154 Western American Literature The Role of Place in Literature. By Leonard Lutwack. (Syracuse, New York: Syracuse University Press, 1984. 274 pages, n.p.) In The Role of Place in Literature, Leonard Lutwack explores the con cept of literary place in European and American literature, focusing on the properties and uses of place as metaphor, place as pervasive symbol, and— of special interest to western literature scholars—place in the American landcape , especially the myths of El Dorado, the garden and the wilderness. A final chapter surveys placelessness in contemporary literature. Lutwack surveys his subject from so many perspectives and includes so much literature that his analysis of particular works or authors is often mis leading. For example, on the basis of his analysis of One of Ours, Lutwack concludes that Cather became disillusioned with America and found true devotion to the land among the French peasants, and that Claude would have returned to “operate his old family farm” had he not died in World War I (157)\ Still, as a work of literary analysis, The Role of Place in Literature is an important addition to literary criticism and of special interest to western litera ture scholars. Lutwack’s catalogue of literature and his demonstration of the pervasive influence of place, not only as “inhabitable space” but also as meta phor and myth, provides scholars with an impressive array of evidence of the tradition behind those works that focus especially on the land. Lutwack may be right in his assertion that the images of the Garden, El Dorado and the wilderness focus on the American place as a passageway, a means rather than an end (178). This image of movement rather than rootedness still informs our attitude towards the American West. In his chap ter entitled “National Literature,” Lutwack gives us a starting place for fur ther study to corroborate or refute the generalizations that he outlines in this important study. DIANE DUFYA QUANTIC Wichita State University Wilderness: The Way Ahead. Edited by Vance Martin and Mary Inglis. (Forres, Scotland: Findhorn Press, and Middleton, Wisconsin: Lorian Press, 1984. 319 pages, $10.50.) The Third World Wilderness Congress, held at Findhorn, Scotland in 1983, must have been filled with an unusual spirit of both portent and hope, and perhaps as well an unusual degree of fellow-feeling, for the proceedings, collected here, are remarkably and consistently cogent. There is a strong sense that what is being said here matters. Most of the essays speak from the heart, conveying the essential connectedness that may be the most important mean ing of wilderness. ...
Read full abstract