The recent revelation of the shipment of γ irradiation-inactivated Bacillus anthracis spore reference materials containing a small number of live spores (Department of Defense [DoD] Laboratory Review. DoD Launches Review of Lab Procedures Involving Anthrax. http://www.defense.gov/news/newsarticle.aspx?id=128939, May 29, 2015) has raised concerns about the safety and security of these materials and doubts on the validity of the protocols and procedures used to prepare these materials. Such inactivated spore materials have historically fulfilled critical needs: as positive controls in assays used to detect these pathogens in suspected samples (live agents cannot be shipped and used in field settings), and are also used in improvement of currently deployed detection methods or development of new methods/platforms for detection of these agents; in other words, to develop and validate detection assays, and for quality assurance activities such as proficiency testing. The committee for comprehensive review of DoD Laboratory procedures, processes, and protocols associated with inactivating B. anthracis spores has found inherent deficiencies in protocols in three phases in the production of inactive spores that could lead to nonsterile products: (1) radiation dosing, (2) viability testing, and (3) aseptic operations (contamination prevention). These deficiencies and other factors contributed to the establishment of protocols that do not completely or permanently sterilize these samples (http://archive.defense.gov/home/features/2015/0615_lab-stats/docs/Review-Committee-Report-Final.pdf, July 13, 2015). The review committee made a number of recommendations, including initiating studies to understand the science of irradiating spores and establishment of standardized protocols across the labs engaged in inactivated spore production. In addition, a clear understanding of the nature of the surviving spores would aid in understanding the phase(s) in which the failure occurred and fixing the problem. Here we consider a few hypotheses.
Read full abstract