Significant areas of prime farmland in the upper Coastal Plain of Virginia have been disturbed by heavy mineral sands (Ti/Zr-bearing ilmenite, rutile, zircon) mining over the past 15 years. Mine soils created by the deposition of tailings and slimes in dewatering pits exhibit physical and chemical properties that limit agricultural use due to abrupt textural changes, heavy compaction from grading and the inherently low pH and available P of the processed subsoils. In 2004, the Carraway-Winn Reclamation Research Farm (CWRRF) was developed with Iluka Resources Inc. in Dinwiddie County to evaluate reconstruction strategies for returning mined land to agricultural production. In 2004, row crop plots were established in a randomized complete block design with 4 replications of 4 treatments: 1) LBS-CT - lime-stabilized biosolids (78 dry Mg ha -1 ) with conventional tillage, 2) LBS-NT - lime-stabilized biosolids (78 dry Mg ha -1 ) with no tillage, 3) TS - 15 cm of topsoil replacement with lime+NPK, and 4) C - control (tailings+lime+NPK). All treatments were deep ripped to 90 cm following grading and limed and fertilized annually to optimal levels. Two additional study sites, managed similarly to the treatment plots, included a compacted (no ripping) area (COMP) and a nearby unmined prime farmland (Orangeburg series) field (UM). Between 2005 and 2008, the plots were managed with a corn-wheat/double crop soybean rotation. In 2009, the plots were managed with cotton and in 2010 with wheat/double crop soybeans. During the initial four year corn-wheat/double crop soybean rotation, the two LBS treatments produced significantly higher yields than the TS or C treatments. No significant differences were observed among treatments for the 2009 cotton yield; however, erratically distributed settlement depressions adversely affected crop growth and harvest and led to high variability within each treatment. Similarly, no significant differences were observed for the 2010 wheat and soybean yields in a low rainfall year. Overall, yields from all four treatments typically exceeded 5-year local county averages, but were 25 to 40% lower than yields from the local prime farmland soil under identical management. Relatively low COMP yields illustrated the need for initial deep ripping and periodic tillage to improve physical conditions of these mine soils.
Read full abstract