Map Of Auditory Space Research Articles

Chapter 24 The development of topographically-aligned maps of visual and auditory space in the superior colliculus

The role of the superior colliculus in attending and orienting to sensory stimuli is facilitated by the presence within this midbrain nucleus of superimposed maps of different sensory modalities. We have studied the steps involved in the development of topographically-aligned maps of visual and auditory space in the ferret superior colliculus. Injections of fluorescent beads into the superficial layers showed that the projection from the contralateral retina displays topographic order on the day of birth (PO). Recordings made from these layers at the time of eye opening, approximately 1 month later, revealed the presence of an adult-like map of visual space. In contrast, the auditory space map in the deeper layers emerged gradually over a much longer period of postnatal life. In adult ferrets in which one eye had been deviated laterally just before eye opening, the auditory spatial tuning of single units recorded in the contralateral superior colliculus was shifted by a corresponding amount, so that the registration of the visual and auditory maps was maintained. Chronic application of the NMDA-receptor antagonist MK801 disrupted the normal development of the auditory space map, but had no effect on the visual map in either juvenile or adult animals, or on the auditory map once it had matured. These findings indicate that visual cues may play an instructive role, possibly via a Hebbian mechanism of synaptic plasticity, in the development of appropriately tuned auditory responses, thereby ensuring that the neural representations of both modalities share the same coordinates. Changes observed in the auditory representation following partial lesions of the superficial layers at PO suggest that these layers may provide the source of the visual signals responsible for experience-induced plasticity in auditory spatial tuning.

Binaural tuning of auditory units in the forebrain archistriatal gaze fields of the barn owl: local organization but no space map

We identified a region in the archistriatum of the barn owl forebrain that contains neurons sensitive to auditory stimuli. Nearly all of these neurons are tuned for binaural localization cues. The archistriatum is known to be the primary source of motor-related output from the avian forebrain and, in barn owls, contributes to the control of gaze, much like the frontal eye fields in monkeys. The auditory region is located in the medial portion of the archistriatum, at the level of the anterior commissure, and is within the region of the archistriatum from which head saccades can be elicited by electrical microstimulation (see preceding companion article, Knudsen et al., 1995). Free-field measurements revealed that auditory sites have large, spatial receptive fields. However, within these large receptive fields, responses are tuned sharply for sound source location. Dichotic measurements showed that auditory sites are tuned broadly for frequency and that the majority are tuned to particular values of interaural time differences and interaural level differences, the principal cues used by barn owls for sound localization. The tuning of sites to these binaural cues is essentially independent of sound level. The auditory properties of units in the medial archistriatum are similar to those of units in the optic tectum, a structure that also contributes to gaze control. Unlike the optic tectum, however, the auditory region of the archistriatum does not contain a single, continuous auditory map of space. Instead, it is organized into dorsoventral clusters of sites with similar binaural (spatial) tuning. The different representations of auditory space in closely related structures in the forebrain (archistriatum) and midbrain (optic tectum) probably reflect the fact that the forebrain contributes to a wide variety of sensorimotor tasks more complicated than gaze control.

Effects of eye position on auditory localization and neural representation of space in superior colliculus of cats.

The maps of visual and auditory space within the superior colliculus are in approximate register both with each other and with the underlying motor maps associated with orienting responses. The fact that eyes and ears can move independently poses a problem for the sensorimotor organization of these two modalities. By monitoring eye and pinna positions in alert, head-fixed cats, we showed that the accuracy of saccadic eye movements to auditory targets was little affected by eye eccentricity (range +/- 15 deg) at the onset of the sound. A possible neural basis for this behavioral compensation was suggested by recordings from superior colliculus neurons. The preferred sound directions of some neurons in the deep layers of this midbrain nucleus exhibited a shift with the direction of gaze, while in others the response throughout the auditory receptive field was either increased or decreased, suggesting that changes in eye position alter the gain of the auditory response.

Effects of eye position on saccadic eye movements and on the neuronal responses to auditory and visual stimuli in cat superior colliculus.

Many neurons in the deeper layers of the superior colliculus (SC) respond to multiple sensory inputs--visual, auditory, and somatic--as well as provide signals essential for saccadic eye movements to targets in different modalities. When the eyes and pinnae are in primary position, the neural map of auditory space is in rough topographic alignment with the map of visual space, and if the auditory map is based solely on headpinna coordinates, any changes in eye position in the orbit will cause misalignment of the maps. We investigated the effects of eye position on the response of sound-sensitive neurons in the SC of cats because previous work on cats and on monkeys had suggested the possibility of species differences in the representation of auditory signals in the SC. We also investigated the effects of eye position on the accuracy of saccades to auditory, visual, and bimodal stimuli. All studies were conducted in alert, trained cats with the head restrained in a fixed position. Neuronal and behavioral responses were studied during periods when the eyes were steadily directed to different positions relative to the position of the sound. Cats showed partial compensation for eye position in making saccades, regardless of the modality of the target, and they showed similar patterns of error in saccades to auditory and visual targets. These behavioral data are consistent with coding the location of visual and auditory targets in the same coordinate system. In the vast majority of intermediate-layer neurons, eye position significantly affected the number of spikes evoked by sound stimuli. For most of these neurons, changes in eye position produced significant shifts in the speaker location producing maximal response. In some neurons, eye position significantly facilitated the magnitude of neuronal response evoked by sounds from a variety of speaker locations. Because few pinna movements could be detected, in is unlikely that these changes in neuronal response could be due to changes in the position of the pinnae. Our results indicate that the deep layers of the SC contain an eye-centered representation of sound location. Because eye position did not affect the percentage of neurons exhibiting multimodal integration, visual and auditory maps appear to remain integrated in the SC even when the eyes are directed eccentrically.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

NMDA-receptor antagonists disrupt the formation of the auditory space map in the mammalian superior colliculus

In the ferret (Mustela putorius) the map of auditory space in the deeper layers of the superior colliculus (SC) matures over a period of several postnatal weeks, a process known to be guided by both visual and auditory experience. The auditory responses are initially very broadly tuned, and gradually become more selective for specific sound locations that coincide with the visual receptive fields recorded in the same region of the SC. To investigate the possible involvement of NMDA-type glutamate receptors in the postnatal development of this auditory representation, we have reared ferrets in which 400 microns thick sheets of the slow-release polymer Elvax, containing the NMDA receptor antagonists MK801 or APV, were placed on the dorsal surface of the SC. The Elvax was implanted on postnatal day (P) 25-27, just before the onset of hearing, and removed 5-6 weeks later, just prior to recording from the SC on around P61-70. In vitro measurements with Elvax containing 3H-MK801 revealed that the amount of drug released declined sharply over the first 10 d and then stabilized at a fairly constant rate for the following 5 weeks. These in vitro data were found to parallel the in vivo release of MK801 from implanted Elvax slices. Diffusion of MK801 from the implant was measured and significant levels were found within 800 microns of the SC surface, suggesting that the action of MK801 was restricted to the superficial and intermediate layers of the nucleus. Extracellular recordings were made from visual and auditory units in the SC in response to free-field stimulation. The visual responses of units recorded in the superficial layers appeared to be unaffected by either of the drug treatments, and formed a normal, adult-like map of visual azimuth along the rostrocaudal axis of the SC in all animals. Most of the auditory single-unit responses recorded at this age in normal, unoperated controls were spatially tuned and topographically organized, although the map of sound azimuth was less precise than that in adult ferrets. Data from age-matched control animals that had been reared with drug-free Elvax implants were not statistically different from the unoperated juvenile ferrets. However, in animals reared with APV or MK801 Elvax implants, there was an increase in the relative numbers of auditory units that were ambiguously tuned to two or more locations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Visual movement and pattern are important for the development of a map of auditory space in the guinea pig superior colliculus

Previous data have indicated that, if guinea pigs are deprived of all visual information during a crucial period early in development (26-30 days after birth), the map of auditory space in the superior colliculus (SC) is completely disrupted. In the experiments reported here, multi-unit auditory receptive fields were recorded in the SC of two groups of anaesthetised guinea pigs that had been exposed to different forms of visual deprivation. One group was reared in a movement-free environment (strobe-reared) and the other group was reared in a pattern-free environment (their eyes covered with light-diffusing masks). Both groups experienced visual restriction during the crucial period for auditory space map development. In both experimental groups, the multi-unit auditory receptive fields were broad and all spatial tuning parameter values were significantly greater than the equivalent values from a control group of normal animals. In the pattern- and motion-deprived groups, a significant correlation existed between the rostro-caudal position of the recording electrode in the SC and the peak response angle of the receptive field, thus showing a degree of topographic organisation of the auditory receptive fields in the SC. However, the topographic order was less precise than that displayed by the control group of animals. These results indicate that, during development, both visual pattern and movement are important for the refinement of the SC auditory space map in the guinea pig.

Site of auditory plasticity in the brain stem (VLVp) of the owl revealed by early monaural occlusion.

1. The optic tectum of the barn owl contains a physiological map of interaural level difference (ILD) that underlies, in part, its map of auditory space. Monaural occlusion shifts the range of ILDs experienced by an animal and alters the correspondence of ILDs with source locations. Chronic monaural occlusion during development induces an adaptive shift in the tectal ILD map that compensates for the effects of the earplug. The data presented in this study indicate that one site of plasticity underlying this adaptive adjustment is in the posterior division of the ventral nucleus of the lateral lemniscus (VLVp), the first site of ILD comparison in the auditory pathway. 2. Single and multiple unit sites were recorded in the optic tecta and VLVps of ketamine-anesthetized owls. The owls were raised from 4 wk of age with one ear occluded with an earplug. Auditory testing, using digitally synthesized dichotic stimuli, was carried out 8-16 wk later with the earplug removed. The adaptive adjustment in ILD coding in each bird was quantified as the shift from normal ILD tuning measured in the optic tectum. Evidence of adaptive adjustment in the VLVp was based on statistical differences between the VLVp's ipsilateral and contralateral to the occluded ear in the sensitivity of units to excitatory-ear and inhibitory-ear stimulation. 3. The balance of excitatory to inhibitory influences on VLVp units was shifted in the adaptive direction in six out of eight owls. In three of these owls, adaptive differences in inhibition, but not in excitation, were found. For this group of owls, the patterns of response properties across the two VLVps can only be accounted for by plasticity in the VLVp. For the other three owls, the possibility that the difference between the two VLVps resulted from damage to one of the VLVps could not be eliminated, and for one of these, plasticity at a more peripheral site (in the cochlea or cochlear nucleus) could also explain the data. In the remaining two owls, there was no evidence of adaptive adjustment in the VLVp despite large adaptive adjustments in the optic tectum. 4. The adjustment of ILD coding in the VLVp was always substantially smaller than expected based on the adjustment of ILD tuning in the optic tectum measured in the same animals. This indicates the involvement of at least one additional site of adaptive plasticity in the auditory pathway above the level of the VLVp.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Responses of neurons in the ferret superior colliculus to the spatial location of tonal stimuli

Using multi-unit recordings, we compared the azimuthal spatial selectivity of auditory neurons in the deep layers of the ferret superior colliculus (SC) to broadband and tonal stimuli. Responses to noise were tuned at different sound levels to a single location, which varied topographically along the rostrocaudal axis of the nucleus to form a map of sound azimuth. Frequency response profiles tended to be multi-peaked, so the spatial tuning was examined at two or more frequencies in each case. Some of the azimuthal response profiles obtained with tonal stimuli were bilobed, as expected from the spatially ambiguous cues available at individual frequencies, although the rest were tuned to a single region of space. The preferred sound directions usually varied with the frequency used, and the range of auditory best positions at each recording site was significantly greater with tones than with noise. Comparison with the acoustical properties of the auditory periphery suggested that the near-threshold positional selectivity of many of the tonal responses may be determined by the monaural directionality of the outer ear. When the sound level was raised by 20 dB so that both ears were stimulated at all speaker locations, the range of tonal best positions obtained at each frequency increased and some of the units responded best to pure tones located in the ipsilateral hemifield. The lack of topographic order in the distribution of tonal spatial selectivity along the rostrocaudal axis of the SC indicates the need for a broadband input, incorporating the spectral localization cues provided by the outer ear, in the construction of a neural map of auditory space.

Multisensory interaction: Influence of spatial visual cues on auditory detection

Recent physiological and psychological studies suggest spatiotopic maps of auditory space often build up by groups of multisensory neurons. At this neuronal level stimulus representations of different modalities seem to be transformed into a common coordinate system. A multimodal stimulus may produce enhancement, depression, or no interaction effect on the cell activity, depending on its certain spatiotemporal combination. In several experiments the influence of visual cues on auditory perception was examined. The results indicate a dependence on spatial and temporal parameters. [Work supported by DFG.]

Representation of multiple sound sources in the owl's auditory space map

The barn owl's inferior colliculus contains a retina-like map of space on which a sound generates a focus of activity whose position corresponds to the location of the sound source. When there is more than one source of sound, the sound waves sum and may generate spurious binaural cues that degrade the auditory image. We investigated the signal conditions under which neurons in the owl's auditory space map are able to resolve two simultaneously active sound sources. We recorded from space map neurons responding to sounds from a pair of speakers separated in azimuth by 45 degrees and mounted on a rotatable arm. Stimuli consisted of a sum of sinusoids or pseudorandom noise bursts emitted simultaneously and at equal overall levels. The characteristics of the sounds in each speaker were varied, and the neuron's response was plotted as a function of the speaker pair's position. When the speakers emitted different sets of summed sinusoids, the cells responded to each speaker separately; that is, the cells were able to resolve two separate targets. However, when the speakers emitted identical summed sinusoids generating binaural cues that were identical to those of a single phantom source between the two speakers, the neurons responded when the speakers were on either side of their receptive fields. By manipulating the amplitude at which each speaker emitted the various frequencies, we could control the position, number, and size of the phantom sources detected by the cell. The cells also resolved two separate sources when they emitted noise bursts that were statistically independent or temporally reversed versions of one another. Since the overall spectra of such waveforms are identical, we suggest that the space map relies on differences between noise bursts that exist over brief time spans.

Plasticity in the superior collicular auditory space map of adult guinea‐pigs

In the guinea-pig the development and maintenance of the superior collicular (SC) auditory space map requires both auditory and visual experience. This paper reports the results of experiments in which adult animals (of different ages) were dark-reared for 4 weeks to define the extent of the period of susceptibility to visual deprivation of the SC auditory map. Dark-rearing for 4 weeks from 100, 150 or 200 days after birth caused degradation of spatial tuning and topography of multi-unit auditory responses in the SC. In contrast, animals reared in the dark from 250 days after birth showed spatially tuned auditory responses similar to those seen in normal animals. These data suggest that the SC auditory space map in the adult guinea-pig remains susceptible to visual deprivation up to 200 days after birth.

Post‐crucial period effects of visual experience and deprivation on the guinea‐pig superior collicular map of auditory space

There were two primary aims of this study. First, to observe if the map of auditory space in the superior colliculus (SC) of the guinea-pig could recover after periods of normal visual experience following visual deprivation during the crucial period. Second, to determine whether any degradation of the space map was observed when the animal was visually deprived for different lengths of time after the crucial period. Animals deprived of visual experience during the crucial period and then allowed normal experience did show a limited ability to construct a SC auditory space map. Whereas visual deprivation following normal auditory and visual experience during the crucial period caused a profound degradation, of both spatial tuning and topography, of auditory receptive fields in the SC. Additional data indicate that the SC auditory space map remains vulnerable to visual deprivation until at least 100 days after birth.

The effects of monocular enucleation on the representation of auditory space in the superior colliculus of the guinea-pig

Multi-unit responses, to free-field auditory stimuli, in the superior colliculus were investigated in guinea-pigs following earlier removal of one eye. Enucleation resulted in disruption of the normal tuning parameter values and of the topographical precision of auditory responses in the SC both ipsilateral and contralateral to the enucleated eye. These data demonstrate that monocular enucleation prevents the normal development of the superior collicular auditory space map.

Adaptive plasticity of the auditory space map in the optic tectum of adult and baby barn owls in response to external ear modification

1. This study demonstrates the influence of experience on the establishment and maintenance of the auditory map of space in the optic tectum of the barn owl. Auditory experience was altered either by preventing the structures of the external ears (the facial ruff and preaural flaps) from appearing in baby barn owls (baby ruff-cut owls) or by removing these structures in adults (adult ruff-cut owls). These structures shape the binaural cues used for localizing sounds in both the horizontal and vertical dimensions. 2. The acoustic effects of removing the external ear structures were measured using probe tube microphones placed in the ear canals. In both baby and adult ruff-cut owls, the spatial pattern of binaural localization cues was dramatically different from normal: interaural level difference (ILD) changed with azimuth instead of with elevation, the rate of change of ILD across space was decreased relative to normal, and the rate of change of interaural time difference (ITD) across frontal space was increased relative to normal. 3. The neurophysiological representations of ITD and ILD in the optic tectum were measured before and > or = 3 mo after ruff removal in adults and beginning at 4.5 months of age in baby ruff-cut owls. Multiunit tuning to ITD and to ILD was measured using dichotic stimulation in ketamine-anesthetized owls. The tectal maps of ITD and ILD were reconstructed using visual receptive field location as a marker for recording site location in the optic tectum. 4. Adjustment of the tectal map of ITD to the altered spatial pattern of acoustic ITD was essentially complete in adults as well as in baby ruff-cut owls. This adjustment changed the magnification of ITD across the tectum, with resultant changes in ITD tuning at individual tectal sites of up to approximately 25 microseconds (approximately 5% of the physiological range) relative to normal values. 5. Adaptation of the tectal ILD map to the ruff-cut spatial pattern of acoustic ILD was substantial but clearly incomplete in both adult and baby ruff-cut owls. Although changes of up to approximately 15 dB (approximately 47% of the physiological range) relative to normal tuning were observed at certain tectal sites, the topography of the ILD map was always intermediate between normal and that predicted by the ruff-cut spatial pattern of acoustic ILD.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Topographic representation of auditory space in the superior colliculus of adult ferrets after monaural deafening in infancy

1. We have investigated the role of monaural cues provided by the outer ear in the construction of a map of auditory space in the superior colliculus. Single-unit recordings were made from the superior colliculus of adult ferrets that were deprived of binaural inputs by surgically ablating the ipsilateral cochlea on postnatal day 21 or 24. 2. The spatial response properties of auditory units in the deeper layers of this nucleus were studied using white-noise bursts presented under free-field conditions in an anechoic chamber. The thresholds of the units recorded in the monaural ferrets were not significantly different from those recorded in the superior colliculus of normal adult ferrets. In both groups the unit thresholds varied by 30-50 dB in each region of the superior colliculus. 3. In normal and monaural ferrets the elevation tuning tended to be sharper than the azimuth tuning. At sound levels of approximately 10 dB above threshold the auditory units recorded in both groups of animals were tuned to a specific region of space that was restricted in azimuth and elevation. The spatial location at which the maximum response was obtained (auditory best position) varied topographically in azimuth along the rostrocaudal axis of the nucleus and in elevation along the mediolateral axis. 4. The azimuthal distribution of best positions associated with each recording location in the superior colliculus of the monaural ferrets and the alignment between this dimension of the auditory map and that of the visual map in the overlying superficial layers were no different from those found at corresponding near-threshold sound levels in normal ferrets. 5. Elevation spatial selectivity was examined in a smaller sample of units. Although elevation best positions shifted downward from the medial to the lateral side of the nucleus in both normal and monaural ferrets, we found that the topography of the auditory representation and its alignment with the visual representation were statistically different in the two groups of animals. 6. Increasing the sound level does not affect the representation of auditory space in normal ferrets. However, when the stimulus level presented to monoaural ferrets was increased, the receptive fields either expanded so that the responses were no longer tuned to any particular region of space, or the responses remained tuned but exhibited a marked shift in the value of the best position.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Experience-dependent plasticity in the inferior colliculus: a site for visual calibration of the neural representation of auditory space in the barn owl

The optic tectum (homolog of the superior colliculus) contains mutually aligned neural maps of auditory and visual space. During development, the organization of the auditory map is guided by spatial information provided by vision: barn owls raised wearing prismatic spectacles, which optically shift the visual field and the visual map in the optic tectum, develop an auditory map that is shifted by an approximately equivalent amount, such that alignment between the two maps is preserved (Knudsen and Brainard, 1991). In this study we investigated whether this shift in the auditory map is intrinsic to the optic tectum or whether it reflects plasticity at an earlier stage in the auditory pathway. Owls were raised wearing prismatic spectacles that displaced the visual field by 23 degrees to the left or right. This manipulation alters the normal correspondence between locations in the visual field and interaural time difference (ITD), the primary cue for the azimuth of a sound source. In normal owls and in owls with at least 150 d of prism experience, extracellular unit recordings were used to assess the representations of ITD at anatomically and physiologically defined sites in the optic tectum and in the two prior stages of the auditory pathway, the external and central nuclei of the inferior colliculus (ICx and ICc). In the optic tectum of normal owls, the values of ITD to which units responded most strongly (best ITDs) varied systematically with the azimuths of unit visual receptive fields (VRFs). In the prism-reared owls, best ITDs were shifted from normal toward the values of ITD produced by sounds at the locations of the units' optically displaced VRFs. In the ICx of prism-reared owls, the representation of ITD also was shifted from normal, by an amount and in a direction that could completely account for the shift in ITD measured in the optic tectum. At some sites in the ICx, the shift in ITD tuning was apparent within the first 7-8 msec of the response; shifted tuning at such short latencies argues that the altered representation of ITD in the ICx reflects plasticity in the ascending auditory pathway, and is not the result of descending activity from higher auditory centers. In the ICc, which immediately precedes the ICx in the ascending pathway, the representation of ITD was normal. The results indicate that the visual instruction of auditory spatial tuning of neurons in the optic tectum reflects plasticity at the level of the ICx, the site where the auditory map of space is first synthesized.

The Wellcome Prize Lecture. A map of auditory space in the mammalian brain: neural computation and development

The experiments described in this review have demonstrated that the SC contains a two-dimensional map of auditory space, which is synthesized within the brain using a combination of monaural and binaural localization cues. There is also an adaptive fusion of auditory and visual space in this midbrain nucleus, providing for a common access to the motor pathways that control orientation behaviour. This necessitates a highly plastic relationship between the visual and auditory systems, both during postnatal development and in adult life. Because of the independent mobility of difference sense organs, gating mechanisms are incorporated into the auditory representation to provide up-to-date information about the spatial orientation of the eyes and ears. The SC therefore provides a valuable model system for studying a number of important issues in brain function, including the neural coding of sound location, the co-ordination of spatial information between different sensory systems, and the integration of sensory signals with motor outputs.

Bilateral inhibition generates neuronal responses tuned to interaural level differences in the auditory brainstem of the barn owl

I investigated the neural algorithms by which neurons gain selectivity for interaural level difference in the brainstem of the barn owl (Tyto alba). Differences in the timing and in the level of sounds at the ears are used by this owl to encode, respectively, azimuthal and vertical position of sound sources in space. These two cues are processed in two parallel neural pathways. Below the level of the inferior colliculus, all neurons in the pathway that processes level differences show responses to this cue that are monotonic, and thus not selective for a particular level difference. Only in the inferior colliculus, which contains a map of auditory space, are neurons sharply tuned to specific interaural level differences. How are these response properties generated from those of the nuclei that provide input to the inferior colliculus? I show that the posterior subdivision of the nucleus ventralis lemnisci lateralis (VLVp) projects bilaterally to the lateral shell of the central nucleus of the inferior colliculus, the input stage to the map of auditory space. Both these nuclei are part of the pathway that processes interaural level differences. Manipulations of the responses in VLVp affected the responses to level differences in the inferior colliculus; responses to time differences were unaffected. By systematically increasing or decreasing neural activity in VLVp, I show that the VLVp on each side provides inhibition to the colliculus at large level differences. This results in a peaked response that is tuned to level differences in the inferior colliculus. Some cells in the lateral shell of the inferior colliculus appear to receive direct GABAergic inhibition from VLVp. I suggest that this circuitry and the algorithms it supports are the neural substrates that allow the barn owl to exploit level differences for computation of sound source elevation.

Changes induced in the representation of auditory space in the superior colliculus by rearing ferrets with binocular eyelid suture.

There have been conflicting reports concerning the importance of visual experience in the development of auditory localization mechanisms. We have examined the representation of auditory space in the superior colliculus of adult ferrets that were visually deprived by binocular eyelid suture from postnatal days 25-28, prior to natural eye opening, until the time of recording. This procedure attenuated the transmission of light by a factor of a least 20-25 and blurred the image so that, as long as the eyelids were still fused, the responses of visual units in the superficial layers of the superior colliculus were labile and very poorly tuned. After the eyelids were opened, the representation of the visual field in these layers appeared to be normal. Acoustically responsive units were, as usual, almost exclusively restricted to the deeper layers of the superior colliculus. However, unlike normal animals, where responses occurring only at stimulus onset predominate, most of these units exhibited sustained or multi-peaked discharge patterns. The degree of spatial tuning of individual units recorded from the normal and deprived groups of animals was not significantly different in either azimuth or elevation. Normally orientated maps of both sound azimuth and elevation were also found in the visually deprived ferrets. However, abnormalities were present in the topography and precision of these representations and consequently in their alignment with the overlying visual map. In particular, an increase was observed in the proportion of auditory units with spatially ambiguous receptive fields, in which the maximum response occurred at two distinct locations. These results indicate that patterned visual experience is not required for establishing at least a crude map of auditory space in the superior colliculus, but suggest that it may play a role in refining this representation during development.

Erratum for Wagner, Sound-Localization Deficits Induced by Lesions in the Barn Owl's Auditory Space Map

In the process of Printing the article “Sound-Localization Deficits Induced by Lesions in the Barn Owl's Auditory Space Map,” by Hermann Wagner [J Neurosci13:371–386 (1993)] the scale bar belonging to the photographs of Fig. 4 (p. 376) was lost. The scale bar belonging to Fig. 3 (p. 375) is valid for Figure 4,b, d, f,andh,as well. The publisher regrets the error.