Duplex stainless steels (DSS) in wire and arc additive manufacturing (WAAM) have attracted significant research attention due to their mechanical properties and corrosion resistance. This study uses conventional and nanomechanical testing methods to compare the mechanical and microstructural behaviors at macroscopic and microscopic length scales. Macro hardness (HV10) testing yielded 259 and 249 in low and high heat input (HI) samples, respectively, while ferrite content averaged 52.7 and 48.5%. However, these results fail to provide conclusive insight into the potential influence of microstructural variations at the macroscopic level, likely due to the composite response of the material. To overcome this limitation, the mechanical response of the DSS samples is assessed at the grain level via high throughput nanoindentation mapping with image processing to track the location of each indent. This approach enabled differentiating the indents landing on ferrite and austenite phases as well as those landing on the interfaces. The results showed that the austenite phase had higher hardness (4.30 and 4.35 GPa) than the ferrite phase (3.89 GPa and 4.03 GPa) for high and low HI samples, respectively. The observed differences in hardness between the phases can be attributed to higher nitrogen content in the austenitic phase.