Forceful headbutting clashes occur every year during the rut for most bovids. Bighorn sheep (Ovis aries) and muskoxen (Ovibos moschatus) show extreme examples of this behavior, exerting head-to-head forces of over 3000 N. Their large horns are commonly thought to protect them from these impacts, to the extent of inspiring football equipment. However, whether their horns or thick skull successfully prevent brain trauma has not been investigated experimentally until now. The aim of our research is to study anatomical adaptations of animals with extreme behaviors in order to provide solutions to human problems. A better understanding of brain injury, or the prevention thereof in these animals, will provide insight for the reduction of traumatic brain injury (TBI) in humans at a time where clinical translation of experimental therapies is limited. In a preliminary study, we found early signs of chronic brain injury in a male muskox using immunohistochemistry staining for abnormally phosphorylated tau and high-resolution MRI. Applying the same techniques to bighorn sheep is complicated, as their tau expression is not well understood. Despite the possibility of brain trauma, the capacity to survive such forceful impacts and continue to thrive is not negligible. Thus, alongside the brain, we simultaneously investigated anatomical properties of the skull of both species, using an ontogenetic series of skulls and skull CT scans, respectively. The skulls of six muskoxen and six bighorn sheep were bisected to describe the braincase in detail for the first time. The differences between juveniles, adults, males, and females were especially important because of the sexually dimorphic nature of headbutting behavior. In muskoxen for example, the male skull is approximately 300% larger than that of the female. Although the large pneumatized sinuses of species such as the bighorn sheep have been suspected to contribute to force mitigation, they may simply be a scaffolding supporting the rapid growth of large horns. Furthermore, bighorn sheep horn cores are proven to have similar biomechanical properties to that of regular cortical bone. These findings indicate that the horns and sinuses may not be the main means of protection and we instead hypothesize that the brain's position within the braincase, its connection to meninges, and the rough inner-surface of the cranium are what allow these animals to survive such extreme forces. Anatomical descriptions will serve to increase our knowledge of bovid inner-cranial anatomy all while aiming to determine which anatomical features are most likely to protect bovid brains, which in turn could be translated to humans as a preventive strategy for TBI.
Read full abstract