The stratigraphic principle of superposition assumes that sediments at surface are youngest. And yet, patches of older preserved landscapes continue to be identified in the regions formerly covered by the Laurentide Ice Sheet. Two gravel pits, at the edge of the western Hudson Bay Lowland near the geographic centre of the North American Ice Sheet Complex, reveal additional patches where older glacial and nonglacial sediment is preserved. These sites expose 1–4 m of a darker, highly overconsolidated, clayier till, and 0–2 m of a lighter, less consolidated, sandier till over glaciofluvial and post-glacial gravels and sands; the waning stages of deposition occurred at 214 ± 22 ka (1σ minimum age model quartz grain optical age estimates, n = 2). This was during the latter end of the cool Marine Isotope Stage (MIS) 7-d (within 1σ range) or near the end of MIS-8 (within 2σ range). Next followed a warmer period similar to, or warmer than, present day with higher precipitation; inferred from pollen and macrofossils deposited in nonglacial low-energy floodplain or pond sediments. Our study highlights the need to accurately date Quaternary sediments, given that the shallowest nonglacial sediments at both gravel pits were deposited during an old (MIS 7) interglacial; there is likely no record of the youngest interglacial (MIS 5). Preservation of older sediment also means that in Quaternary stratigraphy, disjoint regional nonglacial “organic marker beds” should not automatically be considered correlative. Identification of similar “old” patches, together with till stratigraphy and composition, is essential to accurately model glacial sediment transport over time.