The workability of both gap-graded and continuously-graded concretes of various mixture proportions has been measured concurrently by the slump of a standard cone and by a Vebe consistometer. The results are compared for both concretes on the basis of equal maximum size of coarse aggregate, water-cement ratio, and aggregate-cement ratio. The comparison has shown the relative ease of placing gap-graded concrete to attain uniform compaction. Based on test data, a comparative study of the efficacy of slump test versus Vebe time as a measure of workability has been made. The slump test is not fully indicative of the workability for stiffer mixtures with slump less than one inch (2.54 cm) which should be normally used for obtaining economical high-strength concrete. It further indicates that the Vebe consistometer should be used, instead, in all stiff mixtures.
Read full abstract