In a controlled trial of three alternative methods for local treatment of severe burns, a significantly lower incidence of bacterial colonisation was recorded in burns treated with local chemoprophylactic agents than in those treated by exposure in warm, dry air. Of the local chemoprophylactic methods, compresses of 0.5% silver-nitrate solution gave better protection in general against bacterial colonisation than 11.2% mafenide ('Sulfamylon') acetate cream with exposure of burns, but infection with Pseudomonas œruginosa occurred about as often in burns treated with silver-nitrate compresses as in those treated with mafenide cream. Miscellaneous coliform bacilli colonised similar proportions of burns in the three treatment groups. The mean of the highest respiration-rates per patient was significantly higher in patients treated by exposure in warm, dry air than in those treated with silver-nitrate compresses. The mean respiration-rate of patients treated with mafenide was slightly higher than that of patients in the silver-nitrate group, and slightly lower than that of patients in the group treated by exposure in warm, dry air; the mean temperature of patients treated with mafenide was slightly lower than that of the patients treated by exposure, but not apparently different from that of patients treated with silver-nitrate compresses. Mortality in each group was slightly, but not significantly, lower than that expected on a probability chart based on findings in the unit during the years 1965-70. Most of the patients treated with mafenide did not complete the course of treatment because of pain; acidosis occurred only in one patient treated with this agent. Side-effects of silver-nitrate treatment were noted in some patients, including low serum-sodium, acidosis, and diarrhœa. A trial of 1% silver-sulphadiazine cream on smaller burns showed that daily reapplication of the cream gave significantly better protection than reapplication every three or four days; the prophylactic effects of this treatment were similar, whether burns were covered with dressings or exposed.
Read full abstract