Women Talking Business:Domestic Settings for Economic Discourses in The Squatter and the Don Mike Lemon (bio) María Amparo Ruiz de Burton's The Squatter and the Don (1885) has proven a polarizing text for twenty-first century readers. Ruiz de Burton calls attention to illegal land seizures, frustrated economic development, and the subsuming of Californio land and culture within an Anglo-American nationalist paradigm. However, she simultaneously condemns mid-nineteenth-century racial hierarchies and relies on those very structures to argue the Alamar family's position within white American society.1 Additionally, the author's use of multiple popular nineteenth-century genres may distance readers. Literary scholars have identified within The Squatter and the Don historical romance, sentimentalism and melodrama, and realism, among many others.2 The novel's multiple genres warrant a complex reading approach; overlapping generic frameworks also suggest Ruiz de Burton's sophisticated rhetorical strategies for presenting the novel's pressing political and economic questions. To this point, however, scholars have neglected how Ruiz de Burton constructs physical and social spaces to facilitate conversations regarding business. While Marissa K. Lopez has written an excellent analysis on railroads in the author's [End Page 359] work, the use of domestic spaces as transgressive sites also deserves sustained attention.3 In analyzing how The Squatter and the Don uses physically constructed space, we can see that where Ruiz de Burton locates economic discourse allows the author to highlight exclusionary tactics that remove women from conversations about American economic affairs. The novel contains two economic narratives that were contemporary concerns. Furthermore, Ruiz de Burton demonstrate the plotlines' interconnected nature by using romantic storylines to entangle her principal families—the Alamares, Darrells, and Mechlins. The first plot functions as a composite account of illegal settlements on Mexican American lands. It details how William Darrell and other Anglo-American squatters seize and despoil the Alamar rancho. As the courts settle the contested land-claims, squatters shoot the family's cattle, depriving them of capital. Ruiz de Burton attempts to resolve this narrative through the marriage of Mercedes Alamar and Clarence Darrell; moreover, Clarence purchases the rancho to provide the Alamares capital.4 The second narrative centers on the proposed Texas Pacific Railroad that would have connected San Diego to the Mexican Gulf. Because they want to deter competition, the Central Pacific Railroad's so-called Big Four—men who fundamentally shaped California's economic future—frustrate the Texas Pacific's completion.5 The railroad's collapse necessitates Clarence, Mercedes, and the extended Alamar family to relocate to San Francisco. Even though male characters largely preclude women from business discussions, I argue that Ruiz de Burton intentionally has the novel's two matriarchs—Mrs. Mary Darrell and Doña Josefa Alamar—use their homes to invite themselves or become invited into these economic narratives. After framing domestic space historically, I track the author's gendered emphasis through three locations: the Darrells' homes, the Alamar daughters' placement in elite Eastern [End Page 360] venues, and Doña Josefa's San Francisco home. Because the story opens with Mrs. Mary Darrell admonishing her husband while they sit in their shared sitting room, the author emphasizes female voices in domestic spaces. During this and other moments within the land-claim plot, Mrs. Darrell actively drives the narrative action, instructing her affluent son Clarence to buy the land rather than pre-empt—that is, to prematurely settle on disputed Mexican land claims.6 Her climatic entrance into the room that the family later calls the "colony"—a domestic space appropriated by her husband—signals her reinsertion within the land-ownership plotline. That her presence discomforts the male audience demonstrates the author's ironic stance on excluding women from business matters. In the middle of the novel, the author curiously emphasizes the need for the female voice through its absence. During the wedding party chapters, Ruiz de Burton relocates two Alamar daughters on an extended visit to the eastern American seaboard. Even though these chapters do not overtly involve either economic plotline, they signal how gardens and trains actively remove the younger women from talking business. Ruiz de Burton closes the main narrative by returning her...
Read full abstract