The concept of oligometastasis, which represents limited metastatic disease, has recently gained interest, accompanied by a more detailed classification. This study aims to investigate the relationship between the treatment course and prognosis in patients with a recurrence of esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC) after curative esophagectomy. 126 patients with ESCC recurrence after curative resection were enrolled in this study. Oligometastasis was defined as fewer than five recurrences in a single organ. Patients were classified as having oligometastatic recurrence (OLR) or polymetastatic recurrence (PLR). Patients were further classified into four subgroups according to lesion progression: persistent oligorecurrence (PER-OLR), converted polyrecurrence (CON-PLR), induced oligorecurrence (IND-OLR), and persistent polyrecurrence (PER-PLR). We analyzed the relationship between the recurrence patterns and prognosis according to the progression of oligometastatic lesions. OLR was identified in 58 (46%) of 126 patients with recurrence. Patients with OLR had a significantly better prognosis than those with PLR (P < 0.0001). A further subgroup analysis revealed that patients who underwent IND-OLR had a similar prognosis to those who underwent PER-OLR. This study suggests that OLR is a prognostic factor after recurrence following resection of ESCC and that PLR can be converted to OLR by therapeutic intervention to achieve a long-term survival.