Elastin is an extracellular matrix material found in all vertebrates. Its reversible elasticity, robustness, and low stiffness are essential for the function of arteries, lungs, and skin. It is among the most resilient elastic materials known: During a human lifetime, arterial elastin undergoes in excess of 2 × 109 stretching/contracting cycles without replacement, and slow oxidative hardening has been identified as a limiting factor on human lifespan. For over 50 y, the mechanism of entropic recoil has been controversial. Herein, we report a combined NMR and thermomechanical study that establishes the hydrophobic effect as the primary driver of elastin function. Water ordering at the solvent:protein interface was observed as a function of stretch using double quantum 2H NMR, and the most extensive thermodynamic analysis performed to date was obtained by measuring elastin length and volume as a function of force and temperature in normal water, heavy water and with cosolvents. When stretched, elastin's heat capacity increases, water is ordered proportional to the degree of stretching, the internal energy decreases, and heat is released in excess of the work performed. These properties show that recoil in elastin under physiological conditions is primarily driven by the hydrophobic effect rather than by configurational entropy as is the case for rubber. Consistent with this conclusion are decreases in the thermodynamic signatures when cosolvents that alter the hydrophobic effect are introduced. We propose that hydrophobic effect-driven recoil, as opposed to a configurational entropy mechanism where hardening from crystallization can occur, is the origin of elastin's unusual resilience.