Abstract To reveal the effects of surface roughness on the structure and intensity of tornadic flow, we conducted numerical simulations, in which the horizontal density and height of obstacles were controlled independently. Simulation with a low external swirl ratio produced a tornado-like vortex with a narrow core radius. For this low-swirl vortex, when the horizontal density of obstacles was varied while the obstacle height was maintained, the lowest value of maximum tangential wind speed was achieved at a moderate horizontal density; a greater horizontal density led to an increase in the maximum tangential wind speed. By contrast, an increase in obstacle height always resulted in a lower maximum tangential wind speed. The mechanisms underlying such results were considered from the viewpoint of angular momentum depletion. Tall and moderately densely distributed obstacles generated a large amount of depleted angular momentum flux, which thickened the low angular momentum layer inside the corner flow region and the core region of the vortices. As a result, the maximum tangential wind speed decreased in association with the decrease in the radial gradient of angular momentum. Additional simulations were then run with a higher external swirl ratio, which resulted in vortices with a wider core radius. Even the roughness distribution with the highest and moderately dense obstacles did not notably reduce the intensity of the higher-swirl vortex, while the flow structure changed in larger scale. The results of this study suggest that urban roughness with a moderate density of tall buildings may weaken low swirl, thin tornadoes but does not preclude high swirl, wide tornadoes, at least through vortex-scale processes. Significance Statement In this study, we investigate the frictional effects of surface roughness on the intensity and the structure of tornado-like vortices in vortex-scale processes from computational fluid simulations that directly resolve the roughness obstacles. We show that the influence of roughness is maximized when tall obstacles are distributed at a moderate density, such as in urban terrain. This is considered to be because the intensity of the tornado-like vortices is dominated by the angular momentum stratification inside the central region of the vortices, which is strongly influenced by the surface flow at a depth of a similar length scale. This study indicates that small-scale topography, which is not always fully resolved in meteorological models, has a nonnegligible influence on tornado intensity.
Read full abstract