Tumor protein p53 binding protein (53BP1) is a 1972 residue long protein with a critical role in DNA damage repair. 53BP1 forms large, phase-separated nuclear bodies at sites of DNA double strand breaks. An oligomerization domain and two LC8 binding sites have been shown to be crucial for robust recruitment of 53BP1 to sites of DNA damage. LC8 is a small, dimeric hub protein which is known to dimerize intrinsically disordered client proteins. We recently discovered a third LC8 binding site in 53BP1 using a free online algorithm, LC8Pred, and this new site may alter interpretations of previous experiments in which 53BP1 was mutated to eliminate LC8 binding. We provide a biophysical characterization of the LC8 binding domain and oligomerization domains of 53BP1, focusing on differences in LC8 binding in the presence and absence of the oligomerization domain. We also find that the oligomerization domain of 53BP1 is trimeric—a first for LC8 binding clients. Isothermal titration calorimetry shows divergent binding mechanisms for different LC8 binding sites in 53BP1 in the presence and absence of the oligomerization domain, highlighting the importance of multivalency in 53BP1-LC8 interactions.