Bibliometric Analysis Method Research Articles

Analisis Bibliometric: Pengaruh Covid-19 terhadap Kepatuhan Wajib Pajak dan Penerimaan Pajak

The purpose of this research is to find out about taxpayer compliance during the Covid-19 pandemic and how Covid-19 influences tax revenues in Indonesia. This research is a literature study using the bibliometric analysis method to analyze 200 articles related to tax revenue during the Covid-19 pandemic, which are then compiled with metadata using the Mendeley application, and the VOSviewer application is used to visualize publication data in research. Articles were obtained from the Google Scholar database accessed via Publish or Perish in the 2019-2023 range with defining the keywords 'Covid-19' and 'Tax'. The results of the study show that the research classification regarding tax revenue during the Covid-19 pandemic is divided into 4 specific words with topics centered on tax incentives, the Covid-19 pandemic, Covid-19 and taxpayer compliance. The Covid-19 pandemic that hit Indonesia has had an impact on the people's economy so the people's ability to carry out their tax obligations has also decreased. Therefore, this research was conducted to find out how influential Covid-19 was on taxpayer compliance and tax revenue in Indonesia. Then what policies should be made to overcome the impact of the pandemic and the methods used to increase tax compliance.Keywords: Covid-19; Insentif pajak; Kepatuhan wajib pajak

Research on Carbon Emission Structure and Model in Low-Carbon Rural Areas: Bibliometric Analysis

As the energy crisis and environmental problems are exacerbated, rural carbon emissions have gradually attracted increasing attention. Meanwhile, rural areas have the important function of ecological carbon sequestration, so the research field of carbon emissions has gradually expanded from urban to rural areas in recent years. To systematically sort out the research progress regarding low-carbon rural areas, a total of 583 papers published during 2013–2023 were acquired through the bibliometric analysis method from the “professional field of science of building technology” in the core database of Web of Science. Then, the research stage, author cooperation, institutional cooperation, national distribution, and keyword co-occurrence of “low-carbon rural areas” were analyzed via data visualization analysis software VOSviewer, and the current hot issues, such as carbon emission calculation list and elements, carbon emission measurement method/model, and energy saving and emission reduction paths, were further summarized and reviewed. The statistical analysis results show that: (1) in most of the current research on rural carbon emissions, geographical characteristics and rural carbon emissions have been rarely analyzed; (2) there is a lack of interdisciplinary research, e.g., less cooperation with geographic information or other disciplines; (3) the differences and characteristics of rural carbon emission factors in different economies and regions have rarely been analyzed. Based on the analysis, this research pointed out that future research can be comprehensively carried out in formulating rural carbon emission inventory, establishing a multi-scale and multi-regional statistical method and so on. This research also provides a comprehensive analysis and summary of the existing research on the structure and model of carbon emissions in low-carbon rural areas and also presents the problems that need to be paid attention to in the future research, pointing out the research direction for relevant scholars.

Review of research on option pricing: a bibliometric analysis

PurposeOption pricing theory enables computation of the price of an option using different variables associated with the underlying security and options contract. The purpose of this study is to assess research trends that emerged in the field of option pricing. This study reviews existing literature of the option pricing domain, both qualitatively and quantitatively, and identifies potential themes for future research.Design/methodology/approachThis study adopts bibliometric analysis method to explore literature published in the option pricing domain. As part of bibliometric analysis, this study considers both descriptive and network analysis to assess publication trends. For descriptive analysis, the “bibliometrix” package proposed by Aria and Cuccurullo (2017) is used and for network analysis, VOS viewer (Van Eck and Waltman, 2017) and Gephi (Bastian et al., 2009) are used.FindingsThis study identifies research trends, top researchers, articles, journals and contributions from institutions and countries in the option pricing domain. It identifies four clusters that show different directions and also focuses on past studies on the same subject. It explores research gaps by performing an in-depth analysis of existing literature on option pricing and suggests the way forward for research in this area.Originality/valueTo the best of the authors’ knowledge, no previous studies have attempted to analyze the literature published in the option pricing domain. This study fulfils this research gap by conducting a comprehensive analysis of studies in the option pricing area. This study identifies quality research work published in the domain, research trends, contribution by most relevant researchers, contributions across geographies and institutions and the connections among these aspects. This study also identifies important themes and provides directions for future research.

Understanding the Sino-Foreign Cooperative Education in China: A Bibliometric Approach

Sino-Foreign Cooperative Education (SFCE) is a form of international education with Chinese characteristics and it is an integral part of the Chinese education system. The aim of the research was to examine how the SFCE developed from 1995 to 2022. For this purpose, the method of bibliometric analysis was used in this study. This systematic literature review examined 537 articles published in CSSCI, CSCD, and PKU databases. The literature was analyzed with regards to the distribution of publications by year, author, institution/organization and journal. Additionally, visual maps were created with analyses of coauthor, co-words and thematic clusters from COOC and VOSviewer. The results show that SFCE has become a compelling issue. However, the publications in the national academic community were small. The most prolific authors were found to be Lin Jinhui, Guo Qiang, and Liu Mengjin. It was also found that the Xiamen University Educational Institute was the most productive institution and China Adult Education was the top journal in SFCE research. As a result of the bibliometric analysis, there is little cooperation between scientists and institutions in the field of SFCE. According to the co-words and thematic cluster analysis, five main clusters were formed. In the future, in-depth research on vocational education, Sino-Foreign Cooperative universities and countermeasures under the epidemic will become the new trend. A mixed research approach should be more adopted in the research methodology, and the research perspective from different interest subjects should be expanded in the future.

A bibliometric analysis of research on giftedness and mathematics

The current study aimed to (i) creates a bibliometric map of studies conducted on giftedness and mathematics and covered in the Scopus database and (ii) provide a holistic examination of these studies. Analyses included 1088 studies published between 1917 and 2022. We used the VOS viewer for social network visualisations. Using the bibliometric analysis method, we examined the studies regarding the most productive journals, country of origin, citations, and keywords. We found that the number of studies has increased within the last two decades. The outcomes of this research will benefit researchers who study the subject by holistically showing the field.

MAIN METHODS OF STUDYING HYBRID CONFLICTS (USING THE BIBLIOMETRIC DATA OF THE SCOPUS SYSTEM)

In this article, the main focus is on the disclosure of the main methods of researching hybrid conflicts, in particular on the example of bibliometric data of the Scopus system using the quantitative and qualitative method of research – content analysis. In modern scientific discourse, the term “hybrid conflict” is considered as contradictions between state and non-state, as well as terrorist groups, unfortunately, therefore, the challenges facing Ukraine have not received a thorough scientific study. To verify our statements, we used the method of bibliometric analysis using the Scopus system, indicating the insufficiency of in-depth research on the essence and features of hybrid conflicts in the scientific literature. The analysis shows a significant number of documents, which emphasizes the relevance of the topic. The paper analyzes the frequency of use of the term "hybrid conflicts" using content analysis and highlighting its features. The authors also point out the lack of a well-established definition and reflection of the term in international legal documents, which allows taking into account the aspects of modernization in understanding and researching this topic.

Research trends on development of energy efficiency and renewable energy in households: A bibliometric analysis

Households are responsible for more than one-third of global energy consumption and exert a significant environmental impact. Therefore, energy efficiency and renewable energy issues have been a top theme in the literature, with numerous studies examining different facets of residential power consumption, green energy transition, decarbonization, and energy conservation. Despite extensive attention, these research trends and frontiers remain largely uncharacterized and poorly understood. This study aims to provide clear insights into the evolution and latest trends of household energy efficiency and renewable energy studies, reveal significant contributing countries, institutions, and authors of published papers, as well as directions of international collaboration. The method of bibliometric analysis with two supporting instruments (the SciVal platform and Scopus “Analyze search results” tool) was used to investigate an array of 3,761 research items on renewable energy and 4,474 items on energy efficiency in homes formed from the Scopus database. The studied period includes papers published during 1978–2023. The systematic review indicated that the United States, the United Kingdom, and China are primarily contributing countries with strong international collaboration in this field. The top journals include Energy Policy, Energy Efficiency, Energies, and Sustainability, while highly cited researchers investigate environmental, economic, and social effects and management mechanisms for introducing innovative energy-efficient and renewable energy technologies in households like smart meters and grids or the Internet of Things. The research frontier might encompass emerging and pioneering studies on home decarbonization strategies, behavioral interventions, energy saving, prosumerism, and optimization of energy consumption. AcknowledgmentThe paper is prepared within the framework of the research project “Formation of economic mechanisms to increase energy efficiency and provide sustainable development of renewable energy in Ukraine’s households” (No. 0122U001233), funded by the National Research Foundation of Ukraine.

Prefabricated Construction Risks: A Holistic Exploration through Advanced Bibliometric Tool and Content Analysis

Prefabricated construction (PC) offers advantages to the architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) industry such as quality production, fast project completion, low waste output, high environmental sensitivity, and high security. Although PC has several advantages, knowledge gaps persist, necessitating a comprehensive bibliometric study. This research adopts a holistic bibliometric approach, combining qualitative (systematic literature review) and quantitative (bibliometric analysis) methods to assess the current state of prefabricated construction risks (PCRs) research and identify the literature trends. Unlike previous PCRs studies, our research capitalizes on the quantitative analysis capabilities of the Bibliometrix R-tool. We introduce innovative measures, such as the h-index, thematic mapping, and trend topic analysis, to deepen the understanding of the PCRs research landscape. Moreover, this study explores the intellectual structure of PCR research through keyword analysis, cluster analysis, and thematic evaluation, providing valuable insights into scientific studies, collaborations, and knowledge dissemination. In our study, following a systematic literature review to understand the existing knowledge, the R-studio Bibliometrix package is used to map the field, identify gaps in the field, and analyze the trends. This study involves a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of 150 articles in the field of PCRs, with data obtained from the Web of Science spanning from 2000 to 2023. The findings from the analyses reveal that the studies were divided into four different clusters: management, programming, logistics, and supply chain. Additionally, themes such as the integration of PC with Building Information Management (BIM), barriers, and stakeholders were also explored. The analyses indicate a growing awareness of PCRs, particularly in specific areas such as management, performance, and supply chain. This study stands out for its unique methods, analytical approach, and the use of specialized software. It provides valuable insights and suggestions for future studies.

Bibliometric analysis of equity in transportation

This paper aims to map the research landscape in equity and justice in transport and mobility, identifying key publications, authors, institutions, and interdisciplinary connections to inform future research and policy development. A systematic search of scientific articles on equity and justice in transport and mobility was conducted in the Web of Science, resulting in 759 selected articles that were analyzed using bibliometric and network analysis methods. The analysis reveals a growing trend in scientific production since 2013, with the Journal of Transport Geography, Transport Research Part A: Policy and Practice, and the Journal of Transport Policy being the most prominent journals. The most influential authors and institutions are identified, along with the most cited works. Keyword usage trends and thematic analysis show a shift in focus from environmental equity to urban transport, congestion, and accessibility. Cluster analyses highlight focal points and themes, such as accessibility, mobility, social aspects, transport and spatial equity, environmental justice, transport planning, active transport, and methodological evaluations. Co-citation networks reveal three major clusters with differing research focuses: Lukas K. & Martens K.; Litman T. and Currie, G., and Scwanen T. and Cresswell, T. The findings contribute to a better understanding of the existing knowledge in equity and justice in transport and mobility, enabling researchers and policymakers to identify areas requiring further exploration. Additionally, the paper fosters interdisciplinary connections and sets priorities for future research and policy development.

The Trends in Educational Management Research and Its Implications to Higher Education: A Bibliometric Analysis

A research in management of a higher education field has a significant benefit in optimizing the quality of education. The aims of this research are to explain the trends in publication research on management of higher education and its implication to the next developmental researches. This research uses bibliometric analysis method with the data from the most frequently accessed index, Google Scholar database. The Data are collected from the available publications in Google scholar by searching the keywords on management, educational management, and management of higher education through the titles, the abstracts, as well as the keywords using the publish and perish software. The finding from the research mapping indicates that researchers tend to team up collectively in their institution. The majority of management researches in higher education is still dominated by researchers who adopt the function of educational management as the scientific sources in developing the management of higher education. The researchers recommend conducting a number of joint researches between institutions and cross countries to enrich scientific integration and propose some considerations to the policy makers for setting up a more efficient and comprehensive management policy of the higher education.

Tren Penelitian Arsitektur Nusantara: Sebuah Tinjauan Literatur dengan Pendekatan Analisis Bibliometrik

The discourse on "nusantara" architecture has been echoing since 1999. The topic of this research tried to separate itself from ethnographic studies, vernacular architecture, and traditional architecture. This research wanted to build studies on local architectural understanding theoretically to its current application practices and projections of its existence in the future. This study aimed to analyze the trend in "nusantara" architecture research objectively that has been rolling for 24 years by using a bibliometric analysis method using big data provided by Lens, then visualized them using Lens analysis data, Microsoft Excel 35 version 2212 software, and VOSviewer software. This study's results indicated that the research topics on "nusantara" Architecture are not many and varied and have not formed many publication networks.

公共安全视角下城市韧性治理研究的科学知识图谱

At present, the world's urban development is facing many security challenges, and how to improve the level of urban resilience through resilient governance is the research trend to cope with urban disaster risks. Based on bibliometric analysis methods, this paper analyzes the knowledge graph of journal papers with the theme of “Urban Resilience Governance” from 2010 to 2023 using the Chinese CSSCI database and the English WOS database as the literature sources. The analysis found that: (1) The number of Chinese and English publications increased steadily and slowly in the early stage, and the number of publications soared after a certain year, and relevant research is still growing. (2) Foreign research results on urban resilience have been very rich, and there are many introductions and imitations in China. (3) Domestic and foreign research initially paid more attention to urban planning and design, and in terms of specific disaster types, the West paid more attention to climate disasters, while China paid more attention to social security incidents. (4) In terms of urban resilience governance, there is a lot of research on government-led collaborative governance in China, while foreign countries focus on the use of various social and individual capitals. Finally, the research, analysis and governance of cities as complex giant systems is a major trend in current research.

Indonesia-ASEAN Partnership to Counter-Terrorism in Indonesia

Terrorism is an extraordinary crime whose impact is very detrimental to all humans who are victims of this crime. Indonesia, as a member country of the Association of Southeast Asia Nations (ASEAN), is one of the countries that have received several terrorist attacks, such as the Bali Bombing I in 2002, the JW Marriot Bombing in 2003, the Bali II Bombing in 2005, the JW Marriot and Ritz Carlton Bombings in 2005 and 2009, and lately the terrorist attack that happened in Surabaya in 2018. This article aims to examine and analyze the cooperation between ASEAN and Indonesia and the mutual benefits and challenges of Indonesia-ASEAN cooperation from time to time. Furthermore, the study also examines the challenges and opportunities ahead from both sides and explores new strategies to overcome the challenges ahead and find ways to adapt to the terrorist modus operandi, which is constantly evolving from time to time to maintain stability in ASEAN. This study used the theory of international organizations and international regimes alongside bibliometric analysis methods with VOSviewer software as the theory and tool to analyze the topic.

Analisis Bibliometrik terhadap Guru Matematika Indonesia Berbasis VOS Viewer

This study aims to determine the research trends of Indonesian Mathematics Teachers using bibliometric analysis methods. The data in this study were obtained through Google Scholar from 2013-2023 with the keywords Indonesian math teachers. Researchers analyzed 1000 original articles from 2013-2023. Researchers utilize the use of Publish or Perish software and VOS Viewer to analyze data

An Integrative Review of Fear of Childbirth

This study aimed to provide knowledge for midwives to deepen their understanding of their clients when working closely with women during the perinatal period through an integrative review of ‘fear of childbirth’, and to clarify the research topics to be addressed in the future. Methods: This study used an integrative review (IR) method in addition to bibliometric analysis methods to classify and analyse the studies. Review questions (RQ) included 1. ‘what is the status of research efforts (number of papers, location, etc.) on “fear of childbirth”?’, 2. ‘what are the screening methods and prevalence of “fear of childbirth”?’, and 3. ‘what can be learned from the findings of these studies?’Findings: RQ1: The number of papers published gradually increased after 1981 and has been increasing since 2000. Studies conducted in Scandinavia accounted for more than half of the total studies. Conversely, only five studies were conducted in Japan. RQ2: The Wijma Delivery Experience Questionnaire is a screening scale for fear of childbirth developed in Sweden, which has been translated and utilised in multiple languages. In meta-analyses worldwide, the prevalence of fear of childbirth has been reported to range from 3.7% to 43%. RQ3: Fear of childbirth leaves a negative impression of past childbirth experiences on women’s psychological well-being and subsequently leads to post-traumatic stress disorder. Intervention studies have shown that prenatal education can help couples overcome their fear of childbirth. However, the effectiveness of intervention studies that have examined these psychological aspects has not yet been clarified.Conclusion: The prevalence of fear of childbirth varies considerably, possibly owing to cultural differences. Research on fear of childbirth has reported negative effects on the postpartum period and on subsequent pregnancy and childbirth. Practising women-centred care may help prevent this fear.

Service Quality in Maritime Businesses: Bibliometric View

Service quality is crucial in the maritime sector, as it is in all sectors. Service quality research in maritime businesses continues due to technological developments, changing environment and human profile. The study aims to current a holistic perspective to research evaluating service quality in maritime businesses with visual mapping and bibliometric analysis method. Therefore, 122 article were identified in the Web of Science database. It was analyses with the VOSviewer program. It was determined that scientists from 41 countries, especially China, were study. It is possible to say that the number of research carried out in 2022 represents approximately 20% of the total scientific production. This indicates that production will continue to increase.

A literature review of sports tourism research: knowledge graph analysis based on CiteSpace visualization

ABSTRACT The integration of sports and tourism has produced many research results, but the emergence of new disciplines has also brought about confusion in academic context. Using bibliometric analysis method, this paper analyzes the knowledge graph of 379 articles on ‘sports tourism’ collected from 2013 to 2021. It is found that the research hotspot of sports tourism mainly focuses on the concept of sports tourism, the theory of sports tourism, the case study of sports tourism, and the scale of sports tourism industry. From the branch evolution path analysis, it is found that sports tourism research mainly focuses on tourism nostalgia research, sports tourism risk perception research, sports tourism event development, sports tourism sustainable development and so on. Finally, the future research trend is prospected reasonably.

Analisis Bibliometrik Terhadap kemampuan Pemahaman Konsep Matematis

The purpose of this bibliometric analysis is to see opportunities and developments in research trends related to the ability to understand mathematical concepts. This research uses bibliometric analysis method. The data in this study were obtained through Google from 2018 – 2023 with the keyword ability to understand mathematical concepts. Researchers analyzed 1000 original articles from 2018 - 2023. This study used PoP and VOSviewers software to analyze the data. Based on the findings and results and discussion, it was found that the highest number of scientific publications on the Google Scholar website from 2018-2023 occurred in 2019. The research results based on overlay visualization and density visualization in 2018-2023 focused on mathematical concept variables, meaning that many studies have been conducted by other researchers.

Visual analysis of global air pollution impact research: a bibliometric review (1996-2022).

The impact of air pollution is one of the hotspots attracting continuous scholarly attention, but the comprehensive statistical and visual analysis reviews are few. Employing the method of bibliometric analysis, this paper took the relevant literature from 1996 to April 2022 on the Web of Science as the research object. Through the methods of keyword co-occurrence analysis and burst analysis, the spatiotemporal evolution trend, cooperation network, outstanding scholars, knowledge base, and research focus of air pollution impact research are visually presented. Via constructing a common word matrix of high-frequency words, clustering analysis is used to aggregate high-frequency keywords into 24 clusters. By the strategic coordinate analysis method, the relationships within and between clusters were revealed. The main findings include (1) research on the impact of air pollution mainly focusing on human health; (2) the six keywords with the highest centrality are California, hydrocarbons, dioxide, generation, Asia, and diesel; (3) these 11 clusters may be developed into future research hotspots: particulate matter, nitrogen oxides, mortality, ozone, pollution, air quality, asthma, children, epidemiology, aerosols, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons; and (4) seven topics are research hot: daily mortality, long-term exposure, coronary heart disease, concentration, North China plain, traffic-related air pollution, and air pollution.

Research on the Frontier and Prospect of Service Robots in the Tourism and Hospitality Industry Based on International Core Journals: A Review.

This paper used the mixed research method of bibliometric and content analysis to study 284 studies on service robots in the tourism and hospitality industry collected from the Web of Science database. Results show that research in this field started late, and that the COVID-19 pandemic has promoted the rapid growth of the number of research papers. The International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management has so far published the most number of papers. Numerous scholars from universities in different regions of the world have made significant contributions to the research of service robots, and academic collaborations are relatively common, but there are only very few high-yield authors. Empirical research has been widely favored by researchers, wherein online questionnaire and experimental methods have been frequently used. Multidisciplinary theories have also been cited in related articles, especially on the applications of psychological theories. The research fronts cover four branches focusing on service robots, consumers, human employees, and service environment, with all four parts largely overlapping in content. Finally, the paper discusses prospects for the future research agenda of service robots in the tourism and hospitality industry.