New Hibernia Review 7.1 (2003) 69-74 [Access article in PDF] Heroines or Victims? The Women of the Flight of the Earls Jerrold Casway [Figures] The Flight of the Earls in September, 1607, was a miscalculated strategem neither anticipated nor welcomed by Catholic Europe. No vindications can refute that the earls, intimidated by the course of their failing political circumstances, hoped their appearance on the Continent would elicit greater support from their alleged benefactors, Europe's Catholic monarchies. A neglected side of this event has been the roles of the women caught up in this intemperate exodus. 1 Drawing on contemporary accounts and participant lists, it can be deduced that "3 score soldiers," including the crew of a "French barque," 2 took about sixty-five to seventy people to the Continent. 3 Among the refugees who boarded the eighty-ton vessel at Lough Swilly, seventeen passengers were women. Four can be identified by name, three through marital ties, and ten by their service affiliations. "That foreign ship has three of our women, of the nobles of the soil of Banba, the gentle ladies from Erin for whose loss all sorrowed." [End Page 56] 4 Catherine, Countess O'Neill, daughter of Sir Hugh Magennis and sister to Sir Arthur Magennis, the first viscount of Iveagh, became Hugh O'Neill's fourth wife in 1598. By the time of the flight, Catherine had given birth to three sons: Sean (John), Brian (Bernard) and Con (Constantine). The second woman was Nuala O'Donnell, the sister of Hugh Roe O'Donnell, lord of Tyrconnell and aunt of Rory O'Donnell, earl of Tyrconnell. Eldest of the noble women, Nuala O'Donnell had formerly been married to her first cousin Nial Garve O'Donnell. After ten years of marriage, she left her husband in 1600 after he had made a separate peace with the English. Finally, there was Rosa O'Dogarty, daughter of Sir John O'Dogarty, lord of Inishowen, and sister to Sir Cahir O'Dogarty, who married Cathbar, the earl of Tyrconnell's brother. They had one child, Hugh, after three years of marriage. Among the other women identified by name is Caecilia O'Gallagher. She and her husband were the foster parents of Rory O'Donnell's son, Hugh. Caecilia served as the child's wet nurse and looked after the youngster until February, 1608, when he was given over to the Convent of the Dames Blanches in Louvain. Another nurse to the infant O'Donnell is known, Anna ny Madden, the wife of Dennis O'Kelly. There is no evidence, however, that she accompanied the earls abroad. 5 The other women can be identified by their spouses. They include a nurse, the wife of Tyrconnell's steward, Edward "Groom" MacDavid. 6 The other two affiliated women were the spouses of Sean O'Hagan, Tyrone's rent collector, and Art Oge O'Neill, Tyrone's nephew, the son of Sir Cormack MacBaron O'Neill. The remaining ten ladies are unnamed servants who attended the children and the three noble women. Catherine O'Neill had two "amas" [nurses] and three "criadas" [maidservants], Nuala O'Donnell had one "dama" [lady-in-waiting] and one criada, Rosa O'Dogarty had one criada and Tryconnell's infant son was attended to by the aforementioned Caecilia O'Gallagher and two criadas. 7 The class, status, and role of these women are made plain in the record. Four of the women were of noble rank and three came from affiliated client classes. All were northern native Irish, aligned by blood, marriage, and service to the Ulster lords. Of the women not in service, Nuala O'Donnell stood apart because [End Page 57] [Begin Page 59] her status was not based on marriage, children, or clientage. She was the only woman born to either of the two ruling northern families and was a decade older than the other noble ladies. It is also conceiveable that only Nuala had the opportunity to decide for herself whether to participate in the Flight of the Earls. Had the other women resisted or...
Read full abstract