TOPIC: Imaging TYPE: Medical Student/Resident Case Reports INTRODUCTION: Dyspnea is defined as a patient's experience of his or her own breathlessness and is a powerful clue of an underlying pathology that may not be confined to the cardiopulmonary system. Gastrointestinal pathology is often an overlooked etiology of intrathoracic pathology and an unusual cause of respiratory symptoms (1). Hiatal hernias rarely present as dyspnea and are usually seen on plain chest radiograph as a retrocardiac opacity with an air fluid level (2,3). We report a case of left hemithorax opacification suspicious for a large loculated pleural effusion that in fact represented diaphragmatic herniation of abdominal contents. CASE PRESENTATION: A 97-year-old female with history of hiatal hernia and gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) presented to the hospital from an assisted living facility with dyspnea and confusion. As part of her evaluation, a chest X-ray (CXR) was obtained which showed a large left pleural effusion with associated incomplete collapse of the left lung (Figure 1). This was further investigated with computed tomography (CT) of her chest which showed a large, complex left-sided pleural effusion with associated collapse (Figure 2A) for which pulmonary service was asked to evaluate the patient. On review of previous studies, an oral-contrast abdominal and chest CT was done which showed abdominal contents above the diaphragm in the left thoracic cavity - confirming the presence of a large paraesophageal hiatal hernia (Figure 2B). No surgical intervention was offered nor was additional work-up needed for the abnormality observed on CT. DISCUSSION: Although hiatal hernias are common, with studies suggesting a prevalence of 50% of people 50 years or older (3), it rarely results in dyspnea, becoming symptomatic only in the presence of significant hernia size resulting in left atrial compression and/or decreased pulmonary compliance (3). This case highlights the importance of independent evaluation and review of imaging, especially if the "official" read does not seem to fit the clinical scenario. Likewise, longitudinal comparison with previous imaging is paramount to establishing the chronicity and nature of encountered pathology and should be done consistently to avoid incorrect diagnoses and potentially unnecessary procedures. CONCLUSIONS: Herniation of abdominal contents in the form of hiatal hernia is common in adults but rarely manifests as dyspnea. Diagnosis is established on the basis of specific symptoms in combination with radiographic findings. If imaging is misinterpreted, as was done initially in this case, appropriate treatment may be delayed and unwarranted procedures may be performed. Clinicians must interpret imaging independently accounting for clinical context and perform longitudinal assessment of prior studies to arrive at the correct diagnosis. REFERENCE #1: Prevalence of Dyspnea Among Hospitalized Patients at the Time of Admission. Jennifer P. Stevens, MD, MS, Tenzin Dechen, MS, Richard Schwartzstein, MD, Carl O'Donnell, ScD, Kathy Baker, RN, MSN, Michael D. Howell, MD, MPH, and Robert B. Banzett, PhD. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management. 2018 July; Vol. 56 No. 1: 15-22. REFERENCE #2: Hiatal Hernia: An unusual presentation of dyspnea. Seied Ahmad Mirdamadi, MD, Mahfar Arasteh, MD. N Am J Med Sci. 2010 Aug; 2(8): 395-396. REFERENCE #3: When the Stomach Rules the Heart: Dyspnea as a Neglected Complication of a Large Hiatal Hernia. Thomas H. Marwick, MBBS, PhD. Journal of the Americal College of Cardiology. 2011 October 58 (15): 1635-1636. DISCLOSURES: No relevant relationships by Christine Girard, source=Web Response No relevant relationships by Daniel Kotok, source=Web Response
Read full abstract