There are several mistakes in the recent paper about the theoretical studies of defect structure for Mn 2+ ion at the 12-fold tetrakaidecahedral K + site in KTaO 3 by calculating the spin Hamiltonian (SH) parameters, so the calculated defect structure (which is smaller than those obtained from the local density approximation (LDA) method, density functional theory in the generalized gradient approximation (GGA) and the dipole moment study (DMS)) is doubtful. Therefore, we restudy the defect structure in this paper by using the reasonable expressions and parameters. The present result is in agreement with those based on LDA, GGA and DMS methods and can be regarded as reasonable. It appears that the reliability of the defect structure of impurity center determined from the calculation of SH parameter depends strongly upon reasonableness of the used expressions and parameters.
Read full abstract