Low-speed Flight Research Articles

Lift enhancement via leading edge vortex delay in flapping flight utilizing kinematic modifications

Flapping-winged micro aerial vehicles (MAVs) are an innovative approach to indoor flight, useful for reconnaissance. However, challenges remain in improving the maneuverability of these drones in low-speed flight, specifically using wing kinematics for different flight profiles. This work focuses on the plunge motion of the SD7003 airfoil in forward flight. Unsteady simulations are carried out at a Reynolds number of 10,000 in Ansys Fluent upon validation against experimental, theoretical, and numerical results from literature. Modification of the kinematics is performed by skewing the sinusoidal curve that dictates the effective angle of attack of the airfoil, leading to what is termed “peak-shifted” (PS) kinematics. The skewness of the curve is varied systematically to delay the peak of plunge velocity during the downstroke. Due to this, the leading edge vortex formation and shedding were also found to be delayed, with stronger vortex cores causing a surge in lift force. Results indicate that with the PS kinematics, mean lift increased by 4.5% and mean drag reduced by 7.9%, at the cost of an increase in power requirement of 42.9% compared to the baseline kinematics. Since lift augmentation and drag reduction are obtained with no change in plunge amplitude or frequency, this opens up opportunities in tail-less MAV design to use PS kinematics in short intervals for maneuvers or flight controls, including roll, pitch, and yaw.

Three-dimensional CFD model and aerodynamic analysis of dragonfly’s corrugated wing during gliding

Abstract The aerodynamic performance of micro air vehicles (MAVs) in low-speed flight would be improved by mimicking the dragonfly’s wing with corrugated airfoil. Research on two-dimensional corrugated airfoils has revealed that the local vortex in the corrugated structure increases the flow speed and the lift-to-drag ratio in low Reynolds numbers. However, studies seldom focus on the effects of three-dimensional corrugated structures on aerodynamics. In this paper, the mechanism of high aerodynamic performance in a dragonfly’s wing is studied considering a three-dimensional corrugated structure. The high-fidelity dragonfly forewing model is established through reverse engineering. The computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation is performed for the gliding corrugated wing with angles of attack (AOA) of 0°-24° under three Reynolds numbers. The flow characteristics of corrugated wings and the aerodynamic gain from it are analyzed through the simulated streamlines and pressure contours, as well as the comparison between the corrugated wing, flat wing, and flat plate. The results show that the aerodynamic characteristics of corrugated wings are generally superior. Although the introduction of the corrugated structure increases some drag, it brings a higher lift and lift-to-drag ratio than the flat wings.

Control allocation optimization for an over-actuated tandem tiltwing eVTOL aircraft considering aerodynamic interactions

This paper describes control allocation strategies for a tandem tiltwing electric vertical take-off and landing (eVTOL) aircraft with distributed propulsion. The control mappings are constructed as local surrogate models that relate the control effectors to the aircraft's aeropropulsive forces and moments across the full flight envelope, including interactional aerodynamics effects. Control allocation optimization problems are formulated based on force and moment commands for specific flight conditions. Specifically, a nonlinear programming formulation based on nonlinear control mapping is proposed for control allocation optimization, and the problem is solved using a sparse nonlinear optimizer. The solutions obtained from different formulations such as the minimization of force and moment residuals and the minimization of control effort are investigated. Furthermore, these solutions are compared with the solutions obtained using linear control mapping-based formulations. Results presented for the cases of forward flight, low speed flight & hover, and flight in the transition corridor suggest that considering aerodynamic interactions while formulating and solving the control allocation problem is necessary for higher levels of accuracy compared to linear approaches. One-propeller-out scenarios and moment and force generation cases are also investigated. Finally, control allocation for steady and accelerated operation in the transition corridor is discussed. The contribution of the methods and results in the paper is a nonlinear control allocation methodology for the entire flight envelope of an over-actuated tandem tiltwing eVTOL aircraft.

Stratospheric airship trajectory planning in wind field using deep reinforcement learning

Stratospheric airships, with their long endurance, high flight altitude, and large payload capacity, show promise in earth observation and mobile internet applications. However, challenges arise due to their low flight speed, limited maneuverability and energy constraints when planning trajectories in dynamic wind fields. This paper proposes a deep reinforcement learning-based method for trajectory planning of stratospheric airships. The model considers the motion characteristics of stratospheric airships and environmental factors like wind fields and solar radiation. The soft actor-critic (SAC) algorithm is utilized to assess the effectiveness of the method in various scenarios. A comparison between time-optimized and energy-optimized trajectories reveals that time-optimized trajectories are smoother with a higher speed, while energy-optimized trajectories can save up to 10% energy by utilizing wind fields and solar energy absorption. Overall, the deep reinforcement learning approach proves effective in trajectory planning for stratospheric airships in deterministic and dynamic wind fields, offering valuable insights for flight design and optimization.

Analysis, optimization, and testing of a tilt-body aircraft

This paper proposes a new multidisciplinary design optimization framework for tilt-bodies to obtain the optimal combination of geometry and powertrain, achieving both long endurance and low transition power consumption at a 5 kg takeoff weight. A low-fidelity vortex lattice method is used to derive the aerodynamic coefficients. The tandem wings are trimmed using an optimization-based method, considering the effect of distributed propulsion on the trim solution through aero-propulsive interaction at low flight speed. Detailed powertrain parameters are fitted with fewer design variables to calculate power consumption. By analyzing the unique constraints of tilt-bodies, the optimization problem is established as a simultaneous analysis and design architecture, and solved with different numbers of rotors. The impact of the relative geometric relationship between the front and rear wings on aerodynamic performance and constraints is analyzed. Results demonstrate the full angle-of-attack flight capability of tilt-bodies. The optimal design can save nearly 1000 W in transition, with a pure cruise endurance of over 1 hour, which is competitive among other configurations. With an empty weight of only 2 kg, a portion of the battery can be allocated to a heavier payload. High-fidelity computational fluid dynamics corrects the errors of the vortex lattice method on non-lifting components, including the fuselage, nacelles, and landing gear. Finally, the feasibility of the optimal design and the accuracy of the framework are validated by wind tunnel tests and in-flight drag measurements on a test platform.

An integrated three-dimensional aeromechanical analysis for the prediction of stresses on modern coaxial rotors

This paper presents the first application of an Integrated Three-Dimensional aeromechanical analysis—defined as the coupled solution of three-dimensional finite element-based structural dynamics with a three-dimensional Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes-based fluid dynamics—to predict the stresses on a modern coaxial rotor. The coupling was carried out with the University of Maryland’s structural dynamic solver X3D and the U.S. Army’s CREATETM–AV Helios suite of fluid dynamic solvers. A modern four-bladed hingeless coaxial rotor model—inspired by the gross dimensions of the Sikorsky S-97 Raider but generic and open source otherwise—is developed as a demonstration test case. The new structural solver is driven by parallel and scalable solvers and advanced high performance computing. It is enabled by high-order three-dimensional brick finite elements unified with multibody dynamics, integrated aerodynamics, and a special 3D-to-1D fluid-structure interfaces refines the power of delta-coupling procedure while retaining the advantages of existing CFD mesh motion schemes. The analysis predicts the three-dimensional stresses on the rotor blades and hub, together with the deformations, airloads, and wake, in an integrated manner. Two flight conditions are studied: a low-speed flight at 37 knots and a high-speed flight at 150 knots. Interesting three-dimensional unsteady stress patterns are revealed all across the blade but particularly inboard of 50% rotor radius—patterns that change from flight to flight and have remained invisible until now—since they could neither be predicted nor measured in flight. The maximum axial stresses exhibited 3/rev variation at low speed, and 2/rev variation at high speed flight. The lower rotor carried higher oscillatory stress burden at low speed, whereas both the rotors shared the same stress burden at high speed flight. The key conclusion is that such analysis is now indeed possible, and the stress patterns they reveal provide deeper insights into the dynamics of advanced rotors, and these might provide a path toward mitigating them in the future.

Using your head - cranial steering in pterosaurs.

The vast majority of pterosaurs are characterized by relatively large, elongate heads that are often adorned with large, elaborate crests. Projecting out in front of the body, these large heads and any crests must have had an aerodynamic effect. The working hypothesis of the present study is that these oversized heads were used to control the left-right motions of the body during flight. Using digital models of eight non-pterodactyloids ("rhamphorhyncoids") and ten pterodactyloids, the turning moments associated with the head + neck show a close and consistent correspondence with the rotational inertia of the whole body about a vertical axis in both groups, supporting the idea of a functional relationship. Turning moments come from calculating the lateral area of the head (plus any crests) and determining the associated lift (aerodynamic force) as a function of flight speed, with flight speeds being based on body mass. Rotational inertias were calculated from the three-dimensional mass distribution of the axial body, the limbs, and the flight membranes. The close correlation between turning moment and rotational inertia was used to revise the life restorations of two pterosaurs and to infer relatively lower flight speeds in another two.

Numerical investigation of aerodynamic interactions for the coaxial rotor system in low-speed forward flight

This study is conducted to investigate the aerodynamic characteristics of a coaxial rotor in low-speed forward flight using a high-fidelity computational fluid dynamics (CFD) solver. Numerical simulations are performed on the coaxial rotor and its isolated upper and lower rotors at two small advance ratios, 0.12 and 0.24. Interaction events in the flowfield, especially blade-vortex-interaction (BVI), are studied in detail. As the forward speed increases, the airload distributions become concentrated on the front part of the disk. Fluctuations in the loading indicate self-BVIs within each rotor, and blade-crossover events and rotor-to-rotor BVIs between the coaxial upper and lower rotors. Principal BVI events are identified in the well-captured wake structures by the 8th-order TENO reconstruction scheme. Self-BVIs on all rotors reduce in strength as the forward speed increases, while rotor-to-rotor BVIs on the coaxial lower rotor increase in strength with the increasing forward speed. In the coaxial configuration, the wake of the upper rotor is induced to move backwards and downwards due to the exertion of the lower rotor wake. The wake of the coaxial lower rotor features the most complex flow nature among all rotors. At both advance ratios, the coaxial lower rotor experiences a parallel rotor-to-rotor BVI, causing highly impulsive loading fluctuations along the blade span.

Computational Validation and Assessment of Large Amplitude Transverse Gust Physics

Rotary-wing vehicles, in particular smaller, lighter unmanned and urban air vehicles in urban and shipboard settings, will operate in low-speed flight conditions that are dominated by strong transient aerodynamics. Understanding the physics of these transient aerodynamics, specifically large amplitude transverse gusts and the resulting vehicle response, is crucial to the successful development and certification of safe air vehicles that operate in these environments. A high-fidelity computational study, including validation with experiments, explores sharp-edged or step transverse gusts where the gust velocity induces nonlinear behavior caused by flow separation. The behavior of the maximum lift and leading edge vortex behavior with the gust ratio is presented. Gust responses are observed to depart from Küssner’s theory when the leading edge vortex first forms as a distinct feature and breaks away from the wing, resulting in flow nonlinearities. Traditional linear indicial admittance techniques are shown to no longer be valid to predict gust responses when the gust velocity approaches the vehicle flight speed.

Rapid Design Method of Heavy-Loaded Propeller for Distributed Electric Propulsion Aircraft

On Distributed Electric Propulsion (DEP) aircraft, the deployment of numerous high-lift propellers with small diameters on the wing’s leading edge significantly enhances lift during low-speed flight. The increase in the number of propellers leads to a decrease in diameter, which increases the disc loading. In this paper, a rapid design method applicable to heavy-loaded propellers is developed and does not require iterative calculations compared to traditional heavy-loaded propeller design methods, enabling rapid completion of the propeller design. The results of CFD computation show that the relative thrust error of the method proposed in this paper is within 5% for disc loading ranging from 600 Pa to 1400 Pa, features a high-accuracy design of propellers with required thrust, and high thrust coefficients are achieved within large advance ratio range.

Development and Application of Open Rotor Discrete Noise Prediction Program Using Time-Domain Methods

The aerodynamic noise of an open rotor is one of the critical challenges that must be considered in its design and application. FODNOPP, a program specifically programmed to predict the aerodynamic discrete noise of single- and counter-rotating open rotors (such as propellers, propfans, and rotorcraft rotors) at subsonic, transonic, and supersonic helical blade tip speeds, has recently been developed by the first author. This program is composed of four prediction codes, namely code a1, code a2, code b, and code c, each based on Farassat-derived formulations Formu 1-RTE, Formu 1A, Formu 1-Sph, and Formu 3, providing time-domain solutions to the Ffowcs Williams–Hawkings equation. Four verification examples for both propeller low-speed flight noise and counter-rotating propfan take-off noise are presented, along with an application case for transonic helical tip speed counter-rotating propfan cruise noise. The results demonstrate the accuracy of FODNOPP in calculating the noise for these verification cases. And in the counter-rotating propfan cruise noise case, the maximum harmonic sound pressure level of the rear propfan is 5.5 dB higher than that of the front propfan. FODNOPP can be referred to as a comprehensive design tool, and it offers valuable guidance for engineering design focused on rotor-related noise reduction.

Three-Dimensional Aeromechanical Analysis of Lift Offset Coaxial Rotors: A Helios Test Case

Three-dimensional (3-D) solid finite element analysis (FEA) is used to model and study coaxial helicopter rotors. The 3-D FEA is coupled with a lifting line aerodynamic model with free wake to capture rotor-rotor interactions. Two open-access models are developed: one is the Metaltail (a hingeless coaxial rotorcraft), and the other is the coaxial rotor built from articulated UH-60A-like rotors. The former is the main focus of this work and is developed as an example case for the U.S. Army/DoD rotorcraft simulation software CREATETM–AV Helios, while the latter is merely for a regression test. The analysis is performed on a low-speed transition flight for which qualitative data are available for the Sikorsky S-97 Raider aircraft for comparison. Predictions of performance, airloads, vibratory loads, and 3-D stresses are discussed. In the absence of available geometry or property data of the S-97, this study is primarily meant to serve as a capability demonstration of 3-D rotor structural dynamic modeling for such rotors.

Whirl Flutter Test of Swept-Tip Tiltrotor Blades

The first whirl flutter test of the Maryland Tiltrotor Rig (MTR) was recently completed in the Naval Surface Warfare Center Carderock Division (NSWCCD) 8- by 10-ft large subsonic wind tunnel. The MTR is a Froude-scaled, 4.75 ftdiameter, threebladed, semispan, floor-mounted, optionally powered, flutter rig. This paper focuses on the swept-tip blades developed for this test. The swept-tip begins at 80%R and sweeps aft 20° to alleviate whirl flutter. Whirl flutter testing was performed in four con gurations for both blade geometries. The frequency and damping of the wing beam and chord bending were collected at wind speeds up to 100 kt. This paper directly compares whirl utter results between the straight and swept-tip blades and demonstrates higher wing chord damping using swept-tip blades in freewheel conditions, even at lower flight speeds.

Computational Validation and Assessment of Large Amplitude Transverse Gust Physics

Rotary-wing vehicles, in particular smaller, lighter unmanned and urban air vehicles in urban and shipboard settings, will operate in low-speed flight conditions that are dominated by strong transient aerodynamics. Understanding the physics of these transient aerodynamics, specifically large amplitude transverse gusts and the resulting vehicle response, is crucial to the successful development and certification of safe air vehicles that operate in these environments. A high-fidelity computational study, including validation with experiments, explores sharp-edged or step transverse gusts where the gust velocity induces nonlinear behavior caused by flow separation. The behavior of the maximum lift and leading edge vortex behavior with the gust ratio is presented. Gust responses are observed to depart from Küssner's theory when the leading edge vortex first forms as a distinct feature and breaks away from the wing, resulting in flow nonlinearities. Traditional linear indicial admittance techniques are shown to no longer be valid to predict gust responses when the gust velocity approaches the vehicle flight speed.

Influence of Engine Dynamic Characteristics on Helicopter Handling Quality in Hover and Low-Speed Forward Flight

This study assesses the influence of engine dynamic characteristics on helicopter handling quality during hover and low-speed forward flight. First, we construct the helicopter–engine coupling model (HECM) based on the power-matching relationship between the engine and the rotor. The impact of the engine is evaluated by comparing HECM with a helicopter model without the engine. To assess the engine’s influence quantitatively, we consider torque response, height response, and collective–yaw coupling characteristics in ADS-33E-PRF handling quality criteria. The results reveal that the engine power output lag can deteriorate the helicopter’s torque and height response handling quality rate (HQR). After the increase in helicopter mass, the torque HQR caused by engine influence improved, and the altitude HQR further deteriorated. The engine dynamic characteristics can also reverse the yaw rate, decreasing collective–yaw coupling HQR. As the helicopter’s flight speed increased, the engine’s impact on the yaw rate increased by 41.8%. This study can provide valuable insight into the effects of engine dynamic characteristics on helicopter handling quality and offer a reference for the design of helicopter–engine coupling control laws.

MODEL OF THE FLAT FAIRING ANTENNA DIELECTRIC LAYER WITH AERODYNAMIC HEATING

To protect the antenna systems of modern aircraft, radio-transparent dielectric fairings are widely used. At low flight speeds, when designing and evaluating the characteristics of the fairing-antenna, it is assumed that the dielectric constant is a constant value and does not depend on the aircraft's flight speed. As the flight speed increases, as a result of aerodynamic heating of the fairing, its dielectric permeability changes, which leads to errors in the processing of received signals. Currently, to take into account the effect of dielectric coatings heating when designing antenna systems, the temperature of the fairing wall is averaged over its thickness. This method during maneuvering and at high flight speeds leads to large errors in determining the characteristics of the fairing antenna since the nature of the temperature distribution along the thickness of the fairing wall is not taken into account. A new approach to the analysis of dielectric layers with their uneven heating along the thickness is proposed. The obtained results make it possible to adjust the signal processing algorithms with analog and digital matrices, as a result of taking into account the emerging heat flows affecting the fairing of the aviation antenna, which leads to the improvement of the characteristics of the antenna systems.

Influence of flaps deflection angle on aerodynamic performance of aircraft

Flaps, as one of the lift-augmentation devices installed on aircraft, provide sufficient lift during takeoff and landing phases. By installing flaps on the wing, the wing area can be increased, and the wing curvature can be modified. by adjusting the position of the flaps, the aircrafts aerodynamic characteristics can be regulated. This article focuses on studying the impact of forces on trailing edge flaps during takeoff. As finding the appropriate angle of deflection is a crucial factor in improving flight efficiency, this article primarily investigates the influence of flap deflection angles on the aerodynamic forces acting on the aircraft during low-speed flight. The Flow Simulation module is utilized for the analysis of the flow field. The relation between lift and tilt angle of the flap is obtained from numerical simulations. Through the analysis, for the chosen type of flaps configuration, the optimal flap angle for takeoff is 45. This article may offer a reference for the design of flaps.

Powered Low-Speed Experimental Aerodynamic Investigation of an Over-Wing-Mounted Nacelle Configuration

Over-wing integration of ultrahigh bypass turbofan engines can be a solution for next-generation commercial transport aircraft since it eliminates the ground clearance issue and it has the potential to reduce ground noise due to acoustic shielding. Moreover, a unique characteristic of this installation type is the powered lift benefit at low-speed flight conditions. This paper aims to experimentally investigate the effect of the engine power setting on the low-speed aerodynamic performance of an over-wing-mounted nacelle configuration comprising a conventional tube-and-wing layout. Thus, low-speed wind tunnel tests were performed for a half-span powered scale model of the aforementioned configuration. The effect of the engine power setting on the wing lift and spanwise pressure distributions was investigated. The experiments were carried out for angles of attack varying from 0 to 6° and inlet mass flow ratios up to 2.4. The results were used to validate computational fluid dynamics simulations conducted for the same wind tunnel conditions. It has been shown that a significant powered lift benefit can be achieved for the studied configuration, without a penalty in the net propulsive force and that the lift increases linearly with the inlet mass flow ratio. Furthermore, it was observed that the engine power setting largely influences the pressure distributions along the wing, especially at the spanwise sections closer to the nacelle. The low-momentum zone created upstream of the engine at high power settings reduces the pressure at the wing’s upper surface, which is the main factor responsible for the increased lift. By taking advantage of such behavior, drag can potentially be reduced at takeoff and climb due to a lower flap setting required for the same lift.

The performance and application of sweep wing aircraft

With the development of science and technology, more and more civil and military aircraft have adopted swept-back wing shapes. this paper explores the relationship between the angle of swept-wing and the lift, drag and lift-drag ratio of the aircraft, and expounds it in combination with the actual swept-wing aircraft, such as Boeing737 and MIG-23 to find the best sweep angle of the aircraft in the appropriate range and analyze the effect of swept wing angle on flight speed. This paper studies and analyzes the data through literature retrieval and data processing and cites data models from many academic journals. The experimental data are mainly derived from computational fluid dynamics and wind tunnel simulation. This paper finds that a wider sweep angle can result in better aerodynamic performance, suited for supersonic flight, while a smaller sweep angle can result in a better lift-drag ratio, it is suitable for takeoff and landing of aircraft and low-speed flight attitude.

Hummingbirds use wing inertial effects to improve manoeuvrability.

Hummingbirds outperform other birds in terms of aerial agility at low flight speeds. To reveal the key mechanisms that enable such unparalleled agility, we reconstructed body and wing motion of hummingbird escape manoeuvres from high-speed videos; then, we performed computational fluid dynamics modelling and flight mechanics analysis, in which the time-dependent forces within each wingbeat were resolved. We found that the birds may use the inertia of their wings to achieve peak body rotational acceleration around wing reversal when the aerodynamic forces were small. The aerodynamic forces instead counteracted the reversed inertial forces at a different wingbeat phase, thereby stabilizing the body from inertial oscillations, or they could become dominant and provide additional rotational acceleration. Our results suggest such an inertial steering mechanism was present for all four hummingbird species considered, and it was used by the birds for both pitch-up and roll accelerations. The combined inertial steering and aerodynamic mechanisms made it possible for the hummingbirds to generate instantaneous body acceleration at any phase of a wingbeat, and this feature is probably the key to understanding the unique dexterity distinguishing hummingbirds from other small-size flyers that solely rely on aerodynamics for manoeuvering.