Bibliometric Analysis Method Research Articles

Çocuk Ruh Sağlığı Konusundaki Bilimsel Yayınların (2000-2022) Bibliyometrik Analizi ve Türkiye’nin Katkısı

Bibliometric analysis studies are studies that reveal research trends by examining existing studies in the literature on certain subjects and guide future research based on this. Child mental health is also an important issue that attracts the attention of the scientific world and is the subject of scientific publications. In this study, using bibliometric analysis method, it is aimed to reveal the status of scientific publications on child mental health between 2000-2022 and Turkey's contribution to these publications. In the study, the Scopus database was examined with the bibliometric data analysis technique. As a keyword, a search was made using the phrase "child mental health" in English in the title section. All articles published between 2000 and 2022 were included in the study. Articles published outside the journal were excluded from the study. In the study, 7960 studies were reached with keywords at the beginning. 6914 of them were made in 2000 and later. 5015 of them are research articles published in a journal. In the study, analyzes were made on these 5015 articles. The languages of the related articles are English (n = 4782), German (n = 64) and Spanish (n = 49), respectively, in terms of frequency. The country with the highest number of publications on child mental health is the United States (n = 1821). There are 52 articles from Turkey contributing to this issue, and it is in the nineteenth place. According to the productivity criteria, when compared to the 2000s, publications on child mental health have increased approximately five times in the 2020s.

A bibliometric analysis and visualization of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease from 2012 to 2021.

As a common chronic liver disease, nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) has attracted increasing attention in the past decade. Nevertheless, there are few bibliometric analyses that systematically study this field as a whole. This paper explores the latest research progress and future research trends of NAFLD through the method of bibliometric analysis. The articles related to NAFLD, published from 2012 to 2021 in the Web of Science Core Collections, were searched on February 21, 2022, using relevant keywords. Two different scientometrics software tools were used to conduct the knowledge maps of NAFLD research field. A total of 7975 articles on NAFLD research were included. From 2012 to 2021, the publications related to NAFLD increased by year. China ranked on the top of the list with 2043 publications, and the University of California System emerged as the premier institution in this field. PLOs One, Journal of Hepatology and Scientific Reports became the prolific journals in this research field. Co-cited reference analysis revealed the landmark literature in this research field. In terms of potential hotspots, the burst keywords analysis revealed that liver fibrosis stage, sarcopenia, and autophagy will become the focus of future NAFLD research. The annual output of the global publications in the field of NAFLD research showed a strong upward trend. Research in the field of NAFLD in China and America is more mature than in other countries. Classic literature lays the foundation for research, and multi-field studies provide the new development directions. And besides, fibrosis stage, sarcopenia and autophagy research are the hot spots and frontiers of this field.

A Patent Bibliometric Analysis of Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCUS) Technology

Large amounts of CO2 from human socioeconomic activities threaten environmental sustainability. Moreover, uncontrolled resource use and lack of relevant technology exacerbate this issue. For this reason, carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS) technology has gained worldwide attention. Many scholars have researched CCUS, but few have used CCUS patent bibliometric analysis from a unified perspective. This article aims to provide a conclusive analysis for CCUS researchers and policymakers, as well as summarize the innovation trends, technological distribution, and topic evolution. Based on 11,915 pieces of patent data from the Derwent Innovations Index, we used bibliometric analysis and data mining methods to conduct research on four dimensions: overall trend, geographical distribution, patentees, and patent content. The results of this article are as follows. CCUS has entered a rapid development stage since 2013. Patents are mainly distributed geographically in China, the US, and Japan, especially in heavy industries such as energy and electricity. Large enterprises hold patents with a relatively stable network of cooperators and attach great importance to international patent protection. A total of 12 topics were identified through clustering, and these topics gradually shifted from technicalities to commercialization, and from industrial production to all aspects of people’s daily lives.

Searching for coherence in a fragmented field: Temporal and keywords network analysis in political science

AbstractIn this paper, we answer the multiple calls for systematic analysis of paradigms and subdisciplines in political science—the search for coherence within a fragmented field. We collected a large dataset of over seven hundred thousand writings in political science from Web of Science since 1946. We found at least two waves of political science development, from behaviorism to new institutionalism. Political science appeared to be more fragmented than literature suggests—instead of ten subdisciplines, we found 66 islands. However, despite fragmentation, there is also a tendency for integration in contemporary political science, as revealed by co-existence of several paradigms and coherent and interconnected topics of the “canon of political science,” as revealed by the core-periphery structure of topic networks. This was the first large-scale investigation of the entire political science field, possibly due to newly developed methods of bibliometric network analysis: temporal bibliometric analysis and island methods of clustering. Methodological contribution of this work to network science is evaluation of islands method of network clustering against a hierarchical cluster analysis for its ability to remove misleading information, allowing for a more meaningful clustering of large weighted networks.

Knowledge mapping and research trends of the social determinants of health (SDoH): a scientometric analysis.

Social determinants of health (SDoH) play an essential role in the risk of developing diseases or medical disorders. Conducting a comprehensive retrospective analysis is necessary to better understand the development status, research hotspots, and development trends of SDoH research. The bibliometric analysis method is applied based on CiteSpace and VOS viewer to quantitatively analyze and visually review the articles published in the field of SDoH from Web of Science core databases from 2000 to 2021. We quantitatively analyzed the author, institution, and other basic information to probe the development of SDoH and then visually investigated the high-frequency keywords, burst keywords, and keyword clusters to understand better the evolution of hotspots and development directions of SDoH during the study period. Health inequality is the main keyword of the SDoH field, and disease burden is expected to maintain a hotspot in recent years. Further, research methodologies could be improved to explain how upstream SDoH influences human lived experience. Additionally, the SDoH field needs to utilize the horizons of the multidisciplinary approach to consider and discuss sustainable development issues to offer implications for health improvement policy and interventions.

A comprehensive review on emerging trends in the dynamic evolution of digital addiction and depression.

Using digital addiction as an umbrella term to cover any type of addictions to digital technologies such as the internet, smartphones, social media, or video games, the current study aimed to reveal the intellectual structure and evolution of research addressing digital addiction-depression relationship. The study combined bibliometric and science mapping analysis methods for this purpose. Data for the study was gathered from Web of Science Core Collection after a comprehensive process of data search/extraction, and 241 articles were included in the final data set. A period-based, comparative science mapping analysis was performed using the SciMAT software. The analysis of data over three periods, Period 1 (1983-2016), Period 2 (2017-2019), and Period 3 (2020-2022) showed that internet addiction was the most significant theme across all three periods, which was followed by social media addiction. Depression, which emerged as a significant theme during Period 1, was later covered under anxiety disorder theme. Research interest was mostly on factors related to both addiction and depression such as cognitive distortion, insomnia, loneliness, self-esteem, social support, alexithymia, as well as cybervictimization or academic performance. The results suggested that much research is warranted on the digital addiction-depression relationship in different age cohorts, especially children and elderly. Similarly, the current analysis showed that this line of research particularly focused on internet, gaming and social media addiction, and evidence with regard to other types of digital addiction or related compulsive behaviors was almost absent. In addition, research was mostly inclined to understanding cause-effect relationships, which is significant, but preventive strategies seemed to be barely addressed. Likewise, the smartphone addiction-depression relationship arguably garnered less research interest, so future research would contribute to the field in this respect.

Trends and Hotspots of Starch Fermentation Research: Bibliometric Analysis Based on CiteSpace

AbstractFermentation is a common topic in starch scientific research and is widely utilized in the food and pharmaceutical industry. Although many papers on starch fermentation have been published in the past 10 years (2012–2022), reviews of the overall knowledge structure of the discipline are relatively rare. Research in this area progresses rapidly. To stay current with the emerging trends, this review uses a bibliometric analysis method based on CiteSpace software to analyze, review, and briefly comment on selected articles published in the field of starch fermentation over the past 10 years. The research progress and emerging trend of starch fermentation are discussed. A total of 4943 references are used for analysis on CiteSpace. The results showed that from 2012 to 2022, the rate of published articles and the number of citations have increased. China is in first place by number of publications. Jiangnan University is the most prolific institutions, and the most prolific author is Akihiko Kondo. Among the category collaboration, “Agriculture” and “Food Science and Technology” are the first in the two sets of 5 year periods. The keyword “ethanol” shows the highest burst strength level. In addition, food fermentation and clean energy research are the main areas of concern in this field. This review aims to provide new insights for promoting the industrialization development and clinical application of starch fermentation technology.

TAX COMPLIANCE COST: EXPLORE BODY OF LITERATURE BY USE SCIENCE MAPPING

This research aims to explore the knowledge base of tax compliance cost research. Sample literature was taken through the Scopus database. The sample consists of 67 literatures on tax compliance costs with coverage from 1978 to 2021. This research uses systematic literature review, science mapping, and bibliometric analysis methods. Content analysis is carried out to understand in depth the current research topic. In general, the results of the study conclude that research on tax compliance costs needs to go to beyond the complexity of taxation. This research contributes to help academic researchers, policy maker, and regulators potraiying the complete picture of this research area and allow them to formulate furthure research and evidance base policy.

Analisis Bibliometrik Good Government Governance di Indonesia dari Tahun 2015-2020

This study aims to map the research topics carried out by “Good Government Governance” researchers. Identify some research variations in terms of keyword, definitions, theories, methodologies, citation, publication year, and research result. Also, provide suggestions for further research. The data used are secondary data. The number of samples in this study were 58 articles about “Good Government Governance”. The data collection technique used the literature study technique in the form of direct observation of articles and books with the bibliometric analysis method using three special applications of bibliometric analysis. The data analysis method used is bibliometric analysis with Publish or Perish, Mendeley, VOSviewer with tables and graphs using the Microsoft Office Excel program. The results of this study indicate that the vosviewer mapping shows that there are 5 clusters that discuss the topic of “Good Government Governance”, definition of Good Government Governance, Quantitative research methodology, the definition of Good Government Governance, dominating theory is the Agency Theory and Stewardship Theory. The implication of the results of this study can be used for practitioners who are expected to provide a reference for academics such as students, lecturers or teaching accountants who will conduct research using bibliometric analysis in accordance with current issues

The Use of Virtual Worlds in the Field of Education: A Bibliometric Study

The purpose of this study is to examine the publications conducted in education related to virtual worlds with the bibliometric analysis method. This study employed the appropriate keywords determined via digging the Web of Science database. A total of 2,978 publications meeting the criteria of the current study were examined. VOSviewer software was used for the analysis. We utilized co-authorship analysis to see the descriptive characteristics of the examined publications. The most conducted type was proceedings and the number of publications fluctuated over time with a peak in 2012. England, USA, and Spain had the most publications among the countries, and Open University, Coventry University, and the Polytechnic University of Bucharest had the most publications among the organizations. The majority of the studies were published in the journal of Computers & Education, British Journal of Educational Technology, and Interactive Learning Environments. For revealing the most common keywords, we used the co-occurrence analysis. “e-learning”, “second life” and “higher education” were the most occurred keywords in the publications. The citations analysis was used to see which authors and publications were mostly cited in the examined papers. The most cited authors were Dede, C., Lan, Y. and Ketelhut, D. J. According to the analysis of the cited references, Dalgarno and Lee, (2010), Merchant, Goetz, Cifuentes, Keeney-Kennicutt, and Davis, (2014) and Dunleavy et al. (2008) were the most cited studies. Technological developments have affected the interest in the use of VWs in education. As a new type or extension of virtual worlds, metaverse promises new opportunities in education. The findings of this study would present a road map for those future research to see the general picture of the relevant area.

Analisis Bibliometrik Penggunaan Video Pembelajaran di Sekolah Dasar Tahun 2013-2022 Menggunakan Aplikasi VOSViewer

This study aims to analyze the use of instructional videos in elementary schools between 2013 and 2022 using the bibliometric computational mapping analysis method. The Publish or Perish software was used to collect publications data from the Google Scholar database using the keywords "Instructional Video" AND "Elementary School" OR "ES". This search yielded 282 articles. These results indicated that the number of publications related to this topic from 2013-2022 was still small, with an average number of publications of 28.2. Then, it was found that the highest number of publications was in 2021, with a total of 102 articles, while the lowest one was in 2014, with three articles. Analysis of the co-occurrence of keywords using VOSViewer resulted in 15 terms grouped into 5 clusters. Network and density visualization showed several keywords that often appear, namely, Elementary School (ES), instructional video, and video. In addition, the overlay visualization depicted keywords that have become a trend in recent years, namely, video, instructional media, animated video, mathematics learning, and teacher. Thus, future research needs to focus on various types of instructional videos and various subjects in elementary schools.
 Keywords: Bibliometric Analysis, Computational Mapping Analysis, Instructional Video, Elementary School, VOSViewer

A discussion of digital transition impact on facility management of hospital buildings

PurposeThis paper aims to contribute to the discussion of the following questions: How can the digital transition improve the management of the operation and maintenance of infrastructure in health-care facilities? What is the legacy for facility management (FM) teams in this post-COVID-19 management of hospital buildings?Design/methodology/approachBased on a literature review, this paper analyses and categorises existing research on the digital challenges for FM from 2011 until 2021 by conducting a qualitative and quantitative method of bibliometric analysis and discussing the status of digital transition impact on FM of the hospital buildings.FindingsThe trends and challenges of building information modelling, artificial intelligence and the Internet of Things identified and discussed in this paper aim to be as comprehensive as possible to grasp the situation of digital transition in the FM industry in the hospital buildings context. Regarding digital maturity, the limited number of publications highlights that control and management systems cannot fully manage the entire operational phase of hospital buildings. Giving intelligence to buildings will undoubtedly be the future. So making buildings reactive, interactive and immersive is an inevitable transformation for intelligent hospital building systems. Thus, the added value of digitalisation will help facility managers to overcome the issues pointed out in this paper to deal with the growing health demands and enable them to mitigate the impacts of a new and future pandemic.Originality/valueThe novelty of this paper is classifying and unifying facility managers' tendencies regarding high-level information management issues, which are lacking in the literature, with a focus on the approaches with potential and higher impact on FM in the hospital building context and the related steps that should be considered regarding data collection and data structures. These tendencies provide a set of new intelligent approaches and tools, which will increase the efficiency of processes, significantly impacting the potential of optimisation. Also, these trends can improve planning and management of scope, costs, environment and safety in the value chain of projects and assets, thus creating a more resilient and sustainable industry for facility managers in this post-COVID-19 management for hospital buildings.

MULTİPLE SKLEROZ’DA REHABİLİTASYONUN BİLİMSEL HARİTALAMA YÖNTEMİYLE ANALİZİ

This study is about scientific analysis of Multiple sclerosis rehabilitation. For this purpose, scientific mapping method was used in the analysis of publications. Scientific studies published in the Web of Science (WoS) database on rehabilitation in patients with multiple sclerosis between 1986-2021 were analyzed by bibliometric analysis method. VOSviewer package program was used to analyze the data. The data were analyzed in terms of variables such as the author of the publications, countries, active journal, citations, institutions, keywords. As a result of the study, regarding the publications on multiple sclerosis and its rehabilitation; the highest number of studies were published between 2018-2021, with the USA in the first place in this regard; Researchers affiliated with the University of Alabama Birmingham have the most publications on this subject; most publications were published in the journal Disability and Rehabilitation; the researcher who contributed the most to the subject is Robert W. Motl; It was seen that the most cited publication on multiple sclerosis belongs to Kurtzke JF. From Turkey, Idiman E. is at the forefront of the names that contribute to this field. As a result of the findings, it has been observed that the publications on multiple sclerosis and its rehabilitation have increased in recent years. This study can provide researchers with useful information about research directions and limitations, and coauthorship of publications. Focus on research base and collaborations should be increased for high quality multiple sclerosis rehabilitation studies.

EVALUATION OF DIGITAL MARKETING FROM A BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS PERSPECTIVE

It has been concluded that a new transformation in marketing is inevitable, especially during the pandemic period, with the complete disappearance of the traditional customer experience. It has been concluded that a new transformation in marketing is inevitable with the complete disappearance of the traditional customer experience during the pandemic period. The result obtained in this process is the trend from Marketing 4.0 to Marketing 5.0 at the point reached in the digitization of marketing activities. In this context, the aim of the research is to determine the change that started with the digitalization phenomenon in the marketing literature, especially in digital marketing. For this purpose, the marketing literature has been examined by bibliometric analysis method by searching the concept of digital marketing in the journals scanned in TR index in Türkiye since 2000. Thus, 164 articles were included in the analysis. In the studies included in the research; The number of authors, the institutions that the authors are affiliated with, the language used in the studies, the number of articles per publication year, the rate of the magazine with the highest number of publications in the field and the concept of digital marketing together or separately in the title were examined. Material scanning technique was used in data collection. It is thought that the study will contribute to the literature in terms of identifying developments in digital marketing studies and guiding future studies.

Status, Hotspots, and Future Trends: Bibliometric Analysis of Research on the Impact of the Built Environment on Children and Adolescents’ Physical Activity

Applying the visualized bibliometric analysis method, we explored the overall distribution characteristics, research progress, and hotspots of current research on the effect of the built environment on the physical activity of children and adolescents from 2003 to 2022. The research results indicate that the United States, Canada, Australia, and other Western countries are the primary forces of relevant research and have a solid foundation in the research on the impact of the built environment on the physical activity of children and adolescents. Sallis, Saelens, Gile-Corti, and other early authors have had a long-term, important role in this area. The research results have continuously guided new scientific research output for a long time, and emerging research forces have also played a directional role in future research trends, represented by publications such as American Preventive Medicine and Preventive Medicine. Obesity, health behaviors, home–school environment, and various correlations are the research hotspots in this field. This study systematically summarizes and analyzes research on the built environment’s promotion of physical activity among children and adolescents, and it provides valuable guidance and reference for follow-up research in the near future.

BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS OF MATHEMATICAL COMMUNICATION SKILLS USING SCOPUS DATABASE

The purpose of this study is to analyze how the development of research publication trends in mathematical communication skills in mathematics learning for the 2016-2021 period published in Scopus indexed scientific journals, review citation analysis, and examine trend analysis of terms or keywords by authors in journals and journals. The sample uses 142 article titles. Bibliometric analysis methods through quantitative studies are used to collect, process, and analyze data related to mathematical communication skills in mathematics learning. Data retrieval using PoP (Publish or Perish) software. Data analysis is descriptive quantitative. The results showed that the trend of scientific publications regarding the trend of mathematical communication skills increased from 2016-2021. It can be seen from the data that the number of articles published during 2019-2020 was the most researched on mathematical communication skills. The most cited articles related to mathematical communication skills occurred in 2019 with 97 citations. The Pisa question, communication technology, prospective mathematics teacher and self-efficacy are variables that are still rarely studied.

Bibliometric and altmetric analysis of research relating to antiphospholipid syndrome based on VOS viewer (2011-2021).

Antiphospholipid syndrome is an autoimmune disorder characterized by recurrent vascular thrombosis and pregnancy losses in the presence of persistently positive antiphospholipid antibodies. Bibliometric analysis and altmetric analysis are methods of analyzing academic productivity and influence. Currently, the assessment of antiphospholipid syndrome through the above analyses is lacking. This study investigated the quantity and quality of studies in the field of antiphospholipid syndrome and revealed the characteristics of worldwide productivity on this disease by the bibliometric analysis and altmetric analysis. The terms "APS," "antiphospholipid syndrome," "antiphospholipid-antibody syndrome," and "Hughes syndrome" were searched on the Web of Science Core Collection from January 1, 2011, to December 31, 2021. Original articles and reviews were selected. We set the filters as "English." A total of 1818 articles were retrieved from 68 countries, of which 20 met the criteria of major active countries. High-income countries contributed 1341 articles (73.48%). The number of articles annually increased significantly in the 10-year period (P < 0.001). The USA (253, 13.91%) was the most productive country. Adjusted by population, Serbia was top of the list. According to the gross domestic product analysis, Serbia ranked first. The most used keywords such as thrombosis and antiphospholipid antibodies were presented by keywords analyses. A content analysis found antithrombotic and anticoagulant therapy as research hotspots. A significant correlation was detected between average citations and altmetric attention scores (P = 0.002) and Mendeley readers count (P < 0.001). From 2011 to 2021, the number of global articles increased rapidly. Most papers came from high-income countries. The relationship between the bibliometric and altmetric analyses were basically consistent; therefore the two can prove/complement each other. Key points • We revealed the global productivity characteristics of the papers related to antiphospholipid syndrome by using the methods of bibliometric analysis and altmetric analysis. • We found the most selected articles that describe the treatment of antiphospholipid syndrome, especially antithrombotic and anticoagulant treatments, which may be the current research hotspot.

Management of digital transformation in the system of higher education: Global practice

The article discusses various approaches to management processes in the era of digital transformation. Digital challenges in the post-pandemic period have updated new qualification requirements for the higher education system. The transition to distance forms of work, which demonstrated inconsistency in providing quality education, revealed the main problems beginning from a weak infrastructure to the lack of optimal ways of educational activity. The higher education system requires transformation to become competitive in the digital environment and be flexible in assimilating technological innovations. The paper presents the analysis of the main directions of digitalization of higher education with the determined priorities. The study is designed on the methods of bibliometric analysis — counting of the number of publications on a given topic, their content and thesaurus analyses. There were used the built-in tools for analyzing the national bibliographic database of scientific citations and closed systems for searching and machine analysis of large texts of the abstract-analytical system Dimensions.ai. The VOSviewer application was used for the content analysis of the terms, and the resources wordstat.ru and google.trends.com were used to calculate the statistics of requests of the key concepts. The results of the analysis identified a variety of transformational decisions that can be made only at the level of strategic management. System transformations may depend on the given external or internal framework regulated by different subjects of the educational process. The directions of development in the field of digital transformation also depend on the external and internal framework. The article proposes the use of the collegial management format which changes the scheme of interaction between the subjects of education.

An Analysis of the Bibliometric Network on the Impact of Digital Business on Tourism

The purpose of this article is to map the state of E-tourism business tourism research and the connections between these subjects. Using VOSviewer, the bibliometric analysis method helps us visualize and analyze patterns such as co-occurrence of keywords, co-citations of cited authors, and co-citations of cited sources. It also helps us understand the structure related to the topic under study. The Scopus database's 98 publications on etourism- related subjects are examined in total. We discover that since 2008, the trend in etourism research has not substantially grown. Additionally, we identified study subjects that may be investigated using trending keywords. Furthermore, we identified the most influential writers and publications on the subject of e-business and tourist research, as well as the connections between them. To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to use VOSviewer for bibliometric analysis on the subject of e-Tourism and tourism concurrently. 98 publications were thoroughly reviewed.

NATIONAL CONTEXT OF THE STUDY OF THE PROBLEM OF DIGITAL MARKETING MANAGEMENT IN SCIENTOMETRIC DATABASES

This study attempts to determine the content of the national context for studying issues related to digital marketing management. The research was based on scientific articles by Ukrainian scientists included in the Web of Science scientometric database, with a total of 92 articles. The research was conducted using bibliometric analysis methods, including quantitative analysis, relevance of scientific resources, author relevance, relevance of affiliation, and thematic analysis. The limitation of this study is that it focuses exclusively on data from the Web of Science scientometric database. In future research, a similar analysis using other scientometric databases, such as Scopus, would be appropriate to confirm or expand the results presented in this study.