessment to identify mineral dissolution (and pH change). The second group includes methods based on probing fluid/fluid interactions: oil-brine interfacial tension (IFT) and viscoelasticity, and micro-dispersion formation. The most common types of carbonate rocks, including dolomite, limestone, and chalk, were used to comprehensively evaluate the response of each carbonate rock type to brines of different salinities. Each rock type could be distinguished with its particular microscopic texture, pore-size, grain type, and carbonate mineral structure. According to the SI results, oil recovery strongly depends not only on brine salinity but also on the rock type. The oil RF for Indiana limestone was found to be higher than that for other rock types but showed less sensitivity to the degree of dilution. Additionally, RF from dolomite and chalk plugs showed the most and the least sensitivity to the degree of brine dilution, respectively. We introduced a brine efficiency index based on the SI results to compare the results for different rock types and salinities. The results of the systematic tests performed here showed that variation of IFT and viscoelasticity (expressed as phase angle) with brine salinity reduction was neither significant nor monotonic, and did not correlate with the brine efficiency index. Also, minor/negligible mineral dissolution was observed upon brine-rock contact. On the other hand, wettability results based on contact angle measurement and flotation, as well as microdispersion results strongly correlated with the brine efficiency index over a wide range of brine salinities, which indicates these techniques can quickly predict the potency of a system toward low salinity effect (LSE). It is hypothesized, therefore, that the techniques which involve rock explicitly would be more robust because they capture the rock-type dependency of LSE too. The findings from this study can be used for quick screening of the candidate formations for LSWF, before performing the costly and time-intensive special core analysis (SCAL) experiments. The data provided by this research can also enrich the SCAL data bank toward developing robust data-driven predictive models.