Significant evidence suggests that reversible oxidation of methionine residues provides a mechanism capable of scavenging reactive species, thus creating a cycle with catalytic efficiency to counteract or mitigate deleterious effects of ROS on other functionally important amino acid residues. Because of the absence of MSRs in the blood plasma, oxidation of methionines in extracellular proteins is effectively irreversible and, therefore, the ability of methionines to serve as interceptors of oxidant molecules without impairment of the structure and function of plasma proteins is still debatable. This review presents data on the oxidative modification of both intracellular and extracellular proteins that differ drastically in their spatial structures and functions indicating that the proteins contain antioxidant methionines/the oxidation of which does not affect (or has a minor effect) on their functional properties. The functional consequences of methionine oxidation in proteins have been mainly identified from studies in vitro and, to a very limited extent, in vivo. Hence, much of the functioning of plasma proteins constantly subjected to oxidative stress remains unclear and requires further research to understand the evolutionary role of methionine oxidation in proteins for the maintenance of homeostasis and risk factors affecting the development of ROS-related pathologies. Data presented in this review contribute to increased evidence of antioxidant role of surface-exposed methionines and can be useful for understanding a possible mechanism that supports or impairs structure-function relationships of proteins subjected to oxidative stress.